On June 3, 2020

Impossible odds

By Gary Salmon

At first I didn’t even notice it nestled under the root flare of a big white pine stump cut several years ago. But the idea of a white pine seedling growing while being sheltered by its larger former self was too much to ignore. The little 2-inch tall white pine seedling germinated in the rotted wood from the pine trunk with little in organic matter but loose enough for a naked seed to at least get started.

It barely had a bundle of needles, five per bunch which identifies it by species. Like all white pine seeds (about 30,000 of them per pound) they have to come in contact with bare soil to grow and that’s where the difficulty starts. A white pine cone has two seeds per scale with a good cone crop every 2-5 years. Even before they leave the security of the cone the losses start. Squirrels cut them off and eat/store the seeds for winter as do several other mammals and birds.

Although wind borne and large in number with a germination rate of nearly 90% it is where they land that is key: a soil medium loose enough to allow them to lay under or on this strata over the winter.

Think about it.

Most wind borne seed lands on rock, or logs, or tree branches, or leaf litter, or water, or other impervious surfaces and do not survive. There is little actual exposed soil available for seeds to grow unless the soil was abandoned agricultural land, burned over, or otherwise disturbed. And then there is the sunshine, a commodity needed in abundance. Both must be present for a pine to germinate, overcome nearby vegetation by fast growth, and get to the sapling stage. White pine is so shade intolerant that it cannot grow under a canopy of its siblings where you might expect it to.

As to the future of my little seedling. It did at least get started from seed to seedling finding a spot soft enough to lay down primitive roots. But before it gets large enough for me to age it by counting each layer of side branches grown each year (white pine is one of the few trees that can be aged by whorl counting), it has to overcome a sterile soil mix, little available water, and the physical closeness of it’s larger stump shelter. A tree from one seed in a million but stranger things have happened.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

What if Vt’s housing crisis was a bridge?

April 23, 2025
On June 11, 2023, a tanker truck full of gasoline was traveling on Philadelphia’s Interstate 95 when it approached an off-ramp and overturned. The truck spilled 2,500 gallons of gasoline mixed with ethanol, which then ignited. Philadelphia Fire Captain Boyd reported, “Every square foot of the underpass was nothing but flame.” The fire ran into…

Green Up Day is May 3

April 23, 2025
When I went to Kent Pond the other week to launch for the first time, I was all stoked to enjoy the beauty of nature right from the boat launch. But the joke was on me because right behind the treasured bench was a bag of unattended—you guessed it—dog poop. How nice of someone to…

A puzzling situation

April 23, 2025
Over the years, I’ve told my son at least a thousand times, “It’s a puzzle, figure it out.” Borne of necessity, I used the phrase to promote action in my child, given that his first response to difficulty, traditionally, was to either give up or make a half-hearted attempt. Because of his laissez-faire attitude, my…

Mating rituals of muskrats

April 23, 2025
Muskrat mating is so sensational that songs have been written about it. Fans of 1970s pop music might be familiar with a certain ballad, written by Willis Alan Ramsey and popularized by bands like America and Captain & Tennille, about two anthropomorphic muskrats falling in love. Though you probably won’t find breeding muskrats “nibblin’ on…