On December 21, 2016

Organic—Is it worth it?

By Kyle Finneron

Organic is a term that I’m sure most people have heard by now. In the early days of organic foods there were only a few vegetables that were available in an organic capacity, but now the list has grown to an excessive level. As we speak I am drinking organic coffee, my dog has organic dog food and the majority of the foods in my cabinets and refrigerator are organic. Want organic bed sheets and pillowcases? Not a problem; they exist. This got me thinking—what really is organic?
According to the website organic.org, organic is defined as “… produce and other ingredients grown without the use of pesticides, synthetic fertilizers, sewage sludge, genetically modified organisms, or ionizing radiation. Animals that produce meat, poultry, eggs, and dairy products do not take antibiotics or growth hormones.”
Sewage sludge? I understand where most fertilizer comes from but the thought of any form of sludge near my dinner plate makes the hair on the back of my neck stand up.
After reading a description like that, one might think that everything that goes into/onto their body should be organic.
There is, however, one problem for most people: the price. Organic products do seem to be at a premium compared to conventionally grown produce. The question is, why?
This is a common economic thought process behind organic food: organic is better for you; better is more expensive; thus, organic is more expensive. But, does everything have to be organic? I hear a lot of people telling me how hard it is to eat [organically] healthy because it is so expensive. Anyone that has walked through the produce section has surely wondered, “Why are the organic peppers $4 more per package than the conventionally-grown counterpart?” This can even draw out some strong emotions. I once saw a grown man give a package of peppers the finger when he looked at their price tag. I wish I was kidding.
The question becomes, with so many food choices out there, do I have to buy everything organic, or are some items fine when grown by conventional means? Luckily, there is a list that has been created by the Environmental Working Group which refers to the “Dirty Dozen” and “Clean Fifteen.” It’s a list of the 12 most contaminated foods with pesticides, as well as the 15 least contaminated foods.
This does not mean that if you have an item from the dirty dozen list to throw it out or not eat it. Real, whole food is still better for you than a highly-processed sugar or fat-filled snack. This list will hopefully help you navigate the produce section and identify the products that might be worth the extra price.
In closing, remember the words of Michael Pollan: “Eat food, not too much, mostly plants.” Happy eating.

Dirty dozen
(most contaminated with pesticides)
strawberries
apples
nectarines
peaches
celery
grapes
cherries
spinach
tomatoes
sweet bell peppers (Don’t give it the finger and pay the premium!)
cherry tomatoes
cucumbers

Clean fifteen
(least contaminated with pesticides)
avocados
sweet corn*
pineapple
cabbage
sweet peas frozen
onions
asparagus
mangos
papayas*
kiwi
eggplant
honeydew melon
grapefruit
cantaloupe
cauliflower

*some corn and papayas sold in the U.S. use GE Seedstock. Go organic if you want to avoid GE Seedstock.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

The great unfurling

June 18, 2025
We have just about come to the end of the great unfurling. That moment in time when the trees have grown and budded and leafed and have stretched as far as they can go. They are bigger, brighter, and fuller than they were last year, and you can feel the canopy thickening. The woods are…

Calling for a friend

June 18, 2025
We’ve all received those dreaded phone calls— the ones where the person’s voice on the other end suggests something dire is coming. The greatest example of this for me was the night I got the call that my father had died.  It happened during my senior year of college around 9 p.m. Upon returning from…

The dapper sparrow of the underbrush: Eastern towhee 

June 18, 2025
From forest edges and thickets on late spring mornings in the Northeast comes what sounds like an exhortation from across the pond: Drink your tea! This is not a British parent’s plea but rather the song of a chunky, colorful sparrow: the eastern towhee.  The eastern towhee (Pipilo erythrophthalmus, or “red-eyed chipper”) is found in…

‘The Shrouds’ is another erotic techno-thriller from David Cronenberg 

June 18, 2025
Humans have difficulty dealing with death. Canadian auteur David Cronenberg is not immune to this affliction. His wife of nearly 40 years passed away in 2017. Cronenberg said on record that “The Shrouds” is one measure of his grieving process. We all handle grief differently. Maybe not quite as different as Cronenberg or his protagonist,…