On July 20, 2022

Letter writer doesn’t understand Second Amendment

Dear Editor,

This is in response to George De Luna’s letter of July 12. In it, he repeatedly refers to “God-given” rights. Passing over his total lack of evidence for the existence of any supernatural being, let’s look to see how many times this term occurs in the Constitution. Hmmm, well no “God-given,” but maybe it’s just “God.” Well, none of that either.

De Luna writes “…your God-given right to [defend yourself]. The founders made it quite clear we can do that legally with a firearm. The wording is clear, unequivocal, and deliberate.”

Here is the Second Amendment: “A well-regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed.”

What could be clearer than that? It is missing the parts about self-defense and God…

But for Mr. De Luna, the truth of a statement is shown by the confidence with which he says it, and with the number of adjectives he uses. I do agree that we have the right to defend ourselves.

De Luna concludes that not only do you have a right to own guns, you have the duty to own them. I guess the founders say that in the constitution. Let’s see, hmmm. Maybe the Declaration of Independence. Oh well. In any case, I’m not an anti-gun fanatic. I shot guns on the family farm, and an M16 (fully automatic) in basic training in early 1969. And, I do own a gun — a Shennefelt rifle made by my ancestor Nicholas in the mid-1800s in Western Pennsylvania. Hope that suffices.

In his April 19 letter, De Luna lectured us on how women should obey his absurd religious convictions and that somehow, despite all the evidence, Pres. Bonespurs won the 2020 election, and his vile rule should be imposed on all of us. Now he wants to make us buy guns. I’ve survived 76 years without one and without fear, despite living in several states, the country, New York City, and even New Jersey. But I guess De Luna needs the big man in the White House, the big man in the sky, and a gun in his pocket. Not all of us do.

It’s interesting that De Luna deposits this in a Vermont paper rather than one in his own state. Is he afraid of the effect his nonsense might have on his business in the very liberal state of New Jersey? Kem Phillips,
Cavendish

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Homeless legislation encounters Sturm and Drang

May 7, 2025
A cohort of Vermont’s social service providers has embarked on an editorial campaign challenging the House’s recent legislation that would disrupt the status quo of homeless services funding administration. Angus Chaney, executive director of Rutland’s Homeless Prevention Center (HPC), appears to be the author of the editorial and is joined by about a dozen fellow…

From incarceration to community care: Reinvest in health, justice, common good

May 7, 2025
By Brian Cina Editor’s note: Brian Cina is a VermontState Representative for Chittenden-15. Cina is a clinical social worker with a full-time therapy practice and is a part-time crisis clinician. State-sanctioned punishment and violence perpetuate harm under the guise of accountability, justice, and public safety. Since 2017, Governor Phil Scott has pushed for new prisons…

Tech, nature are out of synch

May 7, 2025
Dear Editor, I have been thinking since Earth Day about modern technology and our environment and how much they are out of touch with each other.  Last summer, my wife and I traveled to Fairbanks, Alaska, for a wedding. While there, we went to the Museum of the North at the University of Alaska-Fairbanks. It…

Under one roof: Vermont or bust!

May 7, 2025
Dear Editor, We’re heading north and so excited. We’re moving full time to Vermont! For decades we’ve been snow birds, like my parents, spending half the year in Bradenton, Florida. But now our Florida house is up for sale — a 1929 Spanish Mediterranean brimming with beauty and charm. A young family we hope will…