On December 28, 2023

A glib take on a tired classic

 

Dear Editor,

While real estate prices are absurd — and home-buying and renting are an impossibility for many — laying blame for homelessness at the feet of people of means who move here from elsewhere is a trite and glib iteration of a Vermont Old Guard classic: “It wasn’t a problem until these people showed up.”

In his recent commentary, Bob Stannard harkens back to the folksy golden days when people supposedly hardly noticed socio-economic disparity — and certainly didn’t judge those less fortunate — and then amuses us by judging those more fortunate. A favorite sport in this state. He rues second homes in places like Stowe as a key aspect of the societal ailment that’s evidenced by people living in cars, tents and encampments.

I’m 40 years old and have heard throughout my life any number of old men gripe about the state of things on account of “Them.” The people who come from elsewhere.  It’s a tired line, and one that absolves those of us who see ourselves as “Native” of responsibility. It cements us as a group with a soft moral constitution who would rather lay blame and fawn over an idealized past than acknowledge that our corner of the world has changed. Not necessarily for the better, but not categorically for the worse.

Perhaps by not explicitly blaming Flatlanders, Stannard believes he lends his lazy argument credibility and that its implicit inclusion throughout his commentary will go unnoticed.  

Vermont’s xenophobia persists.

Alan Rawls

North Ferrisburgh

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Clean Heat Standard is just too expensive

December 26, 2024
Dear Editor, In last week’s article by James Kent, “House Republicans mull a plan to repeal the environmental Clean Heat Standard,” he incorrectly suggests the cost impact on heating fuel is only a couple of cents per gallon, citing a report by Energy Futures. We wish that were true, but unfortunately it is not. Act…

Affordability and a healthy environment can coexist

December 26, 2024
Dear Editor, As 2024 draws to a close, I resolve to start the new year with optimism and determination to protect what we care about. Our shared connection to the natural world lies at the heart of Vermont’s identity. We love the beauty and bounty of our state. We also know that a healthy environment…

Let’s welcome asylum seekers

December 26, 2024
Dear Editor, Picture a young woman, nine months pregnant, compelled by forces beyond her control to leave home and make an arduous journey with her betrothed to a foreign land, unsure of their welcome there. At this time of year, most of us raised in the Christian tradition would pretty immediately, if unconsciously, imagine this…

Balancing public interests in wildlife policy

December 26, 2024
Dear Editor, Let’s look at the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Board and Department and tell me if it needs modernizing. And for those unaware, the Board is a 14-member volunteer group comprising hunters, trappers, hound hunters, and anglers from every county. The Board makes public policy decisions on our shared public wildlife without fair representation…