On April 20, 2022

‘Cow’ documentary shows unethical realities of food production on a Vermont farm

Dear Editor,

Despite dwindling numbers of dairy farms,Vermont continues to be the largest dairy producer in New England and dairy is the most profitable sector of the state’s agricultural economy. Tourists flock to Vermont to savor its bucolic splendor and we are grateful to the farmers who toil to preserve its rural character. We should also take a moment to consider the animals who live on these picturesque farms. Andrea Arnold’s new documentary “Cow” tells the life story of a dairy cow named “Luma”with no dialogue. The viewer observes Luma’s life on a dairy farm from the animal’s perspective. In one piercing scene, Luma’s face stares straight into the camera as she bellows for her calf who was taken away from her moments after birth. All of Luma’s babies will be ripped from her at birth and she will bellow helplessly each time. It is plain to the viewer that Luma is an emotional being, capable of experiencing grief and despondency over the routine dairy farming practice of separating cow from calf. The effect is profoundly moving and forces us to grapple with how our food is produced. The documentary does not preach or seek to shock, but rather asks us to see dairy cows as mothers and sentient beings who must endure so many routine indignities and casual cruelties during their short lives. Albert Schweitzer said, “Think occasionally of the suffering of which you spare yourself the sight.” “Cow” asks us to do just that.

Lucy Goodrum, Reading

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

VTF&W board a self-serving loop

September 18, 2024
Dear Editor, Editor’s note: The following was submitted to the Mountain Times as an open letter to Governor Scott. To quote Yogi Berra, “It’s deja vu all over again.” Once again, there are members of the Vermont Fish & Wildlife Board whose terms have expired, this time as of last February, yet they are still…

Vote Radonis for state rep

September 18, 2024
Dear Editor, I’m writing to support of Steve Radonis’s bid for Windsor’s 5th district state rep. And as a 74-year-old Connecticut resident and life-long (so far!) registered Democrat, that’s pretty much all I can do because out-of-state homeowners in Vermont cannot vote in local elections, one of a few issues on which Radonis and I…

Lies masquerading as opinion

September 18, 2024
Dear Editor, In his Aug. 28, 2024, Mountain Times letter “Response to Republican choice,” Mr. George de Luna states rather oddly that “Most of his [Trump’s] ‘lies’ are exaggerations but are in the same direction of the truth.”  Actual journalists disagree.  In their Jan. 24, 2021, Washington Post article “Trump’s false or misleading claims total…

A note of thanks

September 18, 2024
Dear Editor, Thank you to so many who celebrated the life of Erica Hurd last month on the Pittsfield Green.  Like her, it was beautiful in so many ways. She brought us together again to share our love, stories, food, music, tears and laughter. And lots of purple. The support of so many — family,…