On May 6, 2021

People can change

Dear Editor,

One of my favorite Vermont sayings, “You can’t get there from here,” applies to the double standard our state has when it comes to our policy on criminal justice reforms. Our progressive state, known for social reforms, known for breaking barriers, is far ahead of other states, I don’t doubt the truth of that. Vermont should take a look at how we are treating the inmate population.

There are, fortunately, many protections for the victims of crimes, and there should be. People affected by crime need to have supports and a voice in the criminal justice process. If, however, we continue to fail to provide those who have committed the crimes an equal opportunity to repair the harm they’ve committed, then we create more victims, unsafe communities, and fail to provide those who’ve committed the crimes an opportunity to succeed.

Let’s begin with the reality that April was “Second Chance” month. The way our state recognized this important opportunity to give offenders in our state a second chance was by S.18, “An Act relating to limiting earned good time sentence reductions for offenders convicted of certain crimes,” now a law, which gives those with “non-violent crimes” an opportunity for a reduction based on their behaviors. A good premise, that fails to take into account that people who commit a crime that is considered violent should be provided with the same opportunity. 

The underlying sentiment is that if one commits a crime that is violent, they will be placed in the category of beyond redemption. The Vermont government has created a class of offenders, much like that of India’s caste system. There are now those who can be redeemed, and provided opportunities, while at the same time there are the “untouchables,” those who are beyond redemption. 

No different from S.18, is S.7 “An act related to expanding access to expungement and sealing of criminal history records.” Unless, of course, you have committed a violent crime. In the event one is at their lowest point and/or makes a drug or alcohol-induced decision, the state of Vermont will not allow people to be eligible for expungements —again reinforcing the stigma of crime and not allowing people to grow from the experience and become productive members of our communities. Really no different from the public sex offender registry, which has been proven ineffective and a costly boondoggle.

Attorney General Donovan has made it a mission, while in office, to support these initiatives, while paying little or no attention to state’s attorneys in Vermont who are actively pursuing remedies and solutions to decrease incarceration through legal means. These same state’s attorneys are promoting criminal justice reforms only to be overruled by the Attorney General, who appears to follow an old adage:“If you always do what you’ve always done, you’ll always get what you’ve got,” which fails to take into account that people evolve, and can change.

In the end I am reminded of what a family friend and one time Senator from Bennington, James B. Gibney,  said, “If I make you a promise and I break it, I’ll make you another.” The promise that our state leaders are breaking is outlined in Article 1 of the Vermont Constitution, “That all persons are born equally free and independent, and have certain natural, inherent, and unalienable rights, amongst which are… obtaining happiness and safety.”

Timothy R. Burgess,

Waterville

Burgess is a former inmate of the Vermont Dept. of corrections. He is now a prisoner advocate and mediator.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Before school budget talks turn to slashing expenses

November 20, 2024
By Angelo Lynn Editor’s note: Angelo Lynn is the owner and publisher of the Addison Independent, a sister paper of the Mountain Times.  With 2024-25 education property tax rate hikes well into double digits last year, it’s little doubt school boards will be primed for holding costs to a minimum for their upcoming budgets. Already…

Keep pets safe this trapping season

November 20, 2024
Dear Editor, The recreational trapping season in Vermont begins on the fourth Saturday of October each year and lasts through March 31st. For some animals, like otters and beavers, this season lasts for five long months. There are no limits on the number of animals a trapper may kill or on the number of traps…

‘You belong here’

November 20, 2024
Dear Editor, A Latin teacher from junior high school once told me that the word “trivia” comes from roots, meaning three roads. The idea was that people would come together where roads meet to exchange small pieces of information — trivia. Here in Vermont, we certainly swap news on street corners, and I’ve had my…

Welcoming new Americans will strengthen Vt’s economy

November 20, 2024
By Mike Pieciak, Vermont State Treasurer As Vermont’s Treasurer, I am committed to growing Vermont’s economy and building a more inclusive future for our state. To keep our economy on a positive track, we must address our demographic challenges and grow our workforce. I regularly hear from employers about the difficulty of finding workers —…