On April 30, 2025
Editorials

Migrant workers’ arrest should shock Vt. dairy farmers

By Angelo Lynn

Editor’s note: Angelo Lynn is the publisher of the Addison Independent, a sister publication of the Mountain Times.

When federal agents from Trump’s “big-brother” government descended on the Pleasant Valley Farms dairy in Franklin County this past Monday, they arrested eight migrant workers in their homes and placed them immediately into the Northwest State Correctional Facility in Swanton, where they are currently held.

According to the group Migrant Justice, the arrests constituted the largest single immigration enforcement action against farmworkers in recent Vermont history.

The farm, which is Vermont’s largest with 3,000-plus cows on 10,000 acres, is owned by Mark and Amanda St. Pierre. Their son Jamie is part of the management team, along with his wife, the Olympic runner Elle St. Pierre.

In a story reported by Seven Days, Amanda St. Pierre said they had not been told why their employees were being detained, and said the employees “were hired following the federal and state employment requirements. We remain supportive of our employees and appreciative of the valuable role they play in our community preforming essential work on our farm.”

The arrests should send shock waves through Vermont’s farm community, which employs about 850 year-round migrant farmworkers — all crucial to the state’s dairy industry.

Thomas D. Holman, Trump’s “border czar” and a North Country native, stressed that the raid on the farm “wasn’t a raid,” but rather the outcome of a pursuit of two other people who had crossed the border by foot and walked onto the farm. Holman said the migrant workers were arrested during a search of a house on the farm in pursuit of the two walkers. One of the two suspected walkers was also arrested. Holman has previously pledged to support dairy farms and their employment of migrant workers.

The Migrant Justice community isn’t accepting excuses, and neither should Vermonters. “What happened… was an injustice,” said Cristian Santos, a member of the group’s Farmworker Coordinating Committee.

Gov. Phil Scott added his voice saying “migrant workers are an essential part of our communities,” and called on Congress and Trump to pass immigration reform that would make it easier for migrant workers to work here without being “forced to live in the shadows.” 

He’s right, of course, but it’s unlikely to happen with this Republican Congress and with this president — not until massive waves of people stand up against them.

Dairy farmers should join other farmers upset by federal cuts to nutrition programs — and others upset with cuts to a host of programs and services that harm Vermonters — and let this Republican Congress know they’ll be losing their votes if they don’t restrain the rogue at the head of their party and speak out against his destructive policies.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Missing the mark on ed reform

June 11, 2025
Dear Editor, If and when the governor and Legislature agree on something they call “transformational educational reform,” it’s unlikely to be what most people expected or wanted. Vermonters won’t see the property tax relief they were hoping for because changes to the funding system will be a few years off. Instead, the first sign of…

H.454: Another tax hike disguised as funding reform

June 11, 2025
By Ryan Heraty Editor’s note: Ryan Heraty is the superintendent of the Lamoille South Supervisory Union and a doctoral student at the University of Vermont, studying education finance and public policy. Most Vermonters agree our state is facing an affordability crisis, yet few suggest the solution is to raise taxes on low and middle-income Vermonters.…

CHIP is a game changer

June 11, 2025
Dear Editor, Vermont just took a bold, historic step toward solving one of the most urgent issues facing our state: the lack of affordable and attainable homes for Vermonters of all income levels and backgrounds. With the passage of the Community Housing Infrastructure Program (CHIP) during the 2025 legislative session, the state now has a…

Want lower taxes? Then let’s reform education the smart way

June 11, 2025
By Bryce Sammel Editor’s note: Bryce Sammel, of Barnard, previously served on and chaired both the Barnard Academy and Mountain Views school boards. Vermonters are rightly worried about taxes. With rising costs across the board, including property taxes, health care and energy bills, many residents, especially those without school-aged children, are asking a fair question:…