On October 23, 2024
Opinions

Tackling Vermont’s housing shortage

By John Vogel

Editor’s note: John Vogel of Williston is a retired professor at the Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth College.

The shortage and cost of housing in Vermont is a problem we can solve. Other states are showing us how. 

In Minneapolis, apartment rents have declined by 4% over the last five years, according to an NBC News story, while they have soared an average of 22% across the United States. In Texas, total development costs for new apartments are half of what they are in Vermont (based on my discussions with real estate companies). That’s why developers can charge $800 a month in rent for new apartments and still make a profit. 

How did these places do it? 

In Minneapolis, they reduced rent and decreased homelessness by creating incentives for new construction. Between 2017-2022, Minneapolis expanded its housing stock by 12%. The key driver behind this growth spurt was apartments. A full 87% of these new homes were in buildings with 20+ units. As economists will tell you, increasing supply generally causes rent to stabilize — and sometimes even decline. 

To spur this new construction, the Minneapolis City Council adopted three key policies: 

Minimum parking requirements for new developments were eliminated. 

Taller buildings in commercial corridors were encouraged, particularly near transit and along commercial corridors.

Minimum building heights were required in high density zones.  

Minneapolis made it cheaper and easier to build apartments. Politicians withstood scathing criticism from loud NIMBY voices — and developers responded. 

Regulatory improvements are not enough. Minnesota also backed up this program with financial resources, including a $1 billion omnibus housing bill. This legislation, which passed in May 2023, provides funding for housing infrastructure as well as the development of workforce housing and other housing priorities. 

What can we learn from Texas? Why does development cost twice as much in Vermont? 

Texas has some natural advantages — land is plentiful, flat and generally less expensive. Also, the influx of new families means developers can build large complexes, and benefit from economies of scale. 

There is also a less obvious but significant reason: the number of immigrants who work in construction. According to the American Immigration Council, only 17% of the Texas population are immigrants, but they make up 40% percent of the construction workforce. Also, according to the Council, a whopping 39.7 percent of all entrepreneurs in the building industry in Texas are immigrants. 

These newcomers bring skills or a willingness to learn, innovation and a strong work ethic. 

Vermont is short on people with construction skills, which is a key factor in the high price and slow pace of new developments in Vermont. 

Is there a way to draw fresh faces to Vermont and welcome them with opportunity? Can we partner with organizations that help to settle new Americans? Reach across borders? Provide training or sponsor apprenticeship opportunities? Should we begin that conversation? 

In June 2023, the Vermont Legislature and Gov. Phil Scott took a significant step toward increasing the supply of housing. The HOME Act (Act S.100) modified parking requirements for priority housing and offered a 40% density bonus for affordable housing in areas with public water and sewer. 

In 2024, the Legislature took further action and passed H.687 — which modernized Act 250 — smoothing the way for more housing projects and less duplicate regulation. 

This bold legislation is clearly a step in the right direction. But, if Vermont really wants to increase its supply of housing, it needs additional legislative action. 

It also needs to press forward in creative and potentially controversial ways. 

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Two members, including chair, resign from the Commission on the Future of Public Education in Vermont

June 25, 2025
By Corey McDonald/VTDigger Two members of the Commission on the Future of Public Education in Vermont, including the commission’s chair, announced last week they would be resigning, saying they no longer believed their efforts would make any impact. Meagan Roy, the chair of the commission, and Nicole Mace, the former representative of the Vermont School Boards…

The public reality of private schools

June 25, 2025
Dear Editor, In their June 13 commentary, “The Achilles’ heel of Vermont education reform,” the Friends of Vermont Public Education state that, “Since the early 1990s, we have been operating two parallel educational systems — public and private.” The organization calls upon the Vermont Legislature to create “one unified educational system,” arguing that, “The current…

Vt plastic bag use dropped 91% following ban, researchers find

June 25, 2025
In the midst of 2020 Covid measures, another change took place in Vermont: A law went into effect banning businesses from offering plastic bags to customers, with paper bags only available for a fee. A 2023 analysis of a survey of hundreds of Vermonters found the law appeared to have worked. Plastic bag use in…

Plan to manage 72,000 acres of the Telephone Gap project is finalized

June 25, 2025
Staff report The U.S. Forest Service issued its final plan for managing 72,000 acres of public and private land on June 16. The proposed Telephone Gap Integrated Resource Project area is located on the Green Mountain National Forest (GMNF) within the towns of Brandon, Chittenden, Goshen, Killington, Mendon, Pittsfield, Pittsford, and Stockbridge. “The Telephone Gap project is…