On April 13, 2022

More public discussion needed on Prop. 5

Dear Editor, 

Amending the Vermont Constitution is a long and arduous process, taking four affirmative votes in the legislature (two in each chamber) over two biennia, followed by a statewide popular vote, which, for Proposal 5, will take place this November. The purpose of all this is to ensure that the public has time to engage and understand what the proposed amendment is all about. 

However, Proposal 5’s journey has taken place almost entirely under Covid-19 lockdowns and restrictions on public gatherings. It has not received the kind of public scrutiny it needs and deserves. Most Vermonters don’t know what they will be voting on this fall, nor are most aware that they will be casting a vote to change our constitution at all. 

Proposal 5 reads in its entirety:  “That an individual’s right to personal reproductive autonomy is central to the liberty and dignity to determine one’s own life course and shall not be denied or infringed unless justified by a compelling State interest achieved by the least restrictive means.”

Some key points that Vermonters need to understand regarding Proposal 5 are:

  • Although this amendment is being sold as protection for women’s/abortion rights, it does not mention “women,”“abortion” or “pregnancy.” This is a highly problematic legal “bait and switch.”
  • By conferring an equal right to “personal reproductive autonomy” on men as well as women, Proposal 5 could actually undermine a woman’s right to choose to end or carry a pregnancy to term if that decision is in conflict with the biological father’s equally protected right to reproduce. A spokesperson for the ACLU testified that such conflicts would need to be resolved in court. This is a step back for abortion rights.
  • The vagueness in the language opens the door to multiple unintended consequences, such as state-sanctioned eugenics in the form of genetically modified “designer babies, rendering unconstitutional age of consent laws (e.g., possibly legalizing pedophilia), and undermining parental rights and responsibilities in regard to their children’s sexual health.
  • Local public panel discussions critical to have before Vermonters vote in November, or 45 days earlier if they cast an early ballot. 

Vermonters for Good Government would be happy to partner with local media outlets to further these types of discussions.  If you are interested in working with us, please contact: Matthew Strong, the executive director at Matthew@Vermonters
forgoodgovernment.org.

Matthew Strong, executive director, Vermonters For Good Government

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

If Vt wants a future of abundance, we must choose to build

April 23, 2025
By Miro Weinberger Editor’s note: Weinberger is currently the executive chair of Let’s Build Homes. He was raised in Hartland and served as mayor of Burlington from 2012-2024. If you’ve turned on a podcast, watched a late-night show, or scrolled social media in the past month, you’ve probably heard something about “Abundance,” the new book…

Vermont School Board Asso. supports H.454 ed plan

April 23, 2025
Dear Editor, VSBA supports the bill as a more thoughtful and phased approach than Governor Scott’s rushed, five district proposal. Grounded in a more realistic timeline: H.454 is the most grounded and actionable proposal developed during the 2025 session. It acknowledges the operational realities education leaders face every day. The implementation timeline is more manageable…

Vote Bill Vines for Killington Select Board

April 23, 2025
Dear Editor, At the special election on May 28, I am running for the 2-year seat on the Killington Select Board. An incredibly diverse group of people call Killington home; my partner Mary Furlong and I included. After years of renting a ski house, we purchased our first Killington home in 1995. In 1997 we…

The real enemy isn’t fear, it’s how we let it divide us

April 23, 2025
By Stanley McChrystal Editor’s Note: Stanley McChrystal, who is retired from the Army, is the former commander of U.S. and International Security Assistance Forces in Afghanistan and the former commander of Joint Special Operations Command. He is the author of the forthcoming book “On Character: Choices That Define a Life.” This commentary was first published…