On February 16, 2022

Drafters of Prop. 5 messed up

Dear Editor,

Proposal 5 is a proposed amendment to the Vermont State Constitution that its supporters say is necessary to protect a woman’s right to an abortion. Unfortunately, it is becoming apparent that the wording of Proposal 5 is so convoluted and vague that it might actually have the opposite impact on a woman’s right to choose and control her own body.

Proposal 5 is being called the “Reproductive Liberty Amendment,” not the “Right to an Abortion” amendment, or the “Women’s Reproductive Rights” amendment because its language does not mention, at all, abortion or women. If you are a woman concerned with abortion rights, this is a problem. Potentially a big one.

Here’s how Proposal 5 reads, “”That an individual’s right to personal reproductive autonomy is central to the liberty and dignity to determine one’s own life course and shall not be denied or infringed unless justified by a compelling State interest achieved by the least restrictive means.”

This new “right to personal reproductive autonomy,” as opposed to a clear right to an abortion, would apply equally to men as to women, and this could have some significant unintended consequences for women’s rights. The words “abortion” and “woman” are not included in Prop.5, contrary to how it is promoted.

The Vermont House Human Services Committee recently took testimony from an ACLU spokesperson, Indi Schoenherr. She was asked, “What happens if a man’s right to personal reproductive autonomy conflicts with a woman’s regarding the same unborn child? Whose right prevails, and on what legal, constitutional basis under Proposal 5.”

When Schoenherr struggled to answer, committee chair Anne Pugh jumped in and said, “When rights are in conflict, we go to court. And that is the role of the courts to decide, or a judge, or however that is. So, what I’m asking is would I be correct in responding to [the question] to say what you are presenting is a conflict of rights. And where historically this country has gone when there is a conflict of rights is we go to court. Would I be correct in that response?”

To that Schoenherr said, “Yes, that is the correct response.”

And that’s the problem.

Under Roe v. Wade a woman has a right to an abortion during the first trimester of pregnancy that is not in conflict with anyone else’s rights. Under proposal 5, that “right” would potentially be in conflict with the father’s newly minted right to personal reproductive autonomy, and, if so, the woman would have to go to court to sort out that conflict. And, in reading the language of Proposal 5, the woman’s burden might be having to prove there is a “compelling state interest” to justify her abortion.

Although this may not be what the authors of Proposal 5 intended, it is what the women of Vermont will have to live with for a long time if Proposal 5 is ultimately approved and becomes a part of our state constitution. Just so you know.

Annisa Lamberton, Middletown Springs

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Before school budget talks turn to slashing expenses

November 20, 2024
By Angelo Lynn Editor’s note: Angelo Lynn is the owner and publisher of the Addison Independent, a sister paper of the Mountain Times.  With 2024-25 education property tax rate hikes well into double digits last year, it’s little doubt school boards will be primed for holding costs to a minimum for their upcoming budgets. Already…

Keep pets safe this trapping season

November 20, 2024
Dear Editor, The recreational trapping season in Vermont begins on the fourth Saturday of October each year and lasts through March 31st. For some animals, like otters and beavers, this season lasts for five long months. There are no limits on the number of animals a trapper may kill or on the number of traps…

‘You belong here’

November 20, 2024
Dear Editor, A Latin teacher from junior high school once told me that the word “trivia” comes from roots, meaning three roads. The idea was that people would come together where roads meet to exchange small pieces of information — trivia. Here in Vermont, we certainly swap news on street corners, and I’ve had my…

Welcoming new Americans will strengthen Vt’s economy

November 20, 2024
By Mike Pieciak, Vermont State Treasurer As Vermont’s Treasurer, I am committed to growing Vermont’s economy and building a more inclusive future for our state. To keep our economy on a positive track, we must address our demographic challenges and grow our workforce. I regularly hear from employers about the difficulty of finding workers —…