On May 19, 2021

The policing we deserve

Dear Editor,

Two Mondays ago, on my way to work I stopped at the end of Spellman Terrace to take my turn onto South Main Street when a terrifying scene unfolded in front of me. A young man, in obvious distress, slumped against a white van parked on South Main Street. Even though he was nearly doubled over I could see he was holding a gun. To his left, two uniformed Rutland City police officers, guns drawn, retreated to defensive positions between parked cars. As chair of the Rutland City Police Commission, I paused at the intersection unsure of what, if anything, I should do at that exact moment. Thankfully, over the next 20 seconds Sgt. Mosher arrived in a second cruiser to block the south end of the scene while two more Rutland City officers and a state policeman arrived to block the north end. 

As I slowly drove away a feeling of horror fell over me; there are 1,000 ways this situation ends in violence and only a few where it does not.

I have read countless editorials on the state of policing in America. Most, at some point, conclude that policing comes down to individual relationships and trust within the community. How would the situation in New York in July 2014 been different if Officer Pantaleo knew Eric Garner prior to arriving on the scene? Would the murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis in May 2020 have occurred if Derek Chauvin realized they had worked together at the same nightclub? To paraphrase an interview I saw with James Craig, Chief of the Detroit Police Department; the middle of a crisis is a poor time to start building relationships.

About an hour later, with trepidation, I called Chief Kilcullen to ask about the scene I had witnessed and the safety of all involved. To my absolute joy he told me that as the situation evolved and the identity of the armed man became known, Sergeant Jon Dickerson of our Community Response Team jumped on the radio. He had a relationship with this man through his work in the community. He radioed officers, raced to the scene, established a dialogue with the armed man and eventually convinced him to drop the gun and exit the situation peacefully. As he was led away, the man told arresting officers that the only reason he surrendered was because he trusted Jon. There are 1,000 ways this situation ends in violence and only a few where it does not.

This is the policing we deserve. 

Sergeant Jon Dickerson embodies everything the Rutland City Police Department has committed to, trained for, and delivered on a daily basis in our community. I am tired of the media’s obsession on a negative narrative around policing. When our commitment to community policing pays off, when our police force demonstrates the behaviors we expect and deserve, when interpersonal relationships are in place prior to a crisis as they were in this situation, we need to celebrate it and I have never been more proud of our Rutland City Police Department.

Sean Sargeant, Chair, Rutland City Police Commission

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Before school budget talks turn to slashing expenses

November 20, 2024
By Angelo Lynn Editor’s note: Angelo Lynn is the owner and publisher of the Addison Independent, a sister paper of the Mountain Times.  With 2024-25 education property tax rate hikes well into double digits last year, it’s little doubt school boards will be primed for holding costs to a minimum for their upcoming budgets. Already…

Keep pets safe this trapping season

November 20, 2024
Dear Editor, The recreational trapping season in Vermont begins on the fourth Saturday of October each year and lasts through March 31st. For some animals, like otters and beavers, this season lasts for five long months. There are no limits on the number of animals a trapper may kill or on the number of traps…

‘You belong here’

November 20, 2024
Dear Editor, A Latin teacher from junior high school once told me that the word “trivia” comes from roots, meaning three roads. The idea was that people would come together where roads meet to exchange small pieces of information — trivia. Here in Vermont, we certainly swap news on street corners, and I’ve had my…

Welcoming new Americans will strengthen Vt’s economy

November 20, 2024
By Mike Pieciak, Vermont State Treasurer As Vermont’s Treasurer, I am committed to growing Vermont’s economy and building a more inclusive future for our state. To keep our economy on a positive track, we must address our demographic challenges and grow our workforce. I regularly hear from employers about the difficulty of finding workers —…