On February 5, 2020

Climate change isn’t the real crisis

Dear Editor,

Windsor County Sen. Dick McCormack (D-Bethel) recently opined about the climate crisis and how government must implement “a worthy and non-negotiable response” to this crisis.

What is this “worthy and non-negotiable” response?  In the summer of 2018, the “new” Act 250 commission was busy crafting this response. The commission’s purpose was to realign Act 250 in order to address the climate crisis. The following legislators and senators served on this commission: McCormack, Rep. Amy Sheldon, Sen. Chris Pearson, Sen. Brian Campion, former Rep. David L. Dean and Rep. Paul Lefebvre.

The  worst idea to come out of this commission was to “encourage” rural Vermonters to move into a compact urban center. The idea being that rural Vermonters create too much carbon, therefore our lifestyles are undesirable and must be eliminated.

“Keep in mind that Vermont covers an area of less than 10,000 square miles. Vermont’s geographic area occupies 5/1000 of 1% of the planet’s surface. Vermont has less than 1/100th of 1 percent of the world’s population. Our population is around 620,000. The energy consumption of Vermont is the lowest of all 50 states. Since 1990 Vermont’s forests have removed more carbon dioxide than Vermonters have produced emissions.”

The commission’s use of the word “encouraging” is the nice, green-washed way of saying “forcing.”

Government is power, Legislation is force.  The law is force.  This is why special interest groups spend so much time and money lobbying the government. History is full of examples of governments using force in violation of human rights, which include the right of property ownership.

Hitler “encouraged” Jews into ghettos and concentration camps. Stalin “encouraged” the relocation of millions of his fellow citizens into the gulags of Siberia.  The Chinese government, as I write this, is “encouraging” the relocation of 250 million of its rural citizens into high rise apartments in cities.  This could never happen in the United States, right?…Wrong!  The U.S. government has a poor track record of “encouraging” its citizens into compact urban centers, internment camps or reservations. From the 1830s until the 1870s, Native Americans were forcibly moved off their ancestral lands onto reservations. During World War II, Franklin Roosevelt, a progressive Democrat, relocated Japanese Americans into internment camps. During the Vietnam War, the U.S. government forced rural Vietnamese citizens into strategic hamlets.  Politicians through ignorance or outright deception or simple ruthlessness justify these actions by using the bogeyman of an imminent “crisis.”

The constitution of the United States is supposed to protect our rights to property and liberty. “America’s Founders understood clearly that private property is the foundation not only of prosperity but freedom itself. Thus, through common law, state law, and the Constitution, they protected property rights-the rights of people to acquire, use and dispose of property freely,” according to Roger Pilon of the Cato Institute.

McCormack claims to be a staunch civil libertarian as well as an expert on the constitution.  I am told he carries a copy in his pocket and reads it before each legislative session is convened. I believe this. I think he knows exactly what it says and what it doesn’t say, to the last letter.

He  just doesn’t care.

A common denominator for all these dispossessed people I have mentioned, is that they were disarmed of their weapons. Their right to self defense was legislatively removed.

It should come as little surprise that McCormack has a voting record that proves he is an enthusiastic advocate of restricting the right to bear arms.

Stu Lindberg,

Cavendish

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Study reveals flaws with “Best Practices” for trapping

July 24, 2024
Dear Editor, A new peer reviewed paper, “Best Management Practices for Furbearer Trapping Derived from Poor and Misleading Science,” was recently published and debunks Vermont Fish & Wildlife’s  attempt to convince the public that “Best Management Practices” for trapping result in more humane trapping practices. They don’t. In 2022 there was a bill to ban leghold traps—a straight-forward bill that…

Criminalization is not a solution to homelessness

July 24, 2024
By Frank Knaack and Falko Schilling Editor’s note: This commentary is by Frank Knaack, executive director of the Housing and Homelessness Alliance of Vermont, and Falko Schilling, advocacy director of the ACLU of Vermont. Homelessness in Vermont is at its highest level on record, as more people struggle to afford sky high-rents and housing costs. According…

Open Primaries: Free andfair elections?

July 24, 2024
Dear Editor, I don’t know where the idea of open primaries came from or the history of how they began in Vermont. I was originally from Connecticut and when you registered to vote you had to declare your party affiliation. Only if you were registered in a political party, could you take part in that…

The arc of agingand leadership

July 24, 2024
By Bill Schubart Like a good novel, our lives have a narrative arc, during which we are actively participating in and relevant to our world. We are born, rise slowly into sensual consciousness and gradually process what we see and feel. Our juvenile perceptions gradually become knowledge, and, if all goes well, that knowledge binds…