If farmworkers earned more, could we afford what they
By Michael G. Harpold
Income inequality and the minimum wage have become national
buzzwords, but noticeably absent from the conversation is the
economic plight of American farmworkers.
"Almost half the people laboring in our fields are U.S. citizens
and legally authorized immigrants, but Americans tend to think
they're all illegals, so they accept the situation," says Michael
Harpold, a 35-year veteran of the U.S. Immigration and
Naturalization Service (INS) and author of the new book "Jumping
the Line," a realistic and dramatic portrayal of an illegal
immigrant and a Mexican-American farmworker family.
"We're terrified food prices would skyrocket - a fear perpetuated
by some in the agriculture industry - if we don't keep the lid on
Ask the farmers and they'll say, "I'm paying far more than the
minimum wage," and that's often true, Harpold says. "What's not
said is that the work is seasonal, so the laborer works only 100
days a year. His annual income falls far below the poverty
Non-supervisory farmworkers earned an average hourly wage of $10.80
in 2012, well over the federal minimum wage of $7.25, according to
the Farm Labor Survey conducted by the National Agricultural
The same survey found nearly half did not have year-long
The impact of extreme poverty on farmworkers - more than 2 million,
including undocumented immigrants - affects all of us.
"Imagine how well local businesses would do if these workers had
enough money to dine in their restaurants, visit their shops and
pay for their services," Harpold says. "Imagine the benefits to us
all if their children could stay in one school for a full year, and
if they could aspire to careers beyond the fields."
If we could stem the flow of cheap labor crossing illegally into
our country, and if we relied only on legal immigrants and citizen
workers, wages would rise, he says.
What would that look like for the rest of us? Harpold says it's not
the frightening picture some stakeholders paint.
• We'd pay less than $1 more a month for produce.
According to University of California at Davis agriculture
economist Phillip Martin, a 40 percent increase in farmworker wages
would translate to a 2 to 3 percent increase in retail prices for
fruits and vegetables. The trade-off is less economic cost borne by
government to support impoverished farmworker families.
• We would curtail the creation of more
substandard jobs in agriculture. Guest worker programs - where
foreign workers are invited to work on U.S. farms - perpetuate
pockets of rural poverty by keeping labor costs low, encouraging
the creation of more low-skilled, low-income jobs in the area.
Pending House and Senate legislation proposes to allow in hundreds
of thousands of new guest workers. If enacted, this will continue
the vicious circle of poverty and inadequate education trapping
immigrant farmworker families striving to assimilate in our
society. Children of immigrants living in two-parent families are
twice as likely to be poor (44 percent versus 22 percent) as the
children of natives. Two-thirds of farmworker children who live
with both parents remain poor, according to "The New Rural Poverty"
by Philip Martin, Michael Fix & J. Edward Taylor.
• Growers will (as they have in the past)
innovate to make up for fewer workers. When forced to compete for
labor such as occurred when the United States stopped the
importation of Mexican farmworkers in 1964, growers innovate,
mechanizing harvests, planning crop cycles to coincide with worker
availability, and providing housing or transportation. Then,
growers signed contracts with farm workers union president Cesar
Chavez containing hire back clauses for migratory workers, raising
wages and providing healthcare. The brief golden age for American
farmworkers ended after a decade and a half because the U.S. failed
to stop illegal immigration.
As a nation, Harpold says, we cannot talk about income inequality
and minimum wages without including immigration in the
"It's all tied together," he says. "When we address immigration, we
will also address persistent poverty for a large segment of the
A common sense way to improve community dental
By Senator Kevin Mullin (R-Rutland)
There is clear medical evidence linking good oral health - healthy
teeth and gums and quality preventive and restorative care - to
overall health and lower healthcare costs. That's why I've offered
legislation to establish a network of Community Dental Health
Coordinators (CDHCs) to provide more Vermonters with the dental
care they need and deserve.
My bill, S.235, asks that the Commissioner of Health, in
consultation with Vermont's dentists and dental care advocates,
create a CDHC pilot program. Including CDHCs as members of regional
dental teams can significantly improve access to high quality and
affordable dental care.
CHDCs improve oral health in underserved communities through dental
health education, disease prevention, and helping patients navigate
an often-daunting public health system to receive the care they
need from dentists. Most CDHCs come from the same communities where
they work, helping eliminate cultural, educational and language
barriers that can be roadblocks to dental care.
By focusing on oral health education and disease prevention, CDHCs
empower people to manage their own oral health. When disease
requires treatment, the CDHC links patients with dentists who can
provide that treatment, and can help obtain other services-such as
child care or transportation-that patients may need in order to
The strength of this program is in its ability to provide a near
immediate solution to our state's oral health problems. The CDHC
training program is short and they connect people who need dental
care with dentists in need of patients.
We are approaching the CDHC as a pilot program because we should
not be experimenting with healthcare delivery models before they
can be proven to work in Vermont. This approach will allow us to
confirm this model will lower costs and improve access in a
meaningful and measureable way, while giving us the flexibility to
Thankfully, we are not starting from scratch. In 2006, the American
Dental Association (ADA) developed and implemented an effective
CDHC model for several states. Last year, the Vermont State Dental
Society piloted a six-week program in which a CDHC worked in
Winooski to expand oral health education by visiting community
centers, nursing homes, daycare centers and schools. The dental
education provided by the CDHC connected more Vermonters directly
with tools to maintain their oral health and receive quality
The CDHC delivered results by increasing the number of patients
receiving care in Winooski, especially by members of the community
that had been underserved. Now, we're poised to take the next
In the future, with carefully crafted policies and regulation,
CDHCs could also provide basic clinical care. The ultimate goal of
this proposal is to provide every Vermonter access to care from a
dentist, so they can maintain their dental and overall health. This
is particularly important when you consider that many dental
procedures are surgical and medically significant.
In my view, Vermonters have as much a right to see a dentist for
their dental care as they do to see a primary care provider. Our
public policy shouldn't shortchange us by creating unnecessary
layers between patients and our doctors.
My bill contains specific guidance for the Department of Health to
develop a program that will, in fact, expand access to high quality
and affordable dental health care in our communities. It also
ensures that our dentists have a seat at the table because no one
knows more about ensuring the dental health than the dentists who
are trained to provide this highly specialized medical care.
This legislation establishes a common sense path for addressing the
oral health challenges Vermont faces in a collaborative manner that
puts patients first and will get real results. I urge my colleagues
in the Legislature, and fellow Vermonters, to support it.
Washington state 5th grader seeks Vermont
My name is Tovae I go to Conway School in Mount Vernon, WA. I have
gone from Kindergarten to 4th grade and now I found myself in 5th
grade. I have done many projects over the years, but I have never
done a project quite like this. I have thought a while and decided
that I should do the state that is not so popular, but is unique
and beautiful. I haven't heard much about your state, Vermont, but
the little facts I do know have amazed me and make me want to know
more about your state and it's historical events. Even if I do
study hard and get facts about your state I still won't know
I was hoping that your readers would send me artifacts, maybe your
state gem and food and postcards and pictures and fossils and
especially your state quarter to help with my report. I need these
items by April so I can use them to display on my table area. I
would not get an A+ or even a B or C without your help. Please help
me get a good grade on this project. Remember, only YOU can help me
get a good grade.
I already know that Vermont looks a lot like my state, Washington,
in the fall. The items that you give me can not be returned
especially the food. Please send the items to my school
Tovae D, Mrs. Talbert's Class
19710 State Route 534
Mount Vernon, WA 98274
Paid sick days allow workers to care for their
After several years of working at a minimum wage job I mustered up
the courage to apply for something better. The "something better" I
got was in a workforce with a union, and I was more than happy to
join it, even though I didn't pay attention to all the benefits it
had won for the workers.
About a year later, I was working, and my supervisor told me the
school nurse had called to say my son was sick and in the nurse's
office. Since my high school sicknesses had resulted in staying in
the nurse's office until the end of the school day, I thanked my
supervisor and continued to work. That was not the end of it
however. My supervisor said, "You know, you can take the rest of
the day off and take care of him; it's in the union
I was extremely surprised and quite grateful to be able to tend to
him. It gave both him and me peace of mind to know that I had a job
where people and families were just as important as the job. I was
making 75 cents an hour over minimum wage at the time; to have had
to take a half-day without pay would have been quite a dent in the
weekly budget. The workplace's paid sick days policy was a very
welcome help to my single-parent budget.
Chuck Gregory, Springfield, Vt.
Speaking out against child abuse
The latest apparent/alleged murder of a 2-year old girl in
Poultney by her stepfather has incensed me. The fact that she had
been subjected to previous abuse leads me to wonder why she had
been returned to her mother's custody, especially after warnings
from her mother's family members. In my humble opinion, DCF is
understaffed and undertrained. I realize that state budgeting is a
large part of this problem. One answer to these atrocities
happening is for everyone to be made aware of the signs of abuse.
Neighbors, family members, caregivers, grocery clerks - in other
words anyone who might come into contact with these abused and/or
neglected children should know what to look for. In order to do
this Prevent Child Abuse Vermont needs funding to train people to
go out into our schools, public forums, hospitals, etc. One half of
PCAVT's income comes from individuals like you and me,
organizations and businesses.
Educating our young adults in the schools on how to cope with the
pressures of parenting or babysitting for someone else's children
is another of the ways PCAVT strives to reduce the incidences of
abuse. This organization has done a tremendous job in lowering the
incidences of Shaken Baby Syndrome. Visit their website for more
facts and figures.
As 2012-2014 President of the General Federation of Women's Clubs
of Vermont I have taken on Prevent Child Abuse Vermont as my
administration's signature project. As concerned women we need to
get the word out to unprepared caregivers who become violent under
stress that their behavior will not be ignored or tolerated. We
cannot allow innocent little people to continue to be abused,
ignored, and/or neglected.
I implore you!
If this latest unnecessary death has touched you in any way,
please reach out and get involved or make a donation to PCAVT.
Share this letter with your family, friends and neighbors. Who
knows, the next victim may be someone you love.
Send your donations to:
Margaret (Midge)Tucker, GFWC VT President 2012-2014
Legislating prejudice: What I won't be doing on my
By Lee J. Kahrs
My wife Sarah and I will be celebrating our 10-year anniversary
this October, and we decided to mark the occasion with an epic road
trip through the Southwest. Sarah, a great lover of hiking and the
outdoors, has never been to the Grand Canyon, and I wanted to take
her there. We would fly into Las Vegas, pick up a campervan and
drive first to Zion National Park in Utah, then to the Grand
Canyon, then on to Santa Fe and Taos in New Mexico before heading
back across Arizona to Las Vegas.
On Feb. 20, I made camping reservations at the Grand Canyon. It
was the first step in concrete plans the trip, and the way it
worked out, we would be celebrating our actual anniversary, October
10, at the Grand Canyon.
It was exciting. For weeks, I have been poring over websites,
weighing options on campervan rentals, planning the route,
researching the state parks and campgrounds, planning a budget and
estimating how long we would be in each place.
But the same day I made those reservations, the Arizona
Legislature passed S.B. 1062, which re-defines and expands the
state's definition of "exercise of religion" and "state action" to
protect businesses, corporations and people from lawsuits after
denying services based on a sincere religious belief.
They have legislated prejudice.
In the bill, a person is described as "any individual,
association, partnership, corporation, church, religious assembly
or institution or other business organization."
So, if the governor signs the bill into law this week, any Arizona
business owner could legally refuse to do business with a gay
person if they claim that homosexuality goes against their
Brewer has until Saturday, March 1 to either sign the bill into
law or veto it. Based on her recent statements, it could go either
"I think anybody that owns a business can choose who they work
with or who they don't work with," Brewer said the day after the
bill was approved by the legislature. "But I don't know that it
needs to be statutory. In my life and in my businesses, if I don't
want to do business or if I don't want to deal with a particular
company or person or whatever, I'm not interested. That's America.
But the irony is that this bill restricts my freedom and my wife's
freedom if we chose to travel to Arizona because we are gay.
When we finally get to the Grand Canyon, the RV park where I made
the reservations could refuse to let us in based on their religious
beliefs, because we're gay.
When we stop at an Arizona truck stop, the owners could refuse to
sell us gas and snacks, because we're gay.
If we decide to get a motel room for a night to take a break from
the campervan, the motel owner could refuse to rent us a room,
because we're gay.
What's next, separate drinking fountains and lunch counters? This
smacks of the post- civil rights era in America, where blacks were
and still are subjected to prejudice. It's not right, not for any
Cathi Herrod, President of the Center for Arizona Policy, an
organization that supported the passing of the bill, says the bill
"protects the religious freedom of every Arizonan."
In a statement released Saturday, Feb. 22, Herrod said, "It's a
shame that we even need a bill like this in America. But growing
hostility against freedom in our nation, and the increasing use of
government to threaten and punish its own citizens, has made it
necessary. I urge Governor Brewer to send a clear message to the
country that in Arizona, everyone, regardless of their faith, will
be protected in Arizona by signing SB1062."
Herrod and other supporters cite recent lawsuits where business
owners have been sued for refusing to cater a gay wedding, or bake
a gay cake.
What is this, tit for tat? Granted, in the Bill of Rights there is
a provision for freedom of religion, but there is also a right to
freedom of expression. They are not mutually exclusive. I say they
are equally important, by the State of Arizona seems to
Frankly, despite what Gov. Brewer does, we will likely cancel our
trip through the Southwest and spend 10 days traveling the Pacific
Coast Highway in California. We will not spend a dime in Arizona,
and if hundred of thousands of gay people do the same, the Arizona
Department of Tourism will feel the pain.
But there is another layer to all of this. I think that federal
recognition of gay marriage has lulled people, gay and straight
alike, into complacency about gay rights. What the situation in
Arizona is doing is highlighting how far we still have to go.
Don't get me wrong. The fact that my own government recognizes my
marriage and my family is huge. We cried that day in June last
year. It was an enormous affirmation. Plus, I am now saving
thousands on health insurance.
But there is still a long list of places around the U.S., and
around the world, where gays and lesbians are not welcome. Marriage
means less if it's not fully recognized; if we can't in good
conscience honeymoon in Arizona, or Alabama, or Belize, or
Barbados? When I was looking at alternatives to Arizona, I realized
it was also a good idea to avoid Africa, Jamaica, Antigua,
Malaysia, Egypt, Trinidad and Tobago, St. Kitts, St. Lucia and the
That's O.K., I don't expect the whole world to change, yet.
However, I would like to travel freely within the confines of my
own country, without fear of prejudice, rejection and even physical
violence for who I am. We have a long row to hoe before that
becomes a reality, and Arizona just took us back 20 years.
Support Article 7, preserving our towns history at a
The purpose of Article 7 on the Killington ballot this Town
Meeting is to preserve the original Sherburne Library as a
historical town building.
The goal is to repurposes the building (most recently used as the
teen center) as a town historical museum. The uses could be
manifold including: A) Creating a permanent home to consolidate all
the historical artifacts, public and private, in a singular
location. B) Safeguarding and preserving all artifacts and make
them available for the public viewing. C) Creating a public space
for residents, students, tourist and for historical meetings and
lectures. D) Realigning the use of the building closer to its
originally intended use, but now as a library of
Some background information on the original Sherburne Library,
will perhaps help voters better understand its historical place in
Built in 1924 as the Sherburne-West Bridgewater School (a one-room
schoolhouse) volunteers moved the building to its present location
in 1961 where served as The Sherburne Library until 1999. Gail
Weymouth began her career as the Sherburne Librarian in this
building before the new library was build further down on River
Margaret Mowle, president of Sherburne Historians
Education finance reform needed, current funding system
inhibits economic growth
Editor's note: On Feb. 4, the Killington Selectboard sent the
following letter describing the adverse economic impact that Act 60
and 68 have had on the town since the "The Equal Educational
Opportunity Act" was passed in 1997. The Selectboard's letter
refers a report from Vermont Realtors that describes negative
consequences to their collective economic growth (The Mountain
Times, Feb. 6-12 "Realtor's report: Vt.'s school spending increases
unsustainable"). The Governor's response is below.
Dear Governor Shumlin,
On behalf of the citizens of the Town of Killington, we are
writing to address the recent report from the Vermont Realtors
describing Vermont's school spending policies as unsustainable.
This report echoes our stance and our experience in Killington, and
we agree with the finding that our current education finance system
is hurting our economy. We would like to take this opportunity to
urge you and our legislative leaders to begin the much-needed
process of reform.
Here in Killington we have established our own Strategic Plan for
economic development, created with years of input from our
residents, which focuses on making it Vermont's premier resort
community. One of the major goals in our Plan - and key to our
economic growth - is to increase tourism and year-round employment.
The current state of education funding in our state is serving as a
major challenge in the pursuit of this goal.
We believe Vermont's current education funding system is
inhibiting the growth of tourism communities like ours, which are
primary drivers in our state's economy.
By placing huge tax burdens on tourism towns like ours, Act 60 and
68 have dramatically limited businesses' ability to reinvest in
capital improvements and marketing and keep pace with their
competitors in other states.
For example, as a result of Act 60 and 68, Killington Resort saw a
345% increase in their property taxes from 1996 to 2012. As a
result the Resort had to defer improvements and marketing campaigns
they otherwise would have implemented to keep pace with competitive
resorts in other states like New Hampshire, Maine, Colorado,
California and Utah that don't have similar limitations. Increased
taxes have hindered the Resort's ability to maintain its
competitive edge in an already challenging industry.
We support equitable funding for schools, but our town's
contributions to fund education are currently inhibiting our
ability to grow economically. We need effective state systems in
place that offer residents a high quality of life while not
limiting essential growth. We advocate that the state seriously
reconsider its education funding policy.
Thank you for considering our perspective. We appreciate the
opportunity to voice our concerns and support for legislative
action. Should you have any questions, please do not hesitate to
contact Seth Webb, Town Manager at 802-422-3241 or via email at
The Killington Selectboard
J. Christopher Bianchi, Bernard Rome, Patty McGrath
To the members of the Killington
Thank you for contacting me and sharing your concerns about
education financing in Vermont. When it comes to ensuring that our
students have the best possible educational opportunities, we are
all in this together. Vermont has the best public schools in the
country, but it is impossible to ignore that we have among the
highest per pupil spending. It is a problem that deserves our
focus, which is why it is time for us to work together to find
solutions. Toward that end, I have worked with legislative
leadership to host an education finance symposium with tax experts
to examine possible changes to our frustratingly complex funding
mechanism and am committed to working with legislators, school
boards and superintendents to examine the spending side as well.
Taking action now will enable us to deliver an economically
sustainable 21st century education for all Vermont students.
I understand that we have a complex funding system and school
spending is not the only factor in property tax rates. While we are
proud to have what is arguably the most equitable system in the
country, it may be of such complexity that we have lost the
connection between what we get for what we spend. It is also very
hard to compare outcomes across districts. I will continue to work
with the legislature to consider the recommendations from the
education finance symposium and act if adjustments can be made to
simplify the system and help us in our mission to balance school
spending with the ability of Vermonters to pay.
Thank you again for your advocacy on this issue. I will keep your
thoughts in mind as we move forward.
Peter Shumlin, Governor
Vermont: A greenhouse for entrepreneurs
By Lisa Gosselin, Commissioner of the Department of Economic
"I'd love to move to Vermont and start a company here," the
snowboarder said with a sigh as we shared a chairlift at Stowe. I
sighed too: if I had a dollar for every time I heard that, my
mortgage would be paid.
That was nine years ago. Chris Kaiser, the snowboarder went on to
found Vermont Peanut Butter and this February 6, he will join a
panel discussion at the Capitol Plaza in Montpelier to celebrate
Vermont Entrepreneurship Week.
Kaiser moved to Stowe in 2005, started making peanut butter in his
kitchen. He moved operations into a plant in Waterbury in the
summer of 2011. Weeks later, the facility was wiped out by
Tropical Storm Irene. He rebuilt and is now selling his
all-natural nut butters internationally. Kaiser has joined the
ranks of hundreds who came here to ski and went on to build a
business here. He's become a Vermontrepreneur.
What makes a Vermontrepreneur? It's hard work, creativity,
resiliency, and a dedication to quality. It's also an ethic about
life and work and giving back. Vermontrepreneurs measure profits in
ways accountants could never calculate. Yet, the funny thing about
Vermont startups? According to the Census Bureau they are less
likely to fail than those in neighboring states.
"Vermont is very good at growing companies, we're like a
greenhouse," said Joe Fusco at an economic development workshop
held in late January. Fusco is vice-president at Casella Waste
Systems and an advisor at University of Vermont's new Sustainable
Entrepreneurship MBA program (SEMBA).
As a greenhouse state, what is Vermont doing to help grow its
Prizes for business plans: Recently LaunchVT announced it
was upping its 2014 business plan prize money to $25,000 (as well
as a suite of more than $45,000 in pro-bono services ranging from
legal to design work). And Strolling of the Heifers is looking to
offer nearly $90,000 across multiple categories for business
plans in the farm/food sector.
Innovative business-focused education: Such as Champlain
College offering gaming curricula and UVM's new Sustainable
Entrepreneurship MBA (SEMBA). State colleges such as Vermont
Technical College and Community College of Vermont are also
incredible resources for entrepreneurs and offer a suite of
programs -ranging from cheesemaking to sustainable design, SEO to
Technical and business assistance. Vermont's Small Business
Development Center and 12 Regional Development Corporations reach
out across the state advising start-ups and growing businesses
alike. The Vermont Sustainable Jobs Fund provides early stage
grants, loans and technical assistance to businesses that focus on
sustainably-produced goods and services and has been the driving
force behind Vermont's Farm-to-Plate strategic plan.
Venture funding for start-ups: Fresh Tracks Capital
(proud venture parent to Vermont Teddy Bear, Mophie, EatingWell)
has a new fund now and is once again interviewing its next
potential entrepreneurs in a truly Vermont manner: the annual Peak
Pitch event, to be held at Sugarbush on March 6, involves
"chairlift" pitches. And consider Vermont Center for Emerging
Technologies (VCET) in Middlebury and Burlington, which has been
named one of the top 11 university-based incubators in the
Access to big capital: For those entrepreneurs (such as Jay Peak's
Bill Stenger) who have had a big idea, Vermont's EB-5 program has
provided access to more than $300 million in capital for projects
around the state and generated thousands of jobs. In January, a
Mount Snow EB-5 project worth $52 million was approved.
Incentive programs with a proven track record: The
self-funded Vermont Employment Growth Incentive rewards companies
for growing businesses and jobs here and was named one of the
nation's top incentive programs by Good Jobs First. Since its
inception in 2007 this performance-based incentive has promised to
return more than $34 million to companies if they create jobs and
payroll and make capital investments. By 2016, this will have
generated more than 6,145 jobs with an average compensation of
$57,641, over $546 million in new capital investments in Vermont,
and a net return of $24 million to state coffers .
Workforce Training: Another program housed in the Department of
Economic Development, the Vermont Training Program, helps pay up to
50 percent of training costs for employees in qualified businesses.
In 2013, VTP helped train more than 3,850 Vermonters, who
then went on to improved their wages by 13 percent.
Help with government contracting: Vermont's Procurement Technical
Center (PTAC), has helped companies such as Simon Pearce (which
recently received a $5 million order for its fine stemware from US
embassies around the world) and Darn Tough socks and Revision
Eyewear provide products to our government. In fiscal year 2013,
Vermont companies working through PTAC received 519 contracts,
worth $73,22,954-that's nearly double last year's figure.
Export Assistance: The Department of Economic Development's
Vermont Global Trade Partnership (VGTP) allocated over $400,000 in
federal grant funds to small businesses to help offset the costs of
trade shows, export compliance training, and other international
market support. VGTP also provides international market data and
research to companies already exporting or those who seek to enter
the export market.
Mentoring: And lastly, we have businesses that reach out to help
their younger siblings. Recently Dinse Knapp McAndrews announced
that over the next month it is offering free lunchtime legal advice
to start-ups as part of its support of StartUpVT. IBM, which was a
key partner in launching StartUpVT, this hosting a suite of online
programs, events and classes for entrepreneurs this week, Feb.
We've already seen many of Vermont's seedling companies grow into
Ben & Jerry's, Burton, Green Mountain Coffee Roasters,
Dealer.com, Commonwealth Dairy, Biotek, Logic Supply, and others.
But if Vermont's greenhouse economy is to continue to be
successful, we need to find new ways to nurture the state's
businesses: start-ups, emerging and even established larger
As the Department of Economic Development works with partners
around the state to develop a Comprehensive Economic Development
Strategy, we are taking a hard look at what helps companies at all
stages of growth.
We welcome your suggestions and comments. As we know full well,
Vermontrepreneurs have no shortage of good ideas.
To learn more about how to start or grow a business in Vermont or
to submit ideas or comments, visit the Department of Economic
Development's website, ThinkVermont.com.
What is happening in Vermont
We have lots of things to think about here in Vermont. The
Vermont legislature is beginning to cause a crushing tax burden on
Vermont taxpayers. It seems, almost everyday, our elected
officials manage to disconnect on what is happening here in little
old Vermont. As our former governor, James Douglas, said in January
of 2010, we need to cut the drivers that push property taxes
higher every year. In his address he stated that in 1998 the
Vermont education fund was spending $400 million and at the time of
his speech it was running at a rate of $900 million.
Currently the 2013 spend rate was $1.4 billion. This is a
giant increase as about 80% of these increases are coming from
wages and benefits that are promoted by the NEA.
The student population is dwindling but the spending continues to
go up. It is agreed that a lot of this increase is coming from
"income sensitivity" where voters with lower incomes (under
$77,000) are protected against rising taxes.
Lately, reports on town budgets for education are getting louder
and louder - Springfield (loosing 23 teachers and aids),
Montpelier, Barre, Rutland Town are all concerned. Health care
and wages are bumping up this concern. People are moving away
because of fewer jobs with good pay. For example, why would
anyone want to buy or build a house just to pay more in property
taxes where the legislators are telling us to expect a 5% per year
increase in our property taxes in 2014 and 2015. With no new
construction to speak of, the builders, roofers, plumbers,
electricians, furniture salesmen, real estate brokers are moving
away and taking their kids with them. This helps to explain the
drop in student population and lower enrollment in our Vermont
schools. These increases are not responsible in light of
negative job growth, tepid economic growth, and low
Jim Douglas was right, it is no wonder that our k-12 system is
among the most expensive in the nation at more than $14,000 per
student per year.
Killington is proposing to raise the spending per student to
$16,300 up from $13,300 and this is to be voted on March 2,
2014. It might even get us into a penalty by the State.
How do you justify more spending with fewer students? Who
wants to build a new home just to pay more taxes when the taxes on
the current house or condominium is going up? It must be said aloud
most clearly that the Democrats are in control and Vermonters
need to change things. The legislators blame this on the taxpayers
who continue to vote larger budgets to schools( Shap Smith and
Why do we have to continue shouldering the school tax burden for
other towns that want to spend more?
Reality is a tough situation and Vermonters are in deeply
Edwin J.Fowler, Killington
Resort's uphill policy puts them ahead of the
The Uphill Snow Traveler's Organization (USTO) would like to send
a huge thank you to Killington resort management for their roll-out
of the new up hill skiing policy, and for their incredible efforts
to provide consistent first class skiing time and time again. USTO
has over 300 members from all over New England and we can tell you
that Killington's policy is the best around.
For USTO this is a great start and we are thankful to be able to
officially utilize the resorts snowmaking and grooming. We hope
everyone who enjoys uphill travel will take the time to get his or
her Killington uphill ski pass and read the policy. (The article in
last week's edition, Jan. 9-15, "Killington and Pico open mountains
to uphill travelers" provides a detailed overview; the policy can
be read at
Lets do the right thing, go in the right places and support our
Mike Miller, Killington resident and founding member of USTO
Animal abuse at Mountain Meadows Lodge
An abusive behavior is being perpetrated against Alex, the
Shetland Pony, at Mountain Meadows Lodge on Thundering Brook Rd in
Killington. Someone clandestinely trespasses onto the property
and trims the resident pony's bangs and mane without permission of
the owners or of the staff. The pony's bangs and mane in their long
natural state are essential to his warmth and comfort in these cold
winter months and it is appalling that someone would do such harm
to this sweet gentle trusting creature.
Anne and Bill Mercier ask that anyone with knowledge of this
illicit activity please come forward at once by calling 775-1010.
Anonymous tips are welcome.
A motion-sensing camera has captured images of visitors to the
barn and pasture at Mountain Meadows Lodge. These images will be
turned over to the police for a full investigation into this
matter. Please note: If you are the person responsible for
this, please call at once to make restitution before you are
identified and charged.
Bill & Anne Mercier, Innkeepers Mountain Meadows Lodge,
Blood drive reflects the best of Rutland
By Steve Costello
This note of appreciation is a little overdue, as I wanted to
await the final, official count from the Red Cross for the
Gift-of-Life Marathon, but I am writing to thank everyone involved
with the blood drive's record-breaking success. To say it was a
collaborative effort of the community would be to say Mount Everest
is a big hill.
Today (Jan. 2) we received the final, official, count from the Red
Cross, and as expected, the number increased a little bit from the
original, unofficial count of 2,337 pints.
The new national record is 2,350 pints!
Rutland and Rutland County - the whole state, really - should be
proud of the accomplishment, which almost seems inconceivable given
our size, knowing that thousands of families across the region have
benefited. We talk a lot about records and numbers to try to
motivate people to participate in the GOLM, and the psychological
value of success for the community is a big part of my motivation,
but in the end, the GOLM is all about saving lives.
This year's success could never have been achieved without an
incredible partnership between the Red Cross, WJJR, Castleton
College and Green Mountain Power, and hundreds of people within
these organizations. It has been a thrill to work with these teams
and key leaders, including Mike Kempesty, Terry Jaye, Dave Wolk and
Mary Powell, who each put their hearts and souls into the
I have had the opportunity to work with a lot of people over the
past 30 years, and this small group encompasses some of the best
people I've had the pleasure to work with. Each modeled a
tremendous amount of commitment, enthusiasm and hard work, much of
it behind the scenes, to make the GOLM a success.
But the entire community of Rutland, Rutland County and beyond,
made this happen:
· More than 600 students and adults
donated blood for the first time - almost twice as many as donated
in total at the first GOLM 11 years ago.
· More than 320 people donated their
time at the drive, and about 100 other volunteers helped with
· More than 2,800 presenting donors
turned out. (Some were deferred for various reasons.)
· More than 50 businesses and
organizations donated gift bag items or made other in-kind
· Staff from five organizations -
the Paramount Theatre, Elks Club, American Legion, Holiday Inn and
College of St. Joseph - committed themselves to the event and
turned their facilities over to the Red Cross for the day.
· Media outlets throughout the
region supported the drive through news coverage, public service
announcements and advertising discounts.
· Hundreds of businesses and about a
dozen schools gave staff and students time off from work or classes
to attend, and they often turned out in droves to donate
· Mayor Louras, Dave Allaire and
members of the Rutland City Board of Aldermen, other state and
local political leaders and local organizations too numerous to
mention, but ranging from the Chamber of Commerce to Rutland Young
Professionals, helped spread the word in a geometric progression
that ensured everyone was aware of the GOLM.
Every one of these people and organizations served like a thread
in a beautiful tapestry.
As in past years, when Rutland set New England records repeatedly
and came within a whisker of the national record, I've been asked
dozens of times how this community can do what it has done. I
think the answer, taken from the title of Art Jones' documentary
film about Rutland, is simple: There is something special in the
blood in this town.
Steve Costello works at Green Mountain Power and lives in Rutland
Franco family extends gratitude
I write this letter with the deepest gratitude to Chris and the
Killington Community from the entire Franco family. As I sit here
on this day, exactly eight weeks to the minute when my sister
Stephanie called me to tell me that Chris didn't make it, I am
still in disbelief. As devastated as we all were, our hearts were
warmed by the love and support that we all received from Chris's
Killington family, and although all of you were also in deep pain,
you reached out to us. It is difficult to put into words the impact
that your selfless generosity, of both money and spirit, had on our
family. The healing started when Steph, Buddy, Trish, Paul, Loi and
our daughter Elise took the trip to Vermont to gather Chris's
belongings. You were all so gracious, warm, and generous. It
continued when several of Chris's friends: Kell Heather, Kevin,
KoKo, and others made the trip for the wake and funeral. It meant
so much to have them with us. Little did we know that there was so
much more to come from the Killington community.
The healing we received from the Tribute will remain in our hearts
forever. Nothing prepared us for that amazing day! Our Mom was
determined to make the trip to meet all of you and to take part in
Chris's farewell celebration, and she not only made it but also
showed us her wealth of inner strength. The amazing love,
generosity, music, food, drink and friendship at The Foundry that
day helped all of us begin the process of letting Chris continue on
his eternal journey. And we are forever grateful to all of you for
your love and support.
So, in closing, we want to extend our loving gratitude to you,
Christopher Karr, for hosting the tribute; Sean and chefs,
Killington chefs, servers, bartenders; Mike, the musicians, Duane
for organizing the amazing talent; the sound engineer, DJ; the PR
staff and production staff; Jess Gabeler, for her beautiful tribute
slide show and photography; the media who helped spread the word,
Chris's friends who spoke at the tribute, Dave Hoffenberg for
posting tribute video on YouTube; Bobby, for everything he did,
especially for helping make it possible for us to spread Chris's
ashes on his beloved mountain, and the entire Killington community
for being a part of Chris's life and for being
part of this special day.
With love and gratitude,
The Franco Family
Vt. Adaptive Ski and Sports reflects on a successful
year and looks forward, thanks to community support
Many in our extended community have supported Vermont Adaptive Ski
and Sports this year because they know how sports and recreation
can change the lives of people with disabilities, they've inspired
by those around them who give their time and talent to be
outstanding instructors and volunteers, and they believe sports
offers a place where there truly are no boundaries.
It's been a great year for Vermont Adaptive: the 6th Annual United
States Association of Blind Athletes National Winter Festival; the
3rd Annual Long Trail Century Ride; the 25th Annual Vermont 100;
the 20th Annual Vermont 50; and the completion of the $1.3 million
Andrea Mead Lawrence Lodge, our new state headquarters located at
As we take stock in what we've accomplished, we're ever so
thankful for all the support we've received.
We have exciting plans for the upcoming year as we continue to
focus on the preservation of our strong foundation of excellent
programs, develop future facilities in Vermont as well as
opportunities for veterans, outdoor and environmental education,
outreach and advocacy. These are all important priorities for us;
for our participants; for our future.
We've already raised $22,000 of our $120,000 annual fundraising
goal. Between now and Oct. 31, 2014 help us to raise the rest and
help guarantee that Vermont Adaptive will continue to provide the
best year-round programming regardless of one's ability to pay,
equipment and trained volunteers for all of our athletes with
Thank you for being a part of the Vermont Adaptive family. What we
do would not be possible without you.
Erin Fernandez, executive director for Vermont Adaptive
Farmers on the front lines of climate
Stand against fracked gas pipeline
RANDOLPH - On Tuesday, Dec. 17, as people from all over the
state came together at the Vermont Working Landscape Summit, famers
at the center of Vermont's future took a strong stand against the
proposed fracked gas pipeline in Addison County.
Shumlin wants to know how to strengthen our state and our
land-based economy, he should listen to the people who are devoted
to our land. We farmers are on the front lines, and this
pipeline is the wrong choice for our land and our economy," said
Jim Ellefson of Stoney Lonesome Farm in Leicester.
Ellefson and almost 50 farmers from across the state signed an
open letter calling on Governor Shumlin to protect Vermont and on
the Public Service Board to deny a Certificate of Public Good for
the 70-mile pipeline extension from Colchester to Middlebury and
under Lake Champlain to International Paper in Ticonderoga,
As the Farmers' letter reads, "We are farmers, land owners and
stewards of the earth. We are the people that help keep Vermont
open and green. We support energy savings through renewable,
alternative sources, winterization and conservation. We do not
support taking Vermonters' land to build an infrastructure for
another fossil fuel."
Farmers are concerned that continuing to rely on fossil fuels is
an irresponsible choice. Massive new fracked gas infrastructure is
unnecessary because of the clean, local and efficient technologies
already available today.
Even as Vermont Gas Systems officials downplay the dangers of
fracking, the facts continue to mount. 82,000 fracking wells have
been drilled in the U.S. since 2005. Those wells have required
the use of 280 billion gallons of water and at least 2 billion
gallons of chemicals. They have resulted in the release of at
least 100 million metric tons of CO2-equivalent greenhouse gas
These farmers stand with many others across the state opposed to
the fracked gas pipeline, from the over 500 people in attendance at
the September public hearing to the almost 1,000 opposing comments
into the PSB, statewide opposition to this project continues to
As Cornwall farmer Mary Martin says, "This toxic trespass makes no
sense. We should be making decisions that are ecologically
sensible for all, not financially feasible for a few. Shumlin knows
better, and we deserve better."
Open letter to the Public Service Board and Governor
We are farmers, land owners and stewards of the earth. We
are the people that help keep Vermont open and green. We
support energy savings through renewable, alternative sources,
winterization and conservation.
We do not support taking land by eminent domain to build an
infrastructure for another fossil fuel. A fuel that VT Gas extracts
by fracking. The fracking process, of one gas well, typically uses
4 million gallons of water laced with 80 to 330 tons of chemicals,
many known to be toxic and carcinogenic.
In Governor Shumlin's own words:
"Very soon there is going to be a shortage of clean water on this
planet. Drinking water will be more valuable than oil or natural
gas. Human beings have survived for thousands of years without oil
or gas. We have never known humanity or life on this planet to
survive without clean water."
We cannot stand by and allow a Canadian company that has poisoned
their own people and water supplies in Alberta destroy our state
for their profit.
The environmental benefits are questionable. When examined from
"cradle to grave", fracked gas has been proven to be as polluting
as burning coal.* 70% of the gas is ear-marked for International
Paper. They have never been a good neighbor to us and they are one
of the worst polluters in the world.
We are fiercely and adamantly opposed to the use of eminent
domain. We also will not remain silent and watch a foreign company
take our or our neighbors' land by eminent domain to serve a NY
For all Vermonters and future generations we ask the Public
Service Board to deny Vermont Gas Systems a Certificate of Public
We are the Representatives of the land that we work and
RoweCrest Farm, Cornwall
Randy & Mary Martin
Candido's Farm, Cornwall
Jeremy & Caitlin Gildrien
Gildrien Farm, Middlebury
Nate & Jane Palmer
Laughing Tree Farm, Monkton
Rustan Swensen & Mazie Hescock
Hescock Farm, Shoreham
Ross Conrad & Alice Eckles
Dancing Bee, Middlebury
George Gross & Barbara Wilson
Solar Haven Farm, Shoreham
Harwood Farm, Addison
Paul & Doris Seiler
Old Wooster Farm, Shoreham
Lorenzo & Amy Quesnel
Perry Brook Farm, Shoreham
David & Eunice Van Vleck
Barney & Dee Hodges
Sunrise Orchard, Cornwall
Pete's Greens, Craftsbury
Arethusa Collective Farm, Burlington
Jim & Brian & Florence Gill
Little Hogback Farm, Monkton, Bristol
Crazy Acres, Panton
Robert & Polly Maguire
Brian & Patti Wilson
Morningside Farm, Shoreham
Karen & Jon Folger
Pinewoods Farm, West Pawlet
Elmer Farm, Middlebury
John P Falk
Neshobe Farm, Brandon
Amy & Dave Todisco
Hartshorn Farm, Waitsfield
Stan & Mary Pratt
Happy Valley Orchard, Middlebury
R.W. & Cy Tall
Doug & Tammy Atwood
Atwood Orchards, Shoreham
Eric & Mary Skovsted
Joe's Brook Farm, Barnet
Henry & Tata Harper
Julius Kingdom Farm, Shoreham
Your Farm Stand, Charlotte
Ten Stones Chicken Cooperative, Charlotte
Matt Burke & Tanya Srolovitz
Bloomfield Farm, Charlotte
Deirdre Holmes MA,HHC
Plan it Healthier, Charlotte
Annie Claghorn & Caitlin Fox
Taconic End Farm, Leicester
Brian Titus & Fran Recchia
Woods Edge Farm, Greensboro
CHD Farm, New Haven
Home Farm, Orwell
Rowe Farm, Cornwall
Lissy and Bill Heminway
Heminway Farm, Shoreham
Green Mountain Hounds, Charlotte
Oak Meadow Farm, Shoreham
Jim Ellefson & Leslie Wright
Stoney Lonesome Farm, Leicester
James Maroney & Suki Fredericks
Boundbrook Farm, Vergennes
City, GOLM have grown together
By Steve Costello
In less than two weeks, the greater Rutland community has the
opportunity to do something truly remarkable - help save thousands
of lives while putting its best foot forward for all to see.
The Gift-of-Life Marathon, Rutland's annual celebration of
community and goodwill, is expected to collect somewhere in the
vicinity of 2,000 units of blood on Dec. 17. Maybe a little more.
Maybe a little less. Maybe a national record. Maybe not.
While breaking the record would be great - and I sincerely believe
it's possible - I know two things will happen regardless: The
hundreds of donors who turn out will affect thousands of lives, and
Rutland will make an enormous statement about itself.
The Rutland that will host the GOLM this year is not the one that
hosted the first drive, and the people who will donate blood or
volunteer time are not the same either. Some who attend this year
were there for the first one, no doubt, but the community and the
people who live here have changed considerably since the first
Eleven years ago, the Paramount had reopened and hosted the GOLM,
but the theater struggled to stay open, much of downtown was
barren, empty storefronts casting a pall, and many accepted the
image foisted on Rutland by others. "Rut Vegas" wasn't just a
derisive term, it epitomized how many here and elsewhere thought of
In those days, there didn't seem like a lot of hope here; I even
told an interviewer I thought Rutland needed the blood drive, which
quickly started setting state and regional records, as an annual
reminder that the community can do great things.
Fast forward to today. The Paramount is flourishing, with
world-class entertainment and community events virtually every
week. Phenomenal new restaurants dot the downtown, along with
new stores and service businesses few would have imagined in
Rutland a decade ago. Empty storefronts have become the
exception. And the blood drive has expanded to five sites and
a goal about six times larger than the first year's
The blood drive certainly isn't the driver of all that is good in
Rutland, but somehow its fortunes and those of the city have moved
along on more or less parallel tracks, both growing, finding
various levels of success, often surprisingly, and then reaching
for greater heights. The common denominator is the people,
who have rallied around the city just as they have rallied around
the blood drive, with passion and compassion.
Pride in Rutland - both here and across the state - is growing by
the day. You can feel it in the coffee shops, the
restaurants, the barbershops and City Hall, and you can feel it in
when you talk to folks in Burlington, Montpelier and communities
Rutland is making a new name for itself as a thriving, resilient
and innovative community, and on Dec. 17, I'm growing increasingly
confident it will make a name for itself among the most generous
and kindhearted communities in America. I urge your readers to be a
part of this extraordinary day by volunteering or making an
Steve Costello is vice president of generation and innovation
at Green Mountain Power, which along with Castleton College and
WJJR sponsors the Gift-of-Life Marathon.
Killington Selectmen seek to clarify misinformation
about new Winter Sand Policy
Due to the significant amount of misinformation about the town's
new Winter Sand Policy, we are writing to clarify the policy and
address the misinformation. Contrary to much discussion, the
Killington town will continue to provide sand to
residents. Additionally, commercial contractors may continue
to use the sand to serve residents.
Since the 1970s the Town of Killington has provided residents sand
("winter sand") to use on their driveways in the winter. To do
this, in the past, the town has allowed residents to take winter
sand from the large sand pile used by the highway staff for winter
road maintenance. Increasing liability concerns and costs
prompted the town to revise its distribution method. The
policy below (posted on www.killingtontown.com) outlines a new
distribution policy to comply with insurance regulations, ensure
the safety of town residents and help control costs.
The town of Killington will provide residents sand in the
wintertime ("winter sand") to use on their properties in
Killington. The sand is to be used only in the town of
To distribute the sand, the town will create a pile for residents
outside the town garage gate from approximately Nov. 15 to April
The town will not load or supply any shovels for the loading of
sand. Distribution will be limited to a reasonable amount of
sand per trip.
The Highway and Facilities Department will work to replenish the
pile as needed, however, the Department's first priority will be to
maintain the roads.
The public is not permitted to enter the town garage yard without
We adopted this policy on Sept. 17, 2013.
If you have further questions about this issue, please attend one
of our next meetings or send an email to
firstname.lastname@example.org. We meet next on Dec. 3 and
Dec. 10 at 7:30 p.m. at the town offices.
Killington Board of Selectmen: Chris Bianchi, Bernie Rome, Patty
Giving blood saves lives, and could earn Rutland a
Please accept this letter of encouragement for all of the people
of Rutland County to join in this year's Gift of Life Marathon
blood drawing. If you didn't already know, this is not an
"ordinary" event. Rutland has the distinction of having challenged
- and in some cases defeated - the largest blood drives in the
nation against the likes of Boston, MA, St. Louis, MO, Manchester,
NH and others.
We garnered enough attention to have a documentary movie made
about us by famous New York Movie Producer Art Jones. His
production of "The Blood in this Town" ... our town, Rutland,
Vt.... has been shown around the world as a testament to what a
small community with a big heart can do.
This heart is yours and mine and we need to break the record. Last
year we only missed the national, one-day blood drawing record by
14 pints! The record was 1,968 pints and we collected 1,955. We can
beat this in 2013 and show the nation how big our hearts really
Already, in Rutland, 20% of us give blood annually, impressive
seeing as the national average is just 5%. So 14 pints more than
last year is well within reach considering the extra effort being
expended this year.
Be a part of what can surely be the winning team... if you join
We may not be rich or famous. We may not have the glitter of a big
city, but our blood is just a good as anybody's and we're willing
to share it to save lives, like nobody else in the nation. What
community could do anything more important than that?
This year the Gift of Life Marathon will take place Tuesday, Dec.
17 from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m. Call 1-800 RED-CROSS to make an
Royal Barnard, Rutland
Op-Ed: Ship of state is on the right
By Jeb Spaulding, Vermont Secretary of Administration
Recently, Paul Cillo, the founder of Vermont's Public Assets
Institute, penned an Op-Ed claiming that the Shumlin Administration
isn't spending enough to serve Vermonters and calling for taxes to
be raised to match the increased level of services Cillo believes
are warranted. Shortly afterwards, Tom Pelham, co-founder of the
decidedly more conservative Campaign for Vermont, published an
Op-Ed describing Vermont's spending as a "pending fiscal ship
wreck," and calling for significant reductions in current state
In the face of critics from opposite poles of the same budgetary
debate, what is an Administration to do?
Exactly what we have been doing: maintaining our focus on creating
jobs and meeting the critical needs of Vermonters, while carefully
protecting the public purse.
The Shumlin Administration has made tough and responsible budget
choices, even while it has met considerable challenges, such as the
damage from Tropical Storm Irene, a slow economic recovery, the end
of federal stimulus dollars from the Great Recession, and continued
dysfunction in Washington, DC. Administration leaders are being
asked by Governor Shumlin to work across agencies to make state
government work better by increasing efficiency and reducing waste.
All the while, Shumlin has fought off legislative efforts to raise
taxes for General Fund spending.
Though the Shumlin Administration is meeting the challenges of
today while planning for the future, some of our critics seem stuck
in the past. As someone who has worked with both Paul Cillo and Tom
Pelham over many years and across many roles, I respect their right
to advocate for their own views of our state's budget. But as a
state official who must actually deal with the practical art of
governing, I am not as free as a clever advocate to paint the
state's budget situation in stark monochrome.
Pelham's prescription for our claimed woes boils down to the
familiar remedies he has promoted for years: cutting government
services, shifting responsibilities to others, and coming up with
gimmicks that sound promising but usually don't work. He claims our
financial practices have put Vermont's bond rating at risk by
citing a report from Standard & Poor's that actually improved
the outlook on the state's rating.
Tellingly, in recent days, Moody's Investors Services reaffirmed
Vermont's best in New England Triple A rating, explaining, "Moody's
highest rating level reflects Vermont's strong history of financial
management, which includes conservative fiscal policies and the
maintenance of healthy reserve balances that continue to provide a
cushion against any unexpended revenue declines; and manageable
debt profile that reflects the State's focused efforts to reduce
its debt ratios and maintain well-funded pension systems."
Nowhere is Vermont's solid progress clearer than in our path out
of the Great Recession, where Vermont's economy "has recovered more
quickly than the rest of New England, and much faster than many
other parts of the country," according to Federal Reserve Bank of
Boston CEO Eric Rosengren when he spoke in Burlington earlier this
month. And our recovery shows in the numbers: Vermont remains one
of the lowest unemployment rate states in the country, currently
tied for fifth.
Pelham performs historical sleights of hand in his review of
government spending in Vermont. He begins his analysis with 2008,
when the economy began the most significant decline since the Great
Depression. Only he could be surprised that spending by government,
much of it in the form of federal stimulus money, would - and
should - increase as unemployment rose, incomes stagnated, and home
Pelham correctly expresses concern about the long-standing
challenges of funding Vermont's pension systems, a problem
stretching back over many administrations, but then fails to
mention the name of the person who routinely made the trip from a
former Administration's offices in the Pavilion building to the
Statehouse to convince lawmakers that we should not fully fund the
actuarial recommendation for the pension funds: Tom Pelham.
When he left his position as Commissioner of Finance, Vermont was
not the Triple A rated state it is now, and it couldn't possibly
have become one with that kind of budgetary practice. The truth is
that Vermont was ahead of the curve in enacting changes, like
increasing the normal retirement age, increasing employee
contributions, and linking retiree health coverage to length of
employment, to make our public pension plans sustainable. Further,
we now routinely fully fund the annual pension actuarial
Meanwhile, in stark contrast to Tom Pelham, Paul Cillo reaches
back more than 20 years and cherry picks one quote to fault the
Shumlin Administration for not emulating Governor Richard Snelling,
characterized by Cillo as a leader who felt comfortable raising
taxes in order to support increases in state services and programs.
It is important to note that Governor Snelling inherited a budget
gap several times larger than the funding gap currently anticipated
for the next fiscal year. I doubt very much Governor Snelling would
endorse Cillo's whitewash portrait of the extremely difficult
choices his Administration made during that crisis. A more accurate
view of Snelling's budgetary philosophy, one shared by Governor
Shumlin, is reflected in his January 1991 budget speech to the
Legislature, when he said "our citizens expect their government to
balance the need for services and the burden of taxes. They will
not tolerate excessive taxes any more than they will accept neglect
of social interests." The former Governor continued, "Consequently,
Vermont does not and never has had the option of simply deciding
which government programs or services it wants and then levying
taxes at whatever levels might be required."
Cillo believes that the Shumlin Administration has failed to focus
support on Vermont's most needy, ignoring the facts in the process:
increased state spending for low income housing and homelessness;
the first base-budgeted contribution to low income heating
assistance in state history; becoming the first state in the
country to extend free school lunch to all low income public school
children; an increase in the coverage limits for Medicaid; and
increased subsidies for childcare. No one could take a clear-eyed
look at the facts and claim that Governor Shumlin does not value
and support the state's anti-poverty programs.
Finally, claims from both Cillo and Pelham that we are spending
state dollars on public assistance programs without concern for
results ring false.
Following the Governor's lead on a statewide strategic plan,
Secretary Doug Racine and his team at the Agency of Human Services
have aggressively rebuilt its capacity to measure and report
results, something that was done for years but abandoned during the
last decade. The Agency has identified 21 outcomes for the
wellbeing of Vermonters. Contracts with our community partners now
require these measures of performance, so that we can see whether
we are getting desired results for the money we are spending.
Soon, an e-scorecard will allow Vermonters to see how the Agency
is doing on its performance measures. In addition, Governor Shumlin
has launched both an e-dashboard
(http://governor.vermont.gov/govdash) to track a host of social,
economic, and environmental indicators and a financial transparency
website (http://spotlight.vermont.gov/) which allows citizens to
see "Where the Money Comes From" that is used to operate state
government and "Where the Money Goes" when it is spent. Greater
accountability, more effective programs and better results for
Vermonters will result.
While our critics continue to replay the last 20 years of tired
legislative fights, the Shumlin Administration will stay focused on
the future by aiming to create good paying jobs and prudent
management of the state's finances. This budget year and those
beyond will undoubtedly bring new challenges. Vermonters expect
state government to act responsibly and to meet critical needs
within the means we have, and they deserve nothing less.
Franco farewell as true community success
On Sunday, Oct. 27 the Killington community came together to say
"farewell" to our friend Chris Franco.
On behalf of Franco's family, and everyone who helped to organize
the celebration of his life, we just wanted to take a moment to say
"thank you" to everyone for being part of a wonderful day.
It was an afternoon filled with delicious food, beautiful music,
friends and family... All things that Franco loved most. A fitting
tribute to a man that left us much too soon.
Due to the generosity of our community, the talents of the many
chefs and musicians that participated, and everyone who attended,
we were able to raise enough money to take care of all of Franco's
final arrangements and remove that burden from his family.
We would also like to thank Polly Lynn, Jason Mikula and the
entire staff of The Mountain Times for their help in getting the
word out about the event and their support through a difficult time
for many in our community.
A very sincere and grateful "thank you" to you all,
The Family and Friends of Chris Franco
Restricted fund allocation in question
I am dismayed at the cursory reporting done in the Killington
Selectboard Briefs of Oct. 10-16. Specifically, on the
Citizen's Input. It was simply reported that I and
Jim Haff "disputed advice received from Jim
Barlow, recommending the Town hold a vote (essentially a
revote of the budget item voted on in this year's election) to
formally establish a restricted fund for the $217,500
appropriated in the 2013 budget for Golf Debt Balloon Payment".
What is not being reported here is that the same Jim
Barlow recommended to the board before last March's
election that there was no need to have a vote to
formally establish a restricted fund for this purpose, that
the budget vote was adequate authority to establish a
Here is the rationale Jim Barlow wrote to Seth Webb in changing
his recommendation, "If such a vote is not taken, the passage
of time will only make the voters' intent in 2012 less
clear." Huh? As Jim Haff pointed out, if one reads the 2012
Town Report, which I imagine most people get their town
budget information from, on page 3, in the Town Manager's
Report, it clearly states: "Setting aside an additional
$217,500 of undesignated funds to be used against a future
Golf debt liability of $1.1 million, which is due for payment
in 2022." If that is not enough on page 18 there is a budget
line item "Golf Debt Balloon Payment, $217,500. I think it
would be really hard, however far into the future, to
misconstrue the intent of the voters in this case. You have to
remember what Jim Barlow's perspective is. He is an advocate
for the municipal governments not the taxpayers.
Why the sudden turnabout? Why is this current opinion
better than what was acted upon in March? Why is all this this
time being spent by board members and the town manager on
an issue which was pretty much settled in March. While a
couple of members of the Select Board tried to mollify me, and
I suppose the public, by stating that this was just an
exercise in dotting the 'i's and crossing the 't's so that the
restricted fund is ironclad legally. What about the law of
unintended consequences? What if the vote is against
establishing the restricted fund? That will bring the
eventuality of raiding the fund to a reality.
While I have to publicly give the Chris Bianci, Patty
McGrath and Seth Webb the benefit of doubt in this case,
I wonder if this isn't just parliamentary maneuvering to
reverse the intent of last March's vote.
Vito Rasenas, Killington
Too loud, too late
A very vocal minority in our country seems to believe that our
problems are mostly government and social programs. They
scream for "cutting taxes," "shrinking government" and "cutting
spending." It seems to me that they are far too loud and much
too late in their concern.
These people see the number of Americans who receive benefits from
one or more social programs and ask, "How can we continue to
support these millions of people?" Shouldn't the first
question be "why is our economy in such shambles that millions of
Americans need help to survive?"
When I try to answer the latter question, I always end up staring
at globalization and the real effects of giving corporations and
Wall Street special treatment. Why does Apple rake in
billions in profit from sales to Americans, but employ so few
Americans? Same for Nike and all the major footwear
giants. How often do you call a major corporation's Customer
Service line and speak to someone in America?
Why do GE, Exxon-Mobil, and many other corporations often pay
zero-ZERO- in income taxes despite billions in profits? Why do
investment managers get to treat most of their income as capital
gains and pay a lower rate than policemen or firefighters?
With ever fewer jobs, lower wages for any new jobs, and tax
dodging by those who benefit from "offshoring," exactly what does
this vocal minority think the people injured by these phenomena are
supposed to do?
I hear no loud complaints about these things. Nor did I hear
them back when financial institutions issued trillions of dollars
in "credit default swaps" (CDS) before the great 2008 meltdown.
After all, in 2007 the 25 largest US Banks held $14 trillion in
CDS-the nation's GDP was only $13.84 trillion.
But it's safer to criticize ordinary people scrambling to get by
in our corporatized global world. And easier to memorize (and
shout) a few slogans.
Lee Russ, Bennington, Vt.
It's time for an intervention
By Lee H. Hamilton
The American public has lost patience with Washington. The
question is, now what?
Congress is unable to do its job. It displays neither competence
nor responsibility, lurching from crisis to crisis. Too many of its
members reject the notion that accommodation and time-honored
procedures allow them to fulfill their responsibilities to the
American people. They use their legislative skill to engage in
brinksmanship rather than address the country's fundamental
problems. Economic growth? Creating jobs? Putting the federal
budget on a sustainable path? Don't look to Congress.
We do not
have to continue down this road, but we do have to tackle a core
problem: the political center in Congress has weakened to the point
of ineffectiveness, if not near-irrelevance.
Part of the answer lies with the electorate: more people have to
turn out to vote. The more people who vote, the better the chances
to strengthen the political center - that is, moderates and
pragmatists. A healthier Congress rests on expanding efforts to
convince people to vote, and beating back the barriers to
The second solution lies with Congress. Contemplating a
government shutdown, one congressman recently explained his stance
by saying, "All that really matters is what my district wants."
This is not an uncommon view, but it's distressingly limited. Our
system depends on members who believe it's also their
responsibility to lead and inform voters, who are willing to weigh
the national interest as well as parochial concerns and who have
confidence in our system to resolve political differences. In other
words, we need members of Congress devoted to making the system
work, legislators who realize that those who line up on the other
side of them feel just as passionately about their positions,
respect those differences, and are committed to finding common
We change laws and solve our most difficult issues in this country
not by bringing government to a halt, but by fighting out the
issues before the voters in an election. At the end of the day, we
have to move the country forward - and we need to elect members of
Congress who are willing and able to do that.
Lee Hamilton is Director of the Center on Congress at Indiana
University. He was a member of the U.S. House of Representatives
for 34 years.
Editorial: Solving the health care puzzle
By Angelo S. Lynn
As Vermonters begin to decipher the new world of health care
through Vermont Health Connect and the health care exchange, and
Republicans in Congress try to dismantle the nation's health care
law by shutting down government, it's worth stepping back to view
the big picture: that is, how this nation's health care compares to
the rest of the world.
One place to start is with cost. In the U.S., we spent $8,233 per
person in 2010 (the latest available statistics). That's
two-and-a-half times more than most developed nations in the world
(or roughly $3,300), including European countries like France,
Sweden and the United Kingdom. The next highest spenders were
Norway, the Netherlands and Switzerland, but they still spent
$3,000 less per year.
In the U.S., health care spending amounts to a whopping 17.6
percent of GDP, or to put it another way, we spend 17 cents of
every U.S. dollar we generate on health care. The Netherlands is
the next highest at 12 percent of GDP, while the average among the
34 developed countries that belong to the Organization for Economic
Co-operation and Development (OECD) is almost half the U.S. at 9.5
percent. Canada spends $4,445 per person or 11.4 percent of
In a report produced by the OECD that studied the comparative
health care of member nations, the report also found:
• In 2010, the U.S. had 2.4 practicing physicians per 1,000
people, which is well below the average of 3.1 in other OECD
• The number of hospital beds in the U.S. was 2.6 per 1,000
population, again lower than the OECD avg. of 3.4.
• The life expectancy at birth increased by almost nine years in
the U.S. between 1960 and 2010, but that's below the average
increase of 15 years in Japan and over 11 years on average in the
OECD. The average American, the report found, lives to be 78.7
years, compared to 79.8 in OECD countries.
The positive side is that the U.S. leads the world in health care
research and cancer treatment, as well as in other specific types
of care. That's not only better for those patients, but the
research and development creates a lot of jobs. The U.S. also has
shorter waiting times for patients to see doctors. Yet, the U.S.
has fallen behind on public policy issues such as reducing obesity
and the harmful effects of smoking or alcohol abuse. For example,
in the U.S., 35.9 percent of children aged 5-17 are overweight or
obese, compared to an OECD average of 21.4 percent.
Then there is this comment from Canadian multi-millionaire
businessman, David Beatty, 70, who ran food-processing giant Weston
Foods of Toronto, and has been described as a "tough-minded,
suffer-no-fools wealth-creator that conservatives typically cheer."
In an interview with a Washington Post reporter, Beatty lauded the
Canadian system for its outcomes and simplicity and specifically
wondered why U.S. companies "want to be in the business of
providing health care anyway… that's a government function."
Or consider this comparison of the U.S. and Canadian systems by
Roger Martin, another Toronto native who spent years as a senior
partner at the consulting firm Monitor before becoming dean of the
Rotman School of Management at the University of Toronto. Martin
advises U.S. corporate icons like Proctor & Gamble and
Steelcase and lived in the United States for years, according to
the same Washington Post report. In comparing systems, the Post
wrote of Martin's analysis, "Canada's lower spending, better
outcomes and universal coverage make it superior by definition.
Plus, it's 'incredibly hassle-free.' In the United States every
time he took his kids in for an earache his wife spent hours
fighting with the health plan or filling out reams of paperwork. In
Canada, he says, 'the entire administrative cost is pulling your
card out of your pocket, giving it to them and putting it
Which brings us to political circus going on in Washington, D.C.
and this question: As many columnists have speculated recently, is
the real fear for Republicans not that Obamacare will ruin this
country, but that it will be successful - as Medicare, Medicaid and
Social Security have been, and as single-payer systems have been in
the rest of the world?
Water works professionals applaud firefighters during
Fire Prevention Week, call attention to value of
During Fire Prevention Week (Oct. 6-12), I join local water
utilities throughout Vermont in reminding residents about the
critical but often overlooked role that local water supplies - and
the systems that deliver them - play in fighting fires and
protecting public safety.
A properly functioning, well-maintained water system delivers
reliable supplies at a high pressure and volume that can mean the
difference between a small, manageable fire and a destructive,
But water infrastructure - the pipes, distribution mains, wells,
pumping equipment, and other components invisible to the public eye
- is aging and rapidly disintegrating.
This condition is especially prevalent in New England where a
number of public water systems are more than 100 years old.
To safeguard communities from the ever-present threat of fire,
local communities must invest in rehabilitating, improving, and
replacing their water infrastructure so that life-saving water can
flow uninterrupted from a source of supply, through a network of
underground pipes, to the corner hydrant.
I also encourage local communities to support the National Fire
Protection Association's campaign to prevent fires in the kitchen,
the leading area of origin for home fires, by urging their
residents to be more cautious and vigilant, especially when using
the stove (visit www.nfpa.org for more information).
During Fire Prevention Week, water works professionals throughout
New England applaud our region's firefighters for their courageous,
dedicated, and selfless public service.
For more info, visit www.thevalueofwater.org.
Raymond J. Raposa, Executive Director, New England Water Works
Remembering Mike Gallagher
I am deeply saddened to learn of the passing of my long time
friend Mike Gallagher. I first met Mike about 1970 while working at
the former Southworth's Ski Shop in Killington. Mike helped us put
together a Cross Country Ski department; taught us to ski; and even
helped us build a small trail system behind the shop.
I knew Mike was a great skier, but was most impressed while
visiting the home of my friend, Peter Berger in Oslo, Norway in
1973. Peter's Father, Benno, had made supper for us, after which he
began communicating with me about myself and my home in Vermont.
Soon, he said to me "You have a school teacher in your State who
came here to ski in competition, and he beat us. No, Americans had
ever beat us like this in our home sport." I immediately said,
"Yes, you must be talking about Mike Gallagher"... and he said
"Yes, yes... Mr. Gallagher, you must be proud of him."
We certainly are proud of Mike for his many athletic achievements
... and equally appreciative for the kind, encouraging, and
wonderful man that he was.
Royal Barnard, Rutland
Op-Ed submission: It's time to celebrate Vermont's
By Lisa Gosselin, Commissioner, Vermont Department of Economic
When we think of what is "Made in Vermont" we often think of sharp
cheddar, craft IPAs, and fancy-grade maple syrup. What may not come
to mind as quickly? A new wave of Vermont-manufactured products
that use technology so innovative it is changing the world.
That transdermal patch your doctor prescribed? There's a good
chance it was made in St. Albans by global health care company
Mylan Technologies, which recently announced a major facility
expansion. The Ever-Led light tube you just installed to save
energy? Built by LED Dynamics in Randolph. That smart phone you are
carrying? Most likely powered by micro electronics created in Essex
Junction by IBM.
While people around the globe are familiar with Burton's
snowboards, Green Mountain Coffee's K-Cups and Concept2's rowing
machines, many Vermonters are unaware of the thousands of other
innovative products created in our state.
In Bennington, Kaman Composites makes the outer case for a
'cooler' of sorts that can transport a human heart or other
organs destined for a transplant. In Arlington, Mack Molding makes
everything from solar-powered street lights to automated milk shake
machines. White River Junction's Sound Innovation helps
military air crews preserve their hearing with noise-reduction
earplugs. In Brattleboro, ROV Technology engineers the underwater
robots that service nuclear reactors.
Governor Shumlin has proclaimed this Friday, October 4, "National
Manufacturing Day" in Vermont, noting our state is "home to many
great manufacturing businesses, many of which are world leaders in
That's not surprising considering that the modern machine shop
came to life here in the 1820s, in the town of Windsor. "Precision
Valley," as the Springfield/Windsor section of the Connecticut
River valley became known, pioneered what the British called the
"American system of manufacturing," using division of labor,
mechanized production and a new business system of networks that
paired engineers and entrepreneurs, craftsmen and mechanics.
Today, Vermont's manufacturing landscape is totally different but
equally innovative. Small, technologically sophisticated companies
rely on skilled workers, extensive supply chains and global
markets. Facilities are state of the art and environments are
clean, modern and often eco-friendly. Vermont now has more than
1,000 manufacturing firms with 60 percent employing fewer than
10. About 31,000 Vermonters work in manufacturing, or about
10 percent of the total workforce - earning wages 36 percent above
the statewide average. Manufacturing alone contributes 11.1 percent
of Vermont's Gross Domestic Product.
As more and more people discover the value (and values) associated
with a product that is "made in Vermont," that number will grow.
Already, we are seeing some shifts that buck the national trend
toward moving manufacturing offshore. Consider Cabot Hosiery, which
has made a name by kitting Darn Tough socks so durable they come
with a lifetime guarantee. Or Vermont Castings, which announced
last Friday it would be consolidating its grill manufacturing (some
of which is done outside of the U.S.) back here in Randolph.
"We believe in Vermont," said Vermont Casting's new CFO Jacob
Reuben, a former New York financial advisor who helped transition
the company to employee ownership this past summer. "There's a
brand here that you just can't duplicate. 'Made in Vermont,' that
means something. It means quality."
50 Innovations Made In Vermont
To highlight some of the great
things made in our state, the Vermont Department of Economic
Development has created a list of 50 Innovations Made in Vermont,
available at ThinkVermont.com. It is a list of just a few of the
innovative products, designs and technology we produce. It's a list
we hope to add to each year and we invite you to share your
thoughts and nominations on our Vermont Economic Development
Meet the Manufacturers
You can also celebrate this Friday, as many
Vermont manufacturers ranging from Burlington's Burton to the North
Hartland Tool Company to Middlebury's Danforth Pewter will open
their doors to the public. For more information on these and other
events, visit www.mfgday.com or contact the Vermont Manufacturing
Extension Center, vmec.org). In the Bennington area, teachers
in math, science and other STEM programs have already made it part
of their curriculum to visit the area's industries. Take some time
to show yourself or your children what "Made in Vermont" can mean.
Show them the possibilities. Show them the future.
Congress and Syria
By Lee H. Hamilton
As Washington swirls with proposals, counter-proposals, and
political brinksmanship in response to diplomatic efforts on Syria,
the situation has a lot of people scratching their heads. Couldn't
President Obama and Congress have handled this differently?
I prefer to take a step back and ask a different question. Given
that we are stronger as a country and our foreign policy more
effective when the President and Congress forge a unified response
to an international crisis, how can the two branches of government
work together less chaotically to confront a dilemma like this
Let's put a possible congressional vote on Syria in context.
Washington has long been divided over the power to use American
military force, thanks to ambiguity in the Constitution itself: it
gives Congress the power to declare war, but makes the President
commander-in-chief. The last time Congress formally used its war
powers was during World War II. It has ceded authority to the
President ever since.
So I'm encouraged to see the possibility of real congressional
debate on Syria, on what to do when another country uses chemical
weapons, and on the projection of U.S. power. Presidents should not
get a free pass on foreign affairs, but neither should Congress get
to avoid declaring itself. On such difficult issues in the past,
Congress has preferred to sidestep its constitutional
responsibility, defer to the President, and then snipe from the
sidelines when things go wrong.
This time, for better or worse, is different. What I hope we don't
see is a chaotic process that leaves the U.S. appearing divided and
indecisive, with the President forced to wonder how to "consult"
with a disorganized Congress in which power is diffused. There is a
better way, but it requires a regular mechanism for
A few years ago, a bipartisan National War Powers Commission, of
which I was a member, came up with a pragmatic framework that would
create a routine process for the President and Congress to
Had this structure been in place already, a high-stakes vote on
Syria wouldn't seem so unusual and the consultative process would
have been far less messy. My hope, once this is over, is that the
idea will gain greater currency. When international crises arrive,
a routine process that has allowed our political leaders to build
credibility with each other would save them a lot of
Lee Hamilton is Director of the Center on Congress at Indiana
University. He was a member of the U.S. House of Representatives
for 34 years.
Thank you Killington community for a successful
On behalf of the Board of Trustees and the staff of the Sherburne
Memorial Library, I would like to thank the Killington community
for making our weekend Centennial Celebration such a success. The
celebration brought the community together at Saturday's Open house
and Sunday's Gala. All had a good time.
We extend our special thanks to the many the businesses that
contributed to our Tea Cup Raffle and Silent Auction, as well as
individual and organization whose financial generosity made the
event possible. This "thank you" would not be complete without
mentioning the efforts of two individuals: Peter Gould who donated
his artistic talent and created the stunning Centennial Logo, and
Ned Dyer for his special help with our Gala.
We are truly grateful to the entire community for their
support, which was intrinsic to our accomplishments the past
100 years. We forward to writing the next chapter of our history
Diane Rosenblum, Chairman, Board of Trustees Sherburne Memorial
Songs that bring back memories
I enjoyed reading the article by Cindy Phillips in The Mountain
Times last month (Aug. 22-28) on "Memory," and the association of
certain songs and a particular vivid memory. I am not a Baby
Boomer, I am one of the so-called "Greatest Generation," but the
song that takes me back to a certain time is "Gonna Take a
Sentimental Journey." It takes me back to World War II Marberg
Germany as the war was winding down. We had just captured the city
of Marburg. Things quieted down for a bit and we got mail.
My wife sent me the recording of "Gonna Take a Sentimental
Journey." I had to find a record player to hear it, which I did. It
was a very touching song having been over seas over two years at
this point. It must have been very touching for my wife to send me
the record, too. That was the first time I heard it.
The Baby Boomer turned out to be my daughter who I saw for the
first time when I got home, September 1945. Hearing that song today
takes me back 68 years as though it were yesterday.
Jack Derevensky, Quechee, Vt.
Rutland to attempt world's longest contra dance
A group of people in the Rutland area are planning a large event
for June 7, 2014. We have applied for and been granted permission
by the Guinness Book of World Records to attempt the World's
Longest Contra Dance Line; the current record is 2208 set in Riga,
We have secured nationally recognized caller Will Mentor and two
equally known contra dance bands: Perpetual E-Motion and Giant
Robot Dance to perform. Venues are currently being ironed out at
his time. More information and updates will be available soon.
Follow our Facebook page: "Attempting the World's Longest Contra
We are very excited about this opportunity for our community and
hope everyone will be eager to participate as the date gets closer.
Eric Smith, Rutland
Fair followup on Floraculture
Every year, I am asked how does one enter the flower competition
at the Vermont State Fair. The procedure is very simple. A
person just has to pick up a Fair booklet at the Fair main office,
or go online at: VTStateFair.net and follow the instructions.
The flowers are brought to the Bergstrom Building on the first
Friday of the Fair, between noon and 7 p.m. Entries are placed in
several specific categories, and there is even the
opportunity for children under 12 to display their flowers.
Flowers can also be entered daily, in specific categories, which
in addition to awards, provide fresh flowers each day to enjoy.
Daily entries provides the opportunity for everyone to use their
creativity, and lets their neighbors and friends see, not only
their flowers and herbs from their home gardens, but also the
artistic talents of the competitors.
Thursday of Fair week, is Agriculture Eduction day. Many
elementary and middle school kids participate, and are given a seed
packet when they come to the Bergstrom Building. The hope is
that they will plant the seeds either at their home, or somewhere
on their school grounds.
Extension Master Gardeners from all over Rutland County, are on
hand to answer any questions or to make suggestions. Master
Gardener, Jan Sherman and her loyal crew have been working all
summer long, in order to beautify all the gardens seen around the
Fair grounds. These gardens are on display throughout the Fair
grounds, and especially just outside the Bergstrom Building, which
includes the hillside garden, the raised beds, and especially the
lovely waterfall garden built by Master Gardener, Gary
Next door is the compost area. Ron Hebert, Master Composter,
explains how the compost begins with the soil, and how it develops
into beautiful, rich compost, fit for any type of garden. He
is very proud of this excellent display.
Ron and other Master Composters are on hand to explain how one can
begin and develop their own compost, and how it is not only
terrific for any garden, but that it is also helping the carbon
footprint for Planet Earth.
So, besides the exciting rides, animals, and food, there are many
excellent activities which help to make up the Vermont State
The Master Gardeners and Composters are looking forward to
seeing you at the Vermont State Fair next year.
Elaine Nordmeyer, Floraculture Superintendent
By Brett Yates
As the U.S. prepares to launch a military strike against Syria,
it's worth thinking about why we might be doing what we're doing.
For example, one reason why it might make sense for us to attack
Syria is that the country's president, Bashar al-Assad, is killing
lots of innocent people, and therefore something must be done to
Bashar al-Assad had already killed lots of innocent people,
however, before he crossed the famous "red line" by using chemical
weapons to murder nearly 1,500 Syrians in suburban Damascus.
100,000 had died by then; from a moral perspective, Assad is
perhaps no worse for having used chemical weapons than he would be
if he hadn't.
Of course, Barack Obama did say - perhaps unwisely, but I'm sure
at the time it seemed important that he say something - that if
Syria should employ chemical warfare, there would be consequences,
and Secretary of Defense Chuck Hagel has emphasized that "the word
of the United States must mean something." Obama himself has more
recently backed off from the position that his own no-chemicals
mandate is what matters here; the idea now is that he was merely
echoing a universal sentiment, and it's because Assad overstepped
the world's "red line," not Obama's, that action must be
Indeed, chemical weapons are banned by international law.
Yet it would perhaps be disingenuous of Obama to suggest that he's
only adhering to international law by going after Syria, for it is
in fact the responsibility not of the United States - which
actually supported Saddam Hussein's use of chemical weapons in the
Iraq-Iran War - but of the UN Security Council to administer
justice when somebody breaks a treaty.
Furthermore, it is not Obama's stated objective to "stop Assad."
What we're aiming for is something between a warning shot and a
war: a limited strike by bomb and/or missile that will neither kill
Assad nor cripple him to such an extent that he'd no longer have
the capacity to slaughter civilians by the thousand, but will show
him that we're not happy about what he's doing and are ready to
"give him hell" if he continues doing it.
There may be a vague contradiction here, since Obama assures us
that this will not become for the United States a protracted, messy
conflict like the ones in Iraq and Afghanistan, and if he's telling
us the truth, then the threat promised by our circumscribed assault
upon Syria is basically an empty one - yet he's counting on Assad
not to regard it that way.
There's perhaps an essential illogic in the actions of a nation
that, despite not wanting to go to war, attacks another nation, and
that may be why limited, punitive military campaigns apparently
don't work at all, as a recent Los Angeles Times article pointed
out. In 1986, when we bombed Tripoli but left Gaddafi standing, the
Libyans retaliated by blowing up Pan Am Flight 103 and its 270
passengers over Lockerbie, Scotland; Bill Clinton fired 75 missiles
at Al Qaeda training camps in Afghanistan in 1998, and we all know
how they responded three years later. In Syria, we want Assad out,
and Assad knows we want him out, but we don't want to pay the
horrible cost of another "real war"; still, we must do "something."
Meanwhile, Syria's ally Iran has already ordered an attack upon the
U.S. embassy in Baghdad, which, according to the plan recently
intercepted by U.S. intelligence, would be carried out by Iraqi
militants in the event of a U.S. strike upon Syria.
Still, what else can we do? If we lent our support to the Syrian
rebels, Assad would presumably only gas more of them, along with
the women and children who happen to live nearby. What we're going
to do, apparently, is blaze a medium-sized path of destruction
(we'll likely kill a few innocents of our own) that will, however,
leave our enemy mostly intact, and then we're just going to wait
and see what happens.
These days, I get the impression that many Americans sort of
accept that the U.S. military is basically incapable of helping
matters at all anywhere in the Middle East - that whatever we do
just makes things worse, that we inevitably end up killing more
people than we save. This may or may not be true, but in any case
we're all so very tired of the fighting, and a sense of futility
has crept in. Obama is in a tough position here: the hegemonic
dream of Bush and Cheney - the notion that America the Superpower
can and should impose its will upon the rest of the world - has
perished, yet America remains a superpower, and what kind of
superpower are we if we sit back and do nothing while another
hundred thousand Syrians die?
To be fair, sitting back and doing nothing sometimes seems to be
our standard policy when state-sponsored massacres occur anywhere
except in the Middle East. Moreover, I read that six out of ten
Americans oppose the strike in Syria. That we're going to strike
them anyway may be a reflection more of America's identity problem
than of any genuine need to drop a few bombs near Assad. Obama has
scaled back the visible presence of American imperialism - he tries
to avoid putting "boots on the ground" - without disowning
After all, we still have a certain reputation to uphold. It's not
just that "the word of the United States must mean something" when
it actually doesn't. The question is: what does a superpower even
look like if it's not doing anything big on the international
Can the world's greatest nation just be the place that makes the
best blockbuster movies and pop songs and wins the most Olympic
gold medals? Can it just be a place whose citizens are happy and
protected, while their leaders encourage other nations to do right
without attempting by military intervention to force them to? Do
you want to live in a place like that?
Food shelf suffers shortages in West
When I opened the West Rutland Food Shelf in 2008, I committed to
feeding anyone who came down our stairs regardless of where they
lived. Over the last year, however, we have seen an increasing
number of families from outside of West Rutland who are coming to
us struggling with hunger and have exhausted their benefit at their
local Rutland Food Shelf.
For five years we have been able to keep up with the demand but
our food shelf is now in danger of not being able to meet the needs
of residents of West Rutland. We are a small but generous town but
our donor base just cannot keep up with outside demand at his time.
Consequently, we have informed our customers that, until further
notice, we will only be able to serve residents of West
I don't make that decision lightly, and if our conditions change
we may be able to serve our friends in surrounding communities once
Because of the demand we have experience over the Summer months,
in particular, we are operating from a very small and fragile cash
position. If you would like to help us restore our finances to a
more healthy balance, please send contributions of any amount to
the West Rutland Food Shelf, 472 Dewey Avenue West Rutland, Vt.
05777. Donations of food can be made at the Price Chopper in West
Rutland where there is a donation bin or at the Town Hall.
With generous donations of money and food, you have the power to
make it possible for us to feed all of our neighbors that come
through our doors.
On behalf of all those who are struggling with hunger and are
counting on us, thank you.
Tony Morgan, Founder/Director, West Rutland Food Shelf
In Washington, ideology need not reign
By Lee H. Hamilton
As I speak to people about the Congress, one question arises more
than any other: Why is Congress gridlocked? People are perplexed
and disappointed with its performance, and are searching hard for
The roots of Congress's dysfunction are complex. But the
fundamental reason is that real differences in beliefs about
government exist among the voters.
Conservatives place a heavy emphasis on liberty, individual
freedom, and self-reliance. They have little confidence in the
government's ability to play a role in improving society or the
economy, and many of them look upon government as destructive, a
force that undermines our basic freedoms
Moreover, a belief has taken hold among conservatives in recent
years that compromise and accommodation are betrayals of their
cause. This has put great pressure on GOP leaders not to budge in
their negotiations with the White House and Senate
Meanwhile, on the "progressive" side there is much
greater emphasis on using government to narrow economic disparities
and help those at the bottom of the income scale. They emphasize
equality of opportunity for all and individuals' responsibility to
the community around them. While they do not favor a radical
centralization of power in the federal government, as some
conservatives charge, they are more willing to accept government
action - and the legislative compromises that make it
The gap between these views appears unbridgeable. It is not.
That is because most Americans find themselves somewhere between
the extremes, able to see merit in both conservative and
progressive ideas. When I was in office, I often found myself
thinking that many of my constituents were conservative, moderate,
and liberal all at the same time. That hasn't changed. They may be
wary of excessive government, but again and again they turn to
government at some level to help solve the problems they complain
about, and they want it to work effectively and efficiently. More
than anything else, Americans want to see moderation and
cooperation from their political leaders.
In the end, Congress
usually ends up about where most Americans want it to be. So I'm
not surprised how, when dire problems confront them, both
conservatives and progressives in Washington find their inner
Lee Hamilton is Director of the Center on Congress at Indiana
University. He was a member of the U.S. House of Representatives
for 34 years.
Paid sick days are crucial to community well-being
While working in the school system, I witnessed sick kids coming
to school, staff (including food service workers) often becoming
sick, and kids that needed to stay at school laying on cots because
their parents had to make arrangements for their children to be
cared for. After talking to some parents, I realized how much they
agonize over the choice of losing a valuable days pay or staying
home with their sick child. Parents always want to stay home to
take care of sick kids, but losing even one day's pay is a
sacrifice that will mean being behind on the bills. This is
especially true for single parents, relying on one paycheck.
This scene played out over and over again for the 12 years I
worked in a school. Fellow staff members were at risk for any and
all ailments that came through the front door, and then bringing it
home, where other family members took it somewhere else. Thus a
never ending cycle - which could have been prevented by paid sick
days. Paid sick days could be some of the best preventative
medicine we could have in Vermont.
If paid sick days were in place, it would take care of many
problems. Parents wouldn't have to worry, and all workers would
have the right to a healthy workplace. Healthcare is more than just
going to the doctor, it means taking a proactive approach to a
problem that we can solve together.
The Vermont Paid Sick Days Campaign will be officially launched
Thursday, Sept. 19 at 10 a.m. at Red Hen Bakery in Middlesex, Vt.
Coming to this event is a great way to find out more and get
involved in this issue that's crucial to all Vermonters, and eat
some great bread!
Stauch Blaise, Randolph, Vt.
On Labor Day, too many workers labor in the shadows
By Ben Johnson and Richard Trumka
For many Americans, Labor Day barbecues and picnics mark a
nostalgic end to summer. It's also a time to celebrate work and the
people who do the work (and of course, the people who want to work
but can't find jobs). This year, we remember especially that too
many people labor in the shadows of our economy without access to
the rights and protections that everyone deserves.
Over 11 million aspiring Americans attend school, work on our
farms and in our neighborhoods, raise families, own homes and dream
of a better life. But their dreams will never be realized with the
threat of deportation hanging over their heads and a path to
citizenship so far out of reach.
While these immigrant workers struggle to become part of a country
that benefits from their labor but doesn't protect their rights,
unscrupulous employers abuse the system by exploiting workers with
little to no protections-and pay them less. This vicious cycle, in
turn, lowers wages and working conditions for all American workers
and makes it harder for businesses that play by the rules.
No one can deny that our current immigration system is broken, or
that it depresses living standards for all workers. Across the
country this Labor Day, people are calling for immigration reform
that truly protects the rights of all workers.
At the beginning of August, 41 national leaders representing a
broad coalition of advocates who support worker protections that
include a road map to citizenship were arrested in a civil
disobedience action just outside the offices of members of the
House of Representatives in Washington, D.C.
In California, hundreds of cars caravanned to Bakersfield for a
rally in the heart of House Majority Whip Kevin McCarthy's
Right here in Vermont migrant workers and their supporters are
rallying against the ongoing deportations.
The message is loud and clear: if Members of Congress continue to
obstruct a vote on immigration reform, they will have to answer to
a growing majority of Americans who support a path to citizenship
as part of comprehensive immigration reform.
We saw this majority reflected in the diversity of faces that
spoke up to ensure that a vote on comprehensive immigration reform
was successful in the Senate: faith leaders, conservatives and
business owners took action together with immigrant rights groups,
community organizations, working families and labor and civil
The immigration legislation that passed with a solid, bipartisan
majority in the Senate-while far from perfect-lays out a reasonable
roadmap to citizenship for aspiring Americans, lifts up workplace
standards and rights for all Americans, and strengthens border
protections. This would boost the U.S. economy.
According to the U.S. Congressional Budget Office (CBO),
modernizing our immigration system so that it is safer, more
orderly, and more humane would grow our economy and reduce the
deficit by almost a trillion dollars over two decades.
The CBO also reports that a set of reforms that include an earned
path to citizenship would create 732 new jobs in Vermont and
increase our economic output by $51 million in just one year.
Passing comprehensive immigration reform with strong worker
protections, including a path to citizenship, is the economically
and morally right thing to do.
Unfortunately, some Republicans, like Iowa Congressman Steve King,
have been very vocal about why they don't want a vote on
comprehensive immigration reform. According to Rep. King, the
millions of young women and men who call the U.S. their home and
are American in every way except on paper are actually drug mules
with "calves the size of cantaloupes." Will the Republican majority
in Congress really allow bigots who alienate the significant Latino
electorate to speak for their party on the pivotal issue of
Rep. Peter Welch was elected to do what's best for our state and
our country. That includes taking a stance in favor of fixing our
broken immigration system and ensuring that we no longer have
millions of people working in the shadows-and that Labor Day
celebrates all people who work. We are confident that Peter will
fight hard for the right thing.
Our country is watching and the millions who have mobilized will
continue to ramp up action until a path to citizenship is fully
Ben Johnson is the President of the Vermont State Labor Council,
AFL-CIO. Richard Trumka is the President of the National
News from the ledge: Shoreland conservation Bill makes
By Rep. Anne Gallivan
One of the things I enjoy most in summer is an opportunity to be
on or by the water. Lakes, rivers, and oceans lure visitors, and
the healthier the water, the more appealing the experience.
Sensible building and natural shoreline habitats help promote
healthy water while delaying potential eutrophication from
Last winter, the legislature passed Shoreland Bill H526 in the
House of Representatives. Now the creators of the legislation are
holding public meetings around the state to hear important
When the bill passes in the Senate, and meets concurrence by
committee, it will move to rule making to establish the details of
the permitting standards.
Under new regulation, building projects involving 500 square feet
or more of impervious surface must go through a permitting process
to assure a mitigation of new storm-water run-off that could carry
nitrogen and phosphorus into the lakes. The process might include
suggested building design features, water bar diversions for paths
and driveways or additional shore plantings to improve water
The current bill affects all new development, rebuilding, and
remodeling expansions (of a certain size) on lakefront properties.
Homes along the shore that do not undergo change can expect to
continue under current property maintenance. Small lot homes
wanting future expansion may need to plan to add on the inland side
of the home.
Though many older homes are closer than 100 feet from the shore,
the new permits would require a 100 foot setback, preservation of
certain amount of vegetation at the shore and interest in land
management for a full 250 feet from the shoreline. Specifics
of these regulations will be established in the rule making
process. Local size and scope conditions will likely be recognized
in variables to these rules.
Vermont is years behind its neighbors in New York, New Hampshire,
and Maine. Fewer than 20% of Vermont's towns with shoreline have
zoning ordinances that protect shorelines, and since the
encouragement of voluntary standards has failed to do more, a
statewide statute is, in my mind, the best response. Judging from
the data in other states, protective measures will boost property
values that thrive on good water quality and more natural
A meeting Aug. 22 at the Kehoe Conservation Center at Lake
Bomoseen drew several hundred attendees. Many expressed concern for
a perceived loss of owner's rights, while the Shoreland Commission
expressed a sense of urgency in updating Vermont's policy to
preserve at-risk bodies of water. Now is the time to chime in with
concerns as the legislation is tweaked. Contact your county
senators, ANR or me at 483-2854.
OP:ED What you need to know about congress right now
By Lee H. Hamilton
Deeply unpopular and flagrantly unproductive, Congress is on its
August recess right now. It won't return until Sept. 9, after a
five-week recess, leaving itself just a few days to settle issues
like raising the debt ceiling and passing a federal budget.
Here are some things you should know about where it stands at this
stage of the game:
- Few, if any, Congresses can match this one for futility. It
managed to help out some communities in the wake of Hurricane Sandy
and to reach a deal on presidential nominations, but mostly it
can't get things done - whatever your politics. The repeal of
Obamacare, action on climate change, a "grand bargain" on our
fiscal problems, education and tax reform, creating jobs,
strengthening gun laws... the list of dropped balls is long,
although there is still hope for immigration reform, if just
barely. A few weeks ago Speaker John Boehner told Americans not to
judge Congress by how many laws it passes, but by how many it
repeals. It hasn't succeeded on either count.
- The budget process
is a mess. It's been years since Congress put together a budget
according to its regular order, but even by its recent low
standards this year has been chaotic. None of the appropriations
bills needed for the government to continue running after Sept. 30
has been enacted. "It is common for Congress to leave big budget
fights until the last minute," the Wall Street Journal's Janet Hook
wrote as Congress left town, "but the budgeting process now seems
so adrift that even congressional veterans find it hard to see a
resolution." Passing a budget is the most basic function of
government, and Congress can't manage it.
- Members of Congress do
not like to compromise. The parties are more divided ideologically
than they've been for many decades, with one side fiercely hostile
to government and the other convinced that government can
accomplish good things. Neither side can get things done on its
own. That's pretty much the definition of when responsible
lawmakers step forward to build a consensus. Yet in this Congress,
either they don't know how or they're not interested.
A glimmer of hope does exist, as more members respond to polls
showing Americans believe it's more important for the parties to
compromise than to stick to their positions. They may not be able
to come to agreement, but some of them are talking about how
willing they are to reach across the aisle.
- Even so, it's worth noticing that one of the congressional
parties is extraordinarily difficult to lead at the moment. The
Republicans are fractured and squabbling over their future
direction. This makes me sympathize with the formidable task the
Republican leadership confronts.
- Hardly anyone out there thinks Congress is doing a good job -
it's consistently below 20 percent approval ratings - and most
people think it's too partisan. Yet members aren't very concerned.
They've become quite skilled at running against Washington, even
though they are Washington. And they count on the fact that few
voters hold their own member of Congress responsible for its
shortcomings, however unpopular Congress as a whole has
- As lobbyists descend in swarms on Capitol Hill, they hold more
power than ever. They rain cash, twist arms, and even draft bills -
all the things that powerful congressional leaders used to
The NRA's defeat of legislation strengthening background checks
for gun purchases, in the face of overwhelming public sentiment
after Newtown, was nothing less than an impressive display of
political clout and an example of how influential lobbyists and
special interests have become. Perhaps this is why a good number of
my former colleagues have made a tidy living for themselves by
- Finally, all of this contributes to the emerging themes for the
2014 congressional campaign. Candidates will clearly run against
the mess in Washington, and a good number of them, though not all,
will talk regularly about the need to be bipartisan. The big
question for 2015 will be whether the successful ones can translate
their talk into legislation to help move the country forward.
Lee Hamilton is Director of the Center on Congress at
Indiana University. He was a member of the U.S. House of
Representatives for 34 years.
OP:ED Remembering Irene, preparing for future floods
By Deb Markowitz
Like many Vermonters this summer, by July I was sick of the
constant rain. My garden beds flooded. The house smelled
vaguely of mildew. I was worried about the swollen rivers and
flooded lakes. And, I watched the damage mount - storm after
storm - to homes, to roads, to farms, and to weather-dependent
There is little doubt that Vermont is in for wetter springs as
climate change unfolds. Indeed, this year, May and June were
the wettest consecutive 30-day periods on record for Vermont!
The floods we experienced this past summer, like Irene, remind us
that rivers flowing through Vermont communities have tremendous
power to wreak havoc. They also remind us that we must prepare for
our changing climate, and there are many things we can do.
We learned some important lessons from Irene. Healthy forests that
absorb rainfall, and floodplains that give rivers room to spill out
and dissipate energy, will temper the immense power of floodwaters
before they inflict costly damage to our town centers. Vermont's
prized land use pattern - beautiful walkable villages surrounded by
working farms, wetlands, and forests - is the single most
cost-effective strategy we can pursue to buffer communities from
the impacts of fast-moving water. And, we can inadvertently
increase the risks of erosion and flood damage when we remove
debris and fix damage after heavy rains.
As a result of these lessons, the Agency of Natural Resources
(ANR) has been busy. We are developing rules in response to
new legislation, to guide emergency stream projects after storms
that will assure public safety and the quick repair of critical
infrastructure without inadvertently making rivers more prone to
flooding. We formed a new partnership between Vermont's land
conservation organizations and ANR that will target conservation
efforts to protect critical natural places that make us resilient
to flooding. Finally, state agencies are working together to
ensure that new or repaired infrastructure is built to withstand
future floods, and we are exploring policies to promote compact
growth in historic town centers while preserving undeveloped
floodplain areas such as working farms, wetlands, and river valley
We can also learn from the many communities battered by Irene that
have taken positive steps to reduce their vulnerability to future
flood damage. These communities have invested in conserving
undeveloped floodplains, have rebuilt infrastructure to withstand
future floods, have adopted local zoning bylaws to limit growth in
vulnerable areas, and have used new techniques to better manage
Here are some things that we can do in every community:
1. Ensure that flood water has somewhere
to go. Our farms, wetlands and fields provide a place where
flooding rivers can spill out and slow down. Healthy forests also
protect us by absorbing as much as 70% of the rain that falls on
them before it flows overland to streams. Protecting these areas
means less flood damage in our valley villages and homes.
2. Grow wisely in our river valley towns. When we invest in
development in our historic town centers, we create places where
Vermonters want to live, and we also keep the fields and forests
nearby intact so they can dampen serious floods. But living near
rivers calls for smart, flood-savvy investments.
3. Recover stronger: Build bridges and culverts to withstand
flooding. Many of our culverts are too small and our bridges too
low for the storm flows of today. And many roads are too
close to our most unpredictable river channels. We need to better
understand where our infrastructure faces serious risks so that we
can plan to rebuild with resilience.
4. Slow stormwater before it rushes into streams. Our steep
mountain hillsides send water rushing downhill not only during
storms like Irene, but also during the smaller storms we've seen
this summer. We must slow this runoff down if we want to prevent
flooding disasters in the valley bottoms. By managing storm water
so it absorbs into the ground we prevent damaging floods. This also
provides water quality benefits (keeping nutrient high sediment and
contaminants out of our water bodies) and helps to recharge our
Irene was one of the costliest disasters in the state's history,
both in terms of the human costs as well as costs to our
communities, families and businesses. Using the lessons we
learned from Irene we can ensure that Vermont is stronger and
better prepared for the future.
Reflecting on the second anniversary of Irene
Earlier this week, I was interviewed by a PHD candidate from U of
Massachusetts Amherst for insight into how Pittsfield responded to
the flood in the immediate aftermath and now currently.
I tried to give her my best overview and gave her copies of
correspondence to and from government officials, from my desk, a
copy of the book: The Wrath of Irene, and the DVD Flood
One question brought back some very warm memories/feelings dealing
with neighbors overcoming longstanding differences and barriers.
Being a minister, this area really has great meaning for me.
Pittsfield came together as a tight knit community putting all
differences and quarrels aside which, in and of itself, served our
recovery as much as any other factor.
Then she asked how enduring is this sense of closeness.
Honestly, in too many instances it waned from that initial high to
more of a lukewarm climate. As we approach the second anniversary
of "Irene's Wrath" with a Community Gathering and Celebration, my
prayer is that we might somehow recapture that spirit that served
us so well in the recovery.
Time has this way of slipping through our fingers. Two years since
the storm that seems like just yesterday. Edna and I are now in our
sixth year here in Pittsfield. We have made so many good friends,
some very close and special. As the years slip by, I am finding
that REAL friends are more important than anything else beyond the
church and our calling.
I am thankful for this town and ALL who are a part of it.
Howard Gunter, Pastor Pittsfield Federated Church
Castleton concerts enjoyed great success
After completing the 18th year of presenting concerts, the annual
Castleton Summer Concert series has once again enjoyed a most
successful season. Partnering with Castleton State College the past
two years, and with the move into the beautiful, brand new, state
of the art, pavilion, this indoor/outdoor venue has been "the"
place to go in Castleton, on Tuesday evenings.
There were 11 wonderful and exciting performances with great
crowds that enjoyed the musical talents of all the bands that
played in Castleton this summer.
Many of the musicians who have played Castleton, have said that
the program is the premier concert series in the State of
A "thank you" for the success for this excellent program is owed
to many people including: the sponsors, the college and it's
support staff, boy scout troop #13 for all of their contributions
and help, the local media, and certainly the many hundreds of
concertgoers who, each week, support live music with their
attendance at the Castleton College Summer Concert series.
The Castleton College Summer Concert series is a joint community
effort, and a great feeling of pride should be shared by all the
community of Castleton, it's Rutland County neighbors, and New York
With the 18th season complete, the 19th season must be just around
the corner! Until next year,
Dick Nordmeyer, director, and Lori Phillips, conference and
events, Castleton State College
Yankee fan corrects the record
In the last edition of The Mountain Times (Aug. 15) columnist
Brett Yates in his article on Performance Enhancing Drugs,
mis-identifies Alex Rodriguez as the New York Yankees shortstop.
Every baseball fan knows that, since late in the 1995 season, the
Yankees have had (essentially) one short stop - Derek Jeter.
Alex Rodriguez plays 3rd base!
Also, The 12 others suspended with A-Rod, included several All
Stars and one post-season MVP; and they were all Hispanic, possibly
a reason they were not maligned by other sports writers.
Hank Rogers, Killington, Vt.
On Sunday, October 2, 2011 a group of friends and
neighbors from all around Vermont, and many points beyond, came
together to help those who needed help and to lend a hand to those
who needed a hand.
It was a day of music, laughter, great food and community spirit
and despite the rain, over 500 people came to participate and enjoy
the Concert for Killington Area.
When we first started to plan the concert we had a very ambitious
goal of raising $20,000 to help those in need in the towns around
the Killington area. We are happy to announce that we have raised
almost $40,000, as of today, and the total keeps growing.
It would be impossible to thank all of the musicians, business
owners, artists and professionals who made this event possible and
we are humbled by the generosity of those who came to enjoy the
We are truly blessed to live in a place where people care so
deeply about each other and are always willing to help their
neighbors "weather the storm."
The Concert for the Killington Area will not reverse the
devastation that was caused on that dark Sunday in August by
Tropical Storm Irene but the monies raised will go toward helping
families and friends start to rebuild and get their lives on the
road to recovery. We have chosen two charities to help distribute
this money and get it to those who need it most.
It is with a full heart and wide smile that we all say "Thank
You!" to everyone involved with the Concert for the Killington
Area. We could not have done it without your love and
Wishing everyone health, happiness and good friends to get you
through the hard times.
Peace to you all,
Joey Leone & the Committee of the Concert for Killington
To the Editor:
My parents and I are extremely grateful to the Castleton State
College Men's Hockey Team and C.S.C President Mr. David Wolk
for making C.S.C students available to Rutland City residents
in our time of need.
On Friday September 9, 2011, as I leaned on my shovel and wiped
the mud and sweat from my face, I looked up to see a Castleton
State College van stop and approximately 15 to 20 members of
the Castleton Men's Hockey Team approach me and offer to help
remove mud and debris from my basement.
Like many of my fellow Meadow Street residents, I was forced out
of my home on August 28, 2011 by flooding brought on by Irene.
Many of us struggled individually to reclaim our homes from
the wrath of water, mud and damage brought on by storm. The storm
brought out the best in all the individuals I encountered as I
worked to clean my home of mud, water and debris.
The Hockey Team members descended into my basement and almost in
unison began to shovel up mud and then carry the heavy buckets
up the stairs to the side of the street, where they dumped the
buckets and then returned to the basement to repeat their task
over and over.
In addition to being tireless workers, the members of the Men's
Hockey Team are a great group of young men who clearly understand
the meaning of "giving to the community." I cannot express in
words my appreciation for their hard work. I would still be in my
basement, shoveling up mud, had I not received such
After the C.S.C students piled back into their white van and drove
to their next location, an individual asked me "who they were."
I responded, "they are the C.S.C. Men's Hockey Team but as far
as I am concerned they are superheroes."
From: Joseph Zingale Jr.
10 Meadow Street, Rutland, VT
Reflections On Irene
by E. J. Willis
-How many times can you reach for the light switch when there is
-How many times will you try to flush the toilet when there's no
water in the tank?
-Now I know why a caged animal paces - can't get out this way,
can't get out that way - back and forth.
-Patience only lasts so long.
-There IS a morning after. Doesn't mean things are going to be
-Send every soldier you know of a packet of salt and pepper. It
helps the MRE's go down. Maybe a spoonful of sugar would help,
-I wonder how many candles equal one lumen. Is it too late to
thank all those people who gifted candles to me over the years?
Thankfully, I kept them all in one box. They are gone now, but were
-How do you get candle wax off the table, dishes, upholstery, your
clothes, the floor and the cat?
-Not to sound unappreciative, but how many times can you say thank
you to the same people for the same action and mean it?
-The sound of softly flowing water is beautiful, but loud, fast
water sets my nerves on edge.
-No matter how hungry I am, lima beans are not meant to be eaten
by human beings.
-Rain pattering on our steel roof is soothing; rain pounding on
the roof is not.
-If road closed signs are ignored, would bridge gone signs stop
-I now realize how dependent I am on electricity and I do not like
-I found that 3 days without water maxes my tolerance for hauling
buckets of water from the brook.
-We seniors have discovered we can live without internet and
cable, but the younger generation was very disturbed over that
-Phones are a necessity in an emergency and EVERYONE should have
cell service no matter where they live. This is more important than
a health care system that few desire!!
-Never ever get rid of your battery dependent radio! It may be
your only contact with the outside world, your only source of news,
your only comfort during the dark hours.
-Closeness during an emergency is not always comforting -
especially by the 3rd day without H2O.
-More people will walk outside the day after a storm than you knew
lived in your neighborhood.
-Newspapers are the local archivists. Their articles tell our
-The rest of the world is unimportant when you're living in a
-I can now fathom the resolve of the people of Louisiana who
continually face damages from hurricanes. Hurray for them!
-"It won't happen here" doesn't apply anywhere.
-Vermont is Vermont. Only those who live in Vermont would
understand how special, independent, friendly and unique the state
and its people are.
Dear Editor and Friends,
First, I need to say how incredible all the small towns in the
Green Mountain State have pulled together as a team in the
devastating aftermath of Irene. I also need to thank all the people
in the Killington area and the Killington Town Garage for there
support and help with the Kokopelli Inn clean up.
As I work through this rebuilding journey there are a couple of
quotes from two long time proven Killington business owners that
have helped me through this process. Casey Crompton said "be
patient, there is always a Silver Lining" and Steve Durkee wrote me
a note "It will get better." At this point these are difficult to
believe but we are doing our best.
Secondly, our new Vermont slogan is "I am Vermont Strong." If you
would have asked us 3 weeks ago we would have said, "Of course we
are, 'Vermont Strong.'" We would have included our home and
business, the Kokopelli Inn, as Vermont Strong, too. All of this
proved to be weaker than Mother Nature. She challenged us in ways
that no one expected. We are among those who have lost everything
in a blink of Mother Nature's eye.
Our loss includes our business, our home, and our jobs. We are
also hearing the effects of the loss on the hundreds of our
extended family, the Kokopelli tribe members. Families that have
planned annual holidays to be in Killington at our Inn are worrying
about the loss of their reunion location; and wedding guests are
scrambling to make other arrangements. From our seasonal shares who
visit every weekend to all our other guests, and our signature Pot
Luck Dinner Friday crew, are who make up the Kokopelli Inn
It breaks our heart to see that the Kokopelli Inn's wounds from
Irene run so deep. We pride ourselves on providing an Inn that
brings families together. The Inn has the space to accommodate
large families and guests. On August 28th, Tropical Storm Irene
came to us with the force of a Hurricane and took so much
In a matter of hours our home and business was destroyed. The
landslide that came from the swollen river up the hill, the huge
metal culvert could not handle. The house across the street
collapsed into the river then blocked the culvert completely and
the river turned toward us. The river that was filled with
boulders, mud, trees and the remains of the house ended up piling
up around the Inn. Boulders rolled through the front widows and
crashed through the walls like they were made of paper. The
boulders were followed by a flood of river water that came through
the windows and filled our basement.
Irene did leave her mark on the Kokopelli; it includes a mountain
of debris 8-10 feet deep that has locked into place like cement.
Our storage basement filled with water and our basement home
completely destroyed. The entire infrastructure is damaged, tons of
debris in our yard, and septic system. Our electric and heating
system is destroyed, the well is not working, the debris has
settled, and our parking lot is a rocky river bed.
Over the past 8 years we have used all of our resources trying to
build a successful B & B business in Killington. We have
sacrificed our time, money and energy. We have developed a strong
partnership with the town of Killington. We have worked closely
with the Killington Chamber of Commerce, the Economic Development
and Tourism Commission, and the Killington Ski Resort organization.
The results of our partnership with the region have helped our B
& B business flourish with a strong extended family of loyal
As many of the other Vermonters affected by this disaster
understand, we are getting NO support from the insurance companies.
FEMA has given us some immediate assistance, which we are grateful
for, but it's a small fraction of what we will need to bring the
Kokopelli back to life.
Our story is not unique. We could substitute many businesses and
homes into our story. We are used to being the shelter from the
storm, being able to offer rooms to families who need a place to
call home. This is an incredibly challenging time for many people
throughout Vermont. The water has receded, roads are beginning to
open, and lives are moving on at a more normal pace.
However, there are many of us whose road is long and filled with
debris. Vermont pride and strength will continue to move us
forward. In the meantime, please know that if you have ever
considered a rock wall as part of your backyard that now is the
time to build it. We have plenty of rock at the Kokopelli, please
feel free to come by and take as much as you want!
We need help to fix the damage from Irene. We have submitted
applications for all the assistance that has been made available.
The cost in damages far exceeds the available funding. Cleaning the
building to make it safe for us to enter has reduced what we have
received drastically and we do not have money available to pay to
rebuild the infrastructure. We are looking for donations in
return for future weekend stays at a drastically discounted rate.
We need tradesmen willing to offer their time in trade as well.
Please contact us at Castrolmartin@aol.com for more info.
Hurricane Irene has been the worst, most destructive guest we have
had at the Kokopelli Inn. We welcome all at the Kokopelli, however
I hope if another Irene comes through Killington she chooses a
different place to stay.
Chuck and Barbara.
The Last Stand At "Fort Command"
by Ned Dyer
422-FIRE..now there's a number that would get your
attention. If you dialed that number from the time Irene left
town up until Sunday September 11th, you would have been connected
to the Killington Command Center (aka Emergency Response Center)
which was set-up on the second floor of the Killington Volunteer
Fire House on the Killington Road, but for this little tale
we have exercised a little poetic license and are calling the
center "Fort Command."
For the first week after the "Big Water" and like most people in
Vermont, I was dealing with my own issues. After I saw
daylight I felt a need to try and help in some way. At
10:00 a.m. on Monday, or it could have been Sunday or maybe even
Tuesday, I climbed the fire house stairs, turned right into "Fort
Command" and stopped dead in my tracks. There were eight or
ten tables with 4 to 6 chairs around them with Killington
volunteers using their personal cell phones, their own laptops,
telephones, maps, lists, water bottles, containers of cold
coffee and half eaten sweet rolls.
In the midst of all this there was Barry L., the "maker of
badges." ( I know, I saw "Blazing Saddles" too, so don't even say
it! Badges are necessary in emergency situations like
this.) What seemed like an eternity, I stared open-mouthed
trying to get a handle on what was happening. At that point
Steve D. welcomed me and handed me an instruction sheet, which I
never did get to read because Jill D. showed me a list of
volunteers and asked if I wouldn't call them to get there
availability and contact information-game on!
I bounced from table to table using my cell and whatever phone was
free, all the while watching Jeanne K. and Pat L. uploading data
into the data base, Hannah A. and Hal and Cindy B. compiling
volunteer and contractors lists, Betsy B. and Steve D. in a huddle,
Denise C., Kate, Kathy J. oand Pat F. fielding medical
issues, Patti McG. opening up the walking path to access Rutland,
Judy F. and Dottie D (who are the fastest phone picker-uppers east
of the Pecos), Steve Finer was at his desk as the gate keeper, Seth
and Suzie D. were everywhere, and the veterans told me it was like
that 24-7 the week before.
At one point Fort Command got pretty chaotic what with official
business and concerned citizens dropping by hoping to get
some information or any one of a number of valid reasons, so Steve
D. asked if I wouldn't watch the door and maybe redirect some
of the foot traffic. In my zeal I actually asked
Kathleen Ramsey the Town Manager, the nature of her business.
It's been nearly a week and I still blush at the thought of
For me it's been a week of awe and admiration watching a platoon
of locals step up and help direct food and water deliveries
where they are most needed, to get prescriptions to patients in
need, home inspections, setting up comfort stations, advising on
transportation routes, setting up a clinic for pets and generally
giving aid and comfort to an ailing community. But yet, thru
all of this, we couldn't get the needed mayonnaise airlifted to the
Comfort Station for the tuna fish.
So now it's Sunday, our last stand at " Fort Command".
Judy Findeisen is off doing inspections, Denise
Corriell has delivered the last of the prescriptions that
were delivered on Friday from the Pharmacies in Rutland, Steve
Duchan is heading off to Quebec to guide a bicycle tour, a new hot
line has been set up at the Town Office, Judy Evans, Marilyn and
their team are still manning the Comfort Station at the Butternut
and so here we are, Dottie and Pete DaCota and myself, the Llast of
the "Fort Command" Volunteers staring at the silenced phones
experiencing the first symptoms of withdrawal from
telephonitis, and they tell us we can't have a
Hi Mountain Times,
I just got back from CT where I DJ'd a wedding that had to be
moved from Mountain Meadows. The people couldn't thank me enough
for coming down. Besides that everyone that knew I was from VT came
up to me offering their support.
This is such a great community that people here and afar love.
That is why I'm so proud to live here and help out. Instantly I was
helping to deliver water, gas and supplies to stranded friends in
Pittsfield. The Pittsfield community really banded together in that
time of need. That is a special town.
I was hiking to Journeys End as that is the only way I can get to
K-town. Tonight I'm volunteering at the trail from 7pm-12am to help
people at the trail. Mendon is doing a tremendous job in helping
people. From the police to the construction workers to the
volunteers, it's all amazing. People can go to Mendon Town Hall to
sign up. So many people want to volunteer but all don't know
Your last few editions were classy and amazing.
I wanted to let you know that The Mountain Times's coverage and
online updates in the wake of Irene have been outstanding.
Really excellent work keeping everyone locally and beyond
informed. I read the online Times each Thursday and never
miss the hard-copy when I'm in the area.
Best wishes to you and your team.
Hurricane Irene: Seven Days Later
by a proud Vermonter
In the past seven days I've haven't missed a meal or been without
clean water to drink, I have had a warm bed to sleep in. I've been
able to communicate with the people I care about most.
In the past seven days people I know have lost friends, family,
their homes, their valued and cherished possessions and the pets
they loved. These same people have stood up, helped their neighbors
where they could and started to move forward.
In the past seven days I've been disappointed by no one.
In the past seven days I have watched strangers become neighbors;
neighbors become friends and friends grow closer as they stood side
by side and faced adversity and destruction. I've been reassured by
the reaction of people I've grown to depend on and pleasantly
surprised by people who I've had little regard for in the
In the past seven days I've heard our communities called "Islands"
but felt closer to the surrounding towns and their residents than
In the past seven days I've done the best I could with what I had
but am still humbled by those who did so much more with so much
less. I've not worried about what I needed, or what I was missing,
but instead focused on what I had and using the tools I had to
In the past seven days I haven't argued about religion, politics
or the 1% local option tax.
In the past seven days the things I've heard people say the most
is "What can I do?" or "How can I help?"
In the past seven days the best thing I've heard someone say is
"Mother Nature didn't send Irene to Vermont to teach us a lesson;
she picked Vermont to teach everyone else a lesson…on how to bounce
Dear Mountain Times
Thanks for you most resent issue September 1st. I can't believe
you were able to pull this off considering everything.
I wish you well and again thank you for keeping us informed. It is
the unknown that is the worst.
For those of you finding it tough to get specific information
about your property: The Curtis Insurance Agency offers to drive
over to your Killington Property and report what they find
there. Send them an email at email@example.com or
Jon D. Curtis, P.E.
I am a Killington homeowner (second home) and have been a devoted
reader of your paper for years - I was moved by your piece on
the situation in town. My wife and I almost put our family in the
car in New Haven CT on Saturday morning and drove up thinking we
would be safer up there. We are still without power but nothing
like what you are exeriencing.
I can't imagine what you are all going thru now but I admire your
spirit and the role your article will play in keeping people's
hopes up. If you have any information on the condition of houses on
Tanglewood Drive off of West Hill Road I would be grateful - my
home is 117.
I spoke to my friend Boris Pullsmaker yesterday who owns
Hinterland Organic and he has been stranded in Woodstock and unable
to get back to Killington due to the washouts on US-4. Our friends
at Setab were similarly unable as they are at Rutland. Our thoughts
are with you all thru this and I look forward to all of your
Thank you for working to get your publication back up amidst the
devastation. I live in Killington and feel pretty far removed from
what is going on in our corner of the world.
Again, an amazing amount of gratitude to you and yours for posting
photos and news to your website. From my perspective, you offer the
most comprehensive coverage for our town.
Luckily I am safely at home caring for my 3 1/2 year old son while
my husband reports to work for Killington Resort, doing what ever
he can to help the resort and the community. Thus far my big
contribution is giving away the diapers we no longer need to a
resort guest in need. I hope their baby wears size 5.
Other than taking care of my family and donating some diapers, I
feel isolated and unsure of how I might help others. I am not a
reporter, a journalist or anything close (I am the Human Resources
Manager for Farm & Wilderness), but if there is anything I can
do to help in these efforts from the "Island of Killington" do
please let me know.
Dear Mountain Times
I am a second home owner in Vermont and share both your sentiments
in this morning's online post as well as your attachment to the
local area.I am heartbroken to see what has happened to the Central
and Southern VT region and to think of the long road to recovery
We love Killington. We have had a home in Sunrise Village
for the last 7 years and enjoyed the area for many years before
then. Sunrise, as you mention, remains cut off, and we have
no idea what the situation is up there on the mountain.
Looking at the destruction along Rte 4 it's easy to imagine a
similarly dire situation farther up the hill. We heard one of
our full time neighbors did walk to safety on Route 100 and is with
friends who do have power - very good news.
Being so far away and powerless to help is extraordinarily
frustrating, but your reports and photos are extremely
comforting. While we cannot be with you in person, we are
with you in spirit. Stay safe and thanks again for getting
Dear Mountain Times,
Just wanted to drop you a line to say thank you for the reporting
on Killington. As second home owners at Mountain Green we are
obviously very concerned about our property. The damage to the
roadways is incredible.
Each time we arrive in Killington one of my first priorities is to
pick up a copy of your paper. I enjoy reading it to find out
what is going on and relax with the great articles. So of
course I searched for you yesterday to find out what is going on
and your reporting and photographs have been very helpful.
Keep up the great work.
Irvington New York.