On August 31, 2022

The making of Vermont’s largest whoopie pie

Staff report

Rutland has set a new state record and it’s a sweet one!

At the first annual Whoopie Pie Festival was held Saturday, Aug. 27 on Center Street downtown, Dream Maker Bakers of Killington set the Vermont state record by baking and putting together (in front of a crowd) a 554 pound whoopie pie!

The feat took a lot of collaboration, Megan Wagner explained on a Facebook post right before the event. Ralph Syl shared his mother’s classic whoopie pie recipe with her “just before this whole idea came about,” she wrote.

By Erica Canada of Erica Canada Photography
Dream Maker Bakers pose with the Vermont State record for largest whoopie pie — 554 pounds!

Wagner also thanked Dominic’s Pizza “for opening their kitchen to us and letting us do unique things to their oven as we baked a whoopie pie in a pan bigger than their oven,” Wayne Jones of Jones Metal “for building us a 4.5’ diameter circle pan with a 4-inch side in less than 36 hours!” Killington Resort “for the use of their scale and rigging straps for the weighing needs,” Foley “for the transport of the whoopie layers,” and Casella “for providing the heavy equipment required for the final weigh in.”

In addition to the Dream Maker Bakers record breaking pie, there were nine vendor booths from Vermont, New York, and Maine handing out samples to hungry festival-goers. Holly Bromley, owner of The Gettin’ Place in Whitehall, New York won People’s Choice Award and Overall Best, which was voted on by a panel of five judges. Fiona Graves, owner of Fiona’s Sweets & Tweets, a food truck based in Pittsford, won Most Creative, also voted on by judges.

Additionally, the event featured a Parade of Heroes, honoring community members who played a major role in keeping our community safe throughout the Covid-19 pandemic. Over 250 people participated marching through downtown Saturday afternoon.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Weather impacts Killington mid-week skiing

May 8, 2025
Killington Resort planned on keeping its lifts running during the week until May 11 (then weekends only), but rain and warm temps over the last several days have taken a serious toll on its snowpack. Therefore, Killington Resort will be closed Thursday, May 8, and Friday, May 9, to preserve what they have left and…

How Killington became The Beast: Part 9

May 7, 2025
Snow, summer, and snowshed: 1960 saw fast progress How Killington became The Beast: Part 9 By Karen D. Lorentz Editor’s Note: This is the ninth segment of an 11-part series on the factors that enabled Killington to become The Beast of the East. Quotations are from author interviews in the 1980s for the book “Killington,…

Woodstock Foundation honors the winners of new Rockefeller Legacy Scholarship

May 7, 2025
Three Woodstock Union High School students were honored on April 30 for their visionary ideas about shaping Vermont’s future as the first recipients of the Laurance and Mary Rockefeller Legacy Scholarship, a new annual essay competition created to honor the Rockefellers’ lasting impact on the community. The scholarship program was launched in 2025 by The…

Jimmy LeSage Memorial Scholarship awarded to Brycen Gandin of Mendon

May 7, 2025
The first-ever Jimmy LeSage Memorial Scholarship, a $2,500 award created to honor the life and legacy of wellness pioneer Jimmy LeSage, has been awarded to Brycen Gandin, a graduating senior at Rutland Senior High School. Brycen, a resident of Mendon, can use the scholarship toward the college of his choice this coming academic year. Brycen was…