On March 9, 2022

School board candidates against critical race theory flounder at the polls

Covid-19 safety rules and equity initiatives remained broadly popular statewide

By Peter D’Auria/VTDigger

In the weeks before Town Meeting Day, a surge of anti-mask mandate, anti-“critical race theory” candidates from across Vermont made bids for seats on school boards.

But according to results, many of those candidates failed to beat their opponents at the polls — suggesting that schools’ Covid-19 safety rules and equity initiatives remained broadly popular.

Mask mandates and critical race theory, an academic framework used to understand systemic racism, have become wedge issues across the country, including in Vermont.

In the Mill River Unified Union School District, however, the race was narrowly won. Ingrid Lepley, a candidate for the Mill River School District board, fell about 20 votes short of a seat, according to results released by the town of Tinmouth.

Lepley has been linked to a now-shuttered Etsy site whose merchandise included jewelry designed to feature themes of the conspiracy theory QAnon.

Another Mill River candidate, Kristine Billings, who had expressed fear that critical race theory was being “matriculated into the classroom,” fell about 30 votes short of unseating board Chair Adrienne Raymond.

In Springfield, voters turned away two board candidates — Katie Parent and Michael Jasinski — who previously voiced concerns about the instruction of critical race theory in schools.

The two were among five candidates for two board seats. But in results posted on the Springfield town website Tuesday evening, Jasinski and Parent finished last and second-to-last, respectively.

In Arlington, candidate Luke Hall, a former Vermont state trooper who sought to make masks optional in schools and expressed concern about the divisiveness of critical race theory, lost to incumbent Nicole Whalen by roughly 300 votes, according to results sent by the town clerk.

Hall did not immediately respond to a Facebook message seeking comment.

In Milton, voters rejected a trio of school board challengers that had circulated a document criticizing mask mandates and critical race theory, according to unofficial results.

Those candidates — Nichole Delong, Scott O’Brien and Brock Rouse — each garnered approximately 200 fewer votes than their opponents, the results showed. Officials were still tallying “hand counts and write-ins,” they said.

Chair Rick Dooley and newcomers Kumulia Long and Karen Stout were poised to earn seats.

Prior to the election, Delong, O’Brien and Rouse had issued a document affirming their belief in “Americanism not Marxism” and “One Nation Under God.” The candidates also opposed Milton schools’ mask mandate.

In St. Albans, Keith Longmore, a candidate for the Maple Run Unified Union School Board who appeared to have posted right-wing conspiracy theories and offensive memes online, garnered only about half the votes won by his opponent, Reier Erickson.

In the Kingdom East School District, Mathew Johnson, a candidate who had denounced the board’s “socialist agendas” and compared mask mandates to child abuse, lost by roughly 120 votes to two opponents for the board seat, results showed. Johnson did not reply to a Facebook message Tuesday night.

But controversial topics could feature in at least one more election before the end of the month: the Lake Region Union School District board races. Another two anti-critical race theory candidates are running in those elections, which are scheduled for March 22.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Off on the wrong foot

February 5, 2025
At the beginning of the session last month, one of the first daily riddles I shared in our committee was a simple question, “Why is it good to balance on your left foot on New Year’s Eve? Because that way you can start off the new year on the right foot.” Unfortunately, that didn’t happen…

Property tax relief

February 5, 2025
“I can’t afford to live here” and “It’s not worth it” is what I often hear when talking about property taxes. It is one of the main reasons I ran for office — to find a better, more sustainable way to pay for public education. The bulk of most property tax bills is the statewide…

Legislators get first look at proposed funding for governor’s proposed ‘education transformation’

February 5, 2025
By Polly Mikula Since first announcing what they’ve coined the “education transformation” plan on Jan. 22. Governor Phil Scott and his top education officials have gradually unveiled more and more details.  Democratic lawmakers have mostly welcomed Republican Gov. Phil Scott’s grand proposal with cautious optimism. Yet while broad support for a new funding formula and…

Vt legislators introduce bi-partisan bill to phase out tax on Social Security benefits

January 29, 2025
Vermont legislators are calling for support on a bill that seeks to exempt Social Security benefits from state income tax, a move aimed at easing financial burdens for retirees while aligning Vermont with most other states. This proposed legislation, H.74, has over 60 co-sponsors from across all parties and from all corners of the state.  Currently, Vermont is one of…