On October 13, 2021

Police find remains of missing Weathersfield woman, probe into her death continues

By Alan J. Keays/VTDigger

Police say they believe they have recovered the remains of a Weathersfield woman who had been missing since July.

The Weathersfield Police Dept. had been leading the investigation into the disappearance of 50-year-old Tonia Bushway.

As part of the investigation, Weathersfield police on Wednesday, Oct. 6 sought help from the State Police Search and Rescue Team and New England K9 to search properties in the area of Bushway’s home on Little Ascutney Road, state police said in a press release.

New England K9 located human remains around 9:45 a.m. Wednesday on a parcel of land next to Bushway’s property, according to state police.

The Vermont State Police Bureau of Criminal Investigations and Crime Scene Search Team went to the location and spent the day collecting information.

“Investigation at the scene indicates that the remains are those of Bushway,” police said in the statement Wednesday night.

The remains were brought to the Chief Medical Examiner’s Office in Burlington for an autopsy to determine the cause and manner of death and confirm the decedent’s identity.

Those autopsy results were still pending on Thursday, according to Vermont State Police Capt. Scott Dunlap, head of the state police Major Crime Unit.

“We have to rule out any foul play, and that’s what we’re trying to rule out now,” Dunlap said. “The autopsy will tell us more.”

Dunlap described the location of the remains as being in a wooded area and behind a large rock, about 50 to 75 yards from Bushway’s residence.

According to the release, Weathersfield police received a report July 13 that Bushway was missing, with her family telling authorities that a friend of hers told them she was last seen at her residence on July 2.

“Tonia has not been seen or heard from since,” Weathersfield police said in a press release this summer. “Tonia was believed to be walking to Springfield when she was unable to get a ride.”

Dunlap and state police spokesperson Adam Silverman on Thursday referred questions about why the search teams and dogs hadn’t been called in earlier in the investigation to the Weathersfield police.

Weathersfield Police Chief William Daniels did not respond to an email asking the same question. Through a dispatcher, he referred questions about the case back to Vermont State Police, who are now heading the probe into Bushway’s death.

Silverman said state police “cannot speak to what [Weathersfield police] did — their investigative efforts, their investigative steps prior to VSP taking the case.” State police would not object to Weathersfield police commenting on those efforts, he said.

A GoFundMe page set up this summer attempted to raise $2,500 “to offer a reward to help get her home.”

“When family realized she was missing they went to her home and there were squatters living there,” the authors of the GoFundMe page wrote at the time. “Her home was ransacked and the property was trashed. After the family & police showed up at the house, they all scattered leaving a mess that needs to be cleaned up.”

Toshia Emery, Bushway’s daughter, told WCAX-TV in a story that ran earlier this week that she didn’t believe police were doing enough to try to find her mother.

“The police did not put an official missing person post online for people to see and be aware of until July 23rd,” Emery told WCAX. “People were not immediately questioned and not seized and searched.”

Emery could not be reached Thursday for comment.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

VTSU names John Casella 2025 Castleton commencement speaker

April 23, 2025
Vermont State University (VTSU) is graduating its second class this spring on May 17-18, 2025 and has announced a remarkable lineup of commencement speakers for the four ceremonies, held at the Castleton, Lyndon, Johnson, and Randolph campuses over the weekend.  “We are delighted to welcome distinguished alumni and campus community leaders John Casella, Greg Tatro,…

Rutland affordable housing project earns state award for energy excellence

April 23, 2025
RUTLAND— A historic home on River Street in Rutland has been recognized among Vermont’s top energy-efficient building projects, earning a “Best of the Best” award at Efficiency Vermont’s annual Better Building by Design (BBD) conference. The award, presented to Hildebrand Homes, LLC, highlights a creative and forward-thinking approach to affordable housing that aligns energy efficiency…

Youth turkey-calling contest draws record participation

April 23, 2025
CASTLETON— A record-breaking 33 young participants, ranging in age from 2 to 18, showcased their best gobbles, clucks, and yelps at the 19th annual Bart Jacob Memorial Youth Turkey Calling Contest on April 12 at Kehoe Conservation Camp in Castleton. Sponsored by the Oxbow Mountain 4-H Club and underwritten by the Vermont Fish and Wildlife…

How Killington became The Beast: Part 7

April 23, 2025
By Karen D. Lorentz Editors’ Note: This is part of a series on the factors that enabled Killington to become The Beast of the East. Quotations are from author interviews in the 1980s for the book “Killington, A Story of Mountains and Men.” Despite the two-year delay to Killington’s debut—caused by the access road not…