On December 3, 2014

Outside report criticizes DCF handling of child deaths

By Laura Krantz, VTDigger.org

The Department for Children and Families failed to follow its own policies and moved too quickly to reunify two children with their families when it was not safe, an outside report released Friday, Nov. 21, found. That push to reunify, along with other system failures, contributed to those children’s deaths this year, the report concluded.

Gov. Peter Shumlin commissioned the report following the deaths of two-year-old Dezirae Sheldon and 14-month-old Peighton Geraw.

The panel of Vermont medical, education, law enforcement and child development professionals reviewed case records from both incidents and produced a 27-page report that details many areas in which systems failed and communication broke down. The strongly worded report outlines areas in which DCF and other sectors of the child protection system, including courts and police, can improve policies and make sure workers follow those policies in the field.

Many breakdowns in the two cases hinge on the fact that social workers and the courts pushed to reunify the children with a parent without ensuring the homes were safe. There is an incorrect perception among social workers and family courts that “reunification at all costs” is the formal policy of DCF, the report says. That misperception causes officials to incorrectly assume that reunification is more important than a child’s safety, the report says.

Part of the pressure to reunify comes from the federal government, which oversees state child welfare programs, according to Dr. Joe Hagan, a co-chairman of the Vermont Citizens Advisory Board, which created the report. “There has been a tremendous push federally for reunification,” Hagan said at a Friday news conference about the report.

DCF officials in the past and at Friday’s news conference said that reunification when it is safe for the child will continue to be the state’s policy. Officials at the news conference downplayed the report’s findings but said it is clear the department has room to improve.

“We found no wrongdoing, what we found was opportunities to do things more efficiently, more effectively,” Hagan said.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Vermont’s adult loon population is at an all-time high, but fewer chicks are surviving

July 2, 2025
By Izzy Wagner/VTDigger Vermont’s adult loon population is at an all-time high, but scientists have noticed a recent decrease in the number of chicks surviving. In 2024, Vermont saw a record-breaking 123 nesting pairs, 11 of which landed at first-time nesting sites. Out of the 125 loon chicks that hatched in 2024, 65% survived through the…

Vermont State University graduates 414 nurses, boosting local health care workforce

July 2, 2025
Vermont State University (VTSU) has graduated 414 new nurses this year, marking a significant step forward in addressing the state’s ongoing health care workforce shortage. With approximately 92% of these graduates testing for licensure in Vermont and strong NCLEX pass rates, the university continues to deliver on its promise to educate and prepare nurses who…

VT Agency of Education announces summer food service program

July 2, 2025
The Agency of Education announced the availability of summer meal sites providing meals to all children, 18 and under, through the Summer Food Service Program (SFSP). This program ensures that children across the state have access to nutritious meals throughout the summer. Families are encouraged to access these meals to help support children’s growth, health,…

Sanders restores $17m for Vt schools canceled by Trump

July 2, 2025
Senator Bernie Sanders (I-Vermont), ranking member of the Senate health, education, labor, and pensions (HELP) committee, June 27 announced that the U.S. Dept. of Education reversed its decision to cancel nearly $17 million in federal K-12 Covid-19 funding for Vermont school districts and some $2.5 billion for schools across the country. The administration’s announcement follows…