On February 10, 2021

Killington Police obtain arrest warrant for theft of services from North Star Lodge

By Curt Peterson

Killington Police Chief  Whit Montgomery told the Mountain Times the department has obtained an arrest warrant for “theft of services” from North Star Lodge on Weathervane Drive in Killington. The warrant names Katie L. Safford, 30, who maintains a Rutland address.

“I feel pretty confident [Safford] will be located and cited,” Montgomery told the Mountain Times, Feb. 8. “We have put the word out to other agencies as well. She may be living in New York state.”

“When located, Safford will be arrested and arraigned for theft of services greater than $900,” a KPD press release stated, “a felony in the state of Vermont.”

If Safford is convicted, she could face jail for up to 10 years and/or a fine of as much as $5,000.

“On Oct. 26, 2020, Safford secured one suite with a debit card and told [North Star staff] she would be paying with a new card when it arrived in the mail,” according to the press release. “She rented a second adjoining suite as her family was in need of temporary housing.”

Lodge staff saw Safford and her family drive off on Nov. 6 without paying the balance of her bill, which was over $2,000. Room damage was discovered when Lodge employees entered to service the suites.

On Jan. 7 the Killington Select Board received a letter from Dean Romano, general manager of the North Star Lodge, describing the theft – $2,300 due on their bill plus damages to their rooms equating to approximating $3,000.

Carpets and two screens had been damaged, Romano said. He was going to see if the carpets could be cleaned.

KPD officer Matthew Hoffman was given a description and license plate photos from the accused’s vehicles, and a Rutland address provided by Safford.

Chief Montgomery told the Mountain Times Romano reported a woman who said her name was “Katy” and her friend “Roger,” checked into two rooms with four minor children on Oct. 26.

One car had New York plates and the other had temporary Kentucky plates.

Montgomery told the Mountain Times KPD located the registered owner of the New York car, who said he had sold the car last summer to someone not among the North Star guests. “For the most part, temporary plates can’t be [traced],” he said.

The man who accompanied Safford at the Lodge, who called himself “Roger,” has not been identified.

“He would not be liable for theft of services since he did not make the reservation,” Montgomery said. “He could be listed as a witness, though.”

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Pride in Rutland: Flags, resistance, and showing up

June 25, 2025
By Emily Pratt Slatin Pride returned to downtown Rutland this June with more color, noise, and purpose than ever before. What began as a joyful celebration quickly became something deeper—something that felt like resistance. And belonging. And a promise that no one in this community has to stand alone. The day kicked off with the…

Plan to manage 72,000 acres of the Telephone Gap project is finalized

June 25, 2025
Staff report The U.S. Forest Service issued its final plan for managing 72,000 acres of public and private land on June 16. The proposed Telephone Gap Integrated Resource Project area is located on the Green Mountain National Forest (GMNF) within the towns of Brandon, Chittenden, Goshen, Killington, Mendon, Pittsfield, Pittsford, and Stockbridge. “The Telephone Gap project is…

Hot air balloons took flight over Quechee

June 25, 2025
By James Kent This past weekend, June 21-22, people came from all over New England to participate in the 45th annual Hot Air Balloon Festival. Music, food, games, and fun were available for all ages throughout the weekend, but the main attraction was the hot air balloons. And for those looking to see these gigantic,…

Killington residents push for skate park as town reimagines recreation future 

June 25, 2025
By Greta Solsaa/VTDigger As Killington celebrates the 50th anniversary of its recreation center, some residents are pushing to make a skate park a new permanent fixture of the town’s summer offerings.  The town crafted its recreation master plan to holistically determine how to best use its resources to serve residents in the future, Recreation Department Director Emily Hudson…