On October 7, 2020

Judge dismisses Rutland gym’s challenge to governor’s executive order

Attorney General T.J. Donovan announced on Sept. 30 that a judge has dismissed a Rutland gym’s countersuit against the state of Vermont over the governor’s pandemic-related executive order. The gym, Club Fitness of Vermont, had tried to argue that the State of Vermont should pay damages to the gym, which closed from late March through June under the Governor’s closure orders. In May, when Club Fitness of Vermont and its owner refused to stay closed, Attorney General Donovan sued the business and obtained a temporary restraining order against it. The business countersued, seeking damages for what it called an unconstitutional executive order. The countersuit has now been dismissed.

“This decision is a win for Vermonters and Vermont businesses who have done the right thing and complied with the Governor’s orders,” said Attorney General Donovan. “The Court’s ruling confirms what Vermonters know and have done: We all have to do our part because we are all in this together.”

In its decision, the Vermont Superior Court, Civil Division in Rutland found that the Covid-19-related business closure orders constitute a “public program adjusting the benefits and burdens of economic life to promote the common good.” As a result, the State is not required to reimburse businesses subject to the orders. As the Court stated: “Defendants [Club Fitness and its owner] appear not to recognize the reality of Covid-19, the state of emergencies that have been announced throughout the country, and the attempts by courts at all levels to address situations similar to the present case.”

With the Defendants’ lawsuit dismissed, the State will now proceed with its enforcement case against Club Fitness and its owner.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Superstar Six-Pack construction hits new phase as helicopters fly in concrete

July 3, 2025
KILLINGTON — Construction of the new Superstar six-pack chairlift has reached an exciting phase this summer, with helicopters now flying in concrete for the tower and terminal footings. On Wednesday, July 1, a helicopter was seen flying to Killington Resort with a payload of concrete. Killington Resort is replacing its iconic Superstar Express quad with…

Local road construction plans for 4th of July week

July 2, 2025
The following is a weekly report that lists its planned construction activities that will affect traffic on state highways and interstates throughout Vermont for the week of June 30. Most construction projects will pause work for the 4th of July `Local roads in Rutland and Windsor County, include:     I-89 Royalton Construction continues Monday through…

Ribbon cuttings in Ludlow and Proctorsville highlight local business growth

July 2, 2025
A pair of ribbon cuttings on June 20 held by the Okemo Valley Regional Chamber of Commerce (OVRCC) marked a day of celebration for two local businesses and offered a boost of momentum to the region’s small business economy. In Ludlow, Aubuchon ACE Hardware unveiled its newly renovated store on Main Street with a grand…

Cirque Series celebrates successful Killington debut

July 2, 2025
By Polly Mikula The Cirque Series broke trail in New England with two new races. On June 7, runners raced up Cannon Mountain in Franconia, New Hampshire and this past Saturday, June 28, they tackled “The Beast of the East,” Killington Mountain. Cirque is also adding Crystal Mountain, Washington, to its national lineup of eight…