On July 17, 2024
Local News

Sunnymede Farm Store wins summary judgement

By Curt Peterson

UPDATE, July 18: The HPC has chosen not to appeal the summary judgment regarding the Sunnymede store.

On July 8, the Vermont Superior Court, Environmental Division, issued a summary judgement in favor of Sunnymede Farm’s application to construct a “farm store” on the former Lamb Farm property on Route 5 in Hartland.

The judge and interested parties met at the proposed site and at Sunnymede’s farm property on May 29. At that time, according to Hartland Planning Commission (HPC) member Jay Boeri in a phone conversation with the Mountain Times, the judge suggested the litigants find some mutually acceptable compromise. Boeri said that weeks later the HPC hadn’t heard anything from Sunnymede about compromise discussions. The next development was the summary judgement.

In an accompanying letter, judge Thomas G. Walsh wrote, “The [proposed] Farm Store makes efficient use of land, energy, roads, and other infrastructure without contributing to a pattern of strip development. Furthermore, the Farm Store is properly classified as a Resource Based Commercial Use and there are no provisions within the town or Regional plans upon which to deny the project.”

Sunnymede’s proposal has been a focus of efforts by the HPC and the Two Rivers Ottauquechee Regional Planning Commission (TRORC) to stop construction of Sunnymede’s 9,000 sq. ft. retail store, take-out and eat-in deli and bakery on the now-vacant land currently used by a local farmer to produce hay.

The proposal was originally approved by the court on Sept. 18, 2023, inspiring appeals by TRORC alleging violations of their regional plan, and by HPC citing violations of their town plan.

The land is legally owned by SM Farm Shop, LLC and SMFVTMGT, LLC. Besides the two-story farm store building, the proposed improvements will include 46 parking spaces, handcapped accessability, electric vehicle charging stations and bicycle racks.

Sunnymede has warranted that 60-70% of the products sold in the store will be produced either at their farm on Town Hill Road (two miles from the site) or on the subject property, where fruit trees and bushes, and apiaries are planned. This has satisfied judge Walsh that the facility will qualify as a “Farm Store” as described in the cited plans.

Another allegation by the appellants described the farm store as a “strip mall” structure, which is prohibited in their plans. Judge Walsh disagreed, comparing the established description of a strip mall to the two-story, single occupant proposed farm store. 

The judgement cites utilities, water supply, wastewater treatment, proximity to the village center, percentage of land coverage and traffic impact as areas in which the Sunnymede plan complies with Act 250 requirements and the respective town and regional plans.

If either or both appellants want to appeal Judge Walsh’s decision, their recourse would be limited to the State Supreme Court.

The Mountain Times reached out to David Dukeshire, current chair of the HPC for comment about the judgement, but he declined “at this time.” The Mountain Times was unable to reach anyone at TRORC or Sunnymede for comment prior to deadline.  Hartland Select Board chair Phil Hobbie declined to discuss the judgment itself, saying it is a Planning Commission matter, and he doesn’t feel it appropriate for him to comment.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

M&T Bank supports community center van service

October 30, 2024
M&T Bank representatives Marcella Hay (left), retail sales manager SVP, and Tara Buxton (right), branch manager VP, present a $2,500 donation from the M&T Charitable Foundation to Jo Ann Riley (center), Castleton Community Seniors director in support of the CCSI Older Adult and Disabled Transportation Program. The CCSI van service helps older adults and disabled…

Quechee Gorge Bridge inconvenience to be extended

October 30, 2024
By Curt Peterson Drivers on Route 4 in Quechee have been calling the bridge over the gorge “Grumble Strip.” During busy times and tourist season, it can take several minutes to negotiate the way through the traffic signal and the single lane to the other end. Grumblers have a lot of company in their misery…

VARA recognizes athletes, coaches and educators / Rutland native Chuck Hughes honored

October 30, 2024
By Karen D. Lorentz The Vermont Alpine Racing Association (VARA) honored a group of student athletes, dedicated coaches, educators, and volunteers at the 2024 Awards Gala on Oct. 26 at the K-1 Lodge in Killington. A special highlight was the induction of Rutland native Chuck Hughes into the VARA Hall of Fame. Julie Woodworth, VARA…

Local residents, educators met with Interim Secretary of Ed Zoie Saunders in Woodstock

October 30, 2024
By Curt Peterson Governor Scott’s controversial appointment of senate-rejected Zoie Saunders as “interim” secretary of education, after leaving the important post vacant for a year, came with his defensive endorsement: “Once you meet her, you will know she is the right person for the job.” Secretary Saunders is touring Vermont school districts to introduce herself,…