On April 30, 2025
State News

Vermont, 11 other states sue Trump admin over tariff policies

By Gage Skidmore via Wikimedia Commons and Glenn Russell/VTDigger President Donald Trump, left, and Vermont Attorney General Charity Clark

By Habib Sabet/VTDigger

Vermont Attorney General Charity Clark is joining the top prosecutors of 11 other states in a lawsuit challenging the constitutionality of President Donald Trump’s tariff policies, the Attorney General’s office announced Wednesday, April 23.

The attorneys general, who filed the lawsuit Wednesday in the U.S. Court of International Trade in New York City, argue that Trump’s four executive orders imposing tariffs on imports from other countries violate Article I of the U.S. Constitution, which assigns Congress, not the president, the “Power To lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises.”

“President Trump’s illegal tariffs will harm Vermont’s businesses and consumers,” Clark said in a Wednesday press release announcing the suit. “I’m suing the Trump Administration for the 10th time over these illegal tariffs to protect working Vermonters, small businesses, and our economy.”

The lawsuit requests a preliminary and permanent injunction blocking U.S. Customs and Border Patrol from enforcing the tariffs. 

Since taking office, Trump has repeatedly invoked the International Economic Emergency Powers Act while issuing a flurry of executive orders unilaterally declaring levies on imported goods.

But the lawsuit argues that the 1970s-era law doesn’t grant the president the authority to impose sweeping tariffs under any circumstances. 

Moreover, the attorneys general argue in the suit, Trump has trotted out the once-obscure law under false pretenses, claiming that the tariffs are aimed at countering various alleged national security threats, such as illegal immigration and cross-border fentanyl smuggling.

“Yet over the last three months, the President has imposed, modified, escalated, and suspended tariffs by executive order, memoranda, social media post, and agency decree,” the lawsuit states. “These edicts reflect a national trade policy that now hinges on the President’s whims rather than the sound exercise of his lawful authority.”

The lawsuit is the latest in a string of legal challenges made to the Trump Administration’s tariff policy in recent weeks.

Earlier this month, California filed a lawsuit similarly questioning the constitutionality of Trump’s trade-related executive orders. 

Members of the Blackfeet Nation in Montana and two non-profits — the New Civil Liberties Alliance and the Liberty Justice Center —  have also all filed lawsuits opposing various aspects of the administration’s tariff policy in recent weeks.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

‘The winners are losers and the losers are winners’

May 21, 2025
That was how Vermont Public reporter Lola Dufort described one of the potential challenges to move to a foundation formula that is included in the education reform bill under consideration. Under a foundation financing system, which is common in most states, each school district receives a standard amount per student adjusted for certain factors like…

Statewide ban on phones in schools picks up steam

May 21, 2025
By Habib Sabet/VTDigger Vermont is on track to join a growing list of states that have banned smartphones from classrooms statewide. Last week, lawmakers in a key committee advanced legislation that would require all of the state’s public school districts and independent schools to develop policies prohibiting students from using smartphones and other personal devices like…

Deaths from opioid overdose declined significantly in 2024

May 21, 2025
Data shows first sustained annual decrease in opioid overdose deaths since 2019 New data from the Vermont Dept. of Health shows a significant decline in opioid overdose deaths last year. According to the newly-released Fatal Opioid Overdoses Among Vermonters report, 183 Vermonters died from an opioid-related overdose in 2024, a 22% decrease from 2023 when 236…

We met our match!

May 14, 2025
As I may have mentioned before, our House Appropriations Committee has a tradition of starting off each day with a short joke or riddle. Sometimes they are funny or get a laugh because they are lacking. It helps break the ice before we take testimony or discuss various expense priorities. Starting off the budget conference…