On January 25, 2023

Plymouth Cheese prepares expansion plans in Bridgewater

By Katy Savage

Plymouth Artisan Cheese has a new pop-up shop in the Bridgewater Mill Mall in an effort to restore new life into the old building. 

Plymouth Cheese owners Jesse and Sarit Werner became majority owners of the building in March 2022 after a multi-year legal battle with previous owners Andrea Curutchet and Jireh Billings. 

Sarit Werner said the pop-up shop is temporary as Plymouth Cheese prepares to expand and open a second retail store in the former Bridgewater Mill Mall — now called Bridgewater Mill.

“Things are slow-moving in this economy,” said Werner, explaining her family is obtaining permits. “That’s why we wanted to maximize momentum and build this pop up.” 

The pop-up shop opened at the beginning of December. The Werners plan to turn the Bridgewater Mill into a maker space for artists and performers in addition to a food hub.

“We’re in the food space,” Werner said. “We’re tying to gather like-minded businesses.”

The Werners bought Billings’ and Curutchet’s 69,000 square foot portion of the Bridgewater Mill, totaling 75% for $563,000 last March. Furniture and pottery maker ShackletonThomas owns the other 25% of the building.

The Werners’ pursuit of the building started six years ago, when they purchased a storage shed in the Bridgewater Mill for Plymouth Cheese.

The owners disagreed over association fees, taxes and sewer payments to the town. The town put the Bridgewater Mill up for tax sale in 2019 due to a delinquent sewer bill.  

“We really fought for this,” Werner said. “We could have walked away easily. We really persevered.”

Werner said there are 10 tenants in the building, including a hair studio, a post office, Ramuntos Pizza and an art gallery. 

“Everybody’s here,” she said. “Everybody’s happy. We’ve started a new chapter. We’re in it for the long-haul. This is just the beginning.”

The cheese shop is open from 11 a.m to 4 p.m. Thursday-Sunday. 

The owners are looking for new tenants.

“We’re open to all ideas,” Werner said. “Bring your paintbrush.”

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Downtown Rutland hotel project moves forward as mayoral election looms

February 20, 2025
By James Kent At a press event Thursday morning, Feb. 20, Mayor Doenges and developers from Center & Wales LLC signed a letter of intent, marking a formal commitment to move forward with the $40 million investment that will reshape the corner of Center and Wales streets. The project will bring a seven-story, mixed-use building…

Candidates for Killington Select Board answer questions

February 19, 2025
Tuesday night, Feb. 18,the  Killington Pico Area Association (KPAA) held a forum for the four candidates vying for two seats on the Killington Select Board. One seat is for a 3-year term; the other a 1-year term. Incumbent Chris Karr will face a challenge from Patrick Cushing for the 3-year seat. Karr is the owner…

Richard T. Godfrey, Jr., 96

February 19, 2025
Richard T. Godfrey, Jr., beloved husband, father, and grandfather, died of natural causes on Wednesday, Feb.12, at the White River Junction VA Medical Center.  “Dick” was born July 08, 1928, in Norton, Massachusetts, to Richard T. Godfrey, Sr., and Grace (Howard) Godfrey. In 1946, he graduated from Segreganset Agricultural School in Segreganset, Massachusetts. Upon graduation,…

Rutland County employers get over $100,000 in unclaimed property

February 19, 2025
Vermont Treasurer Mike Pieciak joined Rutland Mayor Mike Doenges on Thursday, Feb. 13, to return over $100,000 of unclaimed property to Rutland County employers. The event was held in connection with the Treasurer’s Claim Your Money campaign, an effort to return at least $1 million of unclaimed property to Vermonters in the month of February.…