On October 5, 2022

Aldermen discuss defunding Redevelopment Authority

By Katy Savage

Some members of the Rutland Board of Alderman criticized the Rutland Redevelopment Authority for not being proactive or collaborative enough at the board’s Oct. 3 meeting.

Alderman Thomas Franco made a motion to defund the Rutland Redevelopment Authority (RRA) and “use our taxpayers dollars to actually further economic development in very clear terms.”

Franco proposed the RRA essentially move forward without RRA Executive Director Brennan Duffy to focus on grant administration and “allocating resources for proactive economic development strategies with other entities.”

The board quickly tabled the motion but continued the discussion.

Alderman Chris Ettori called the RRA “broken” and said he’s been concerned for a decade about its “lack of collaboration and lack of active projects.”

Ettori called Duffy a “gatekeeper, not a facilitator,” explaining, “He has described himself as that.”

While Duffy was not present at the meeting, Mayor David Allaire said the discussion was “unfortunate.”

“I think it’s unfortunate to have this discussion without Brennan being here to defend himself,” Allaire said.

Allaire, who was elected mayor six years ago, said he’s seen different approaches to economic development.

“Economic development means different things to many different people,” he said.

Allaire and RRA leaders said Franco gave little notice prior to his motion. Allaire said he was informed of the motion 2 1/2 hours prior to the meeting and he would have prepared better, but Franco defended his motion.

“It’s truly alarming even after a two-hour heads up our top leadership cannot give us any idea of what economic development means for our city or what strategies are in place or what goals or objectives we have,” Franco said. “Taxpayers deserve to have real leadership in this space.”

Alderman Bill Gillam, Jr., who was part of starting the RRA in the 1980s, called the discussion a political attempt to sway votes for the impending November election. (Allaire’s mayorship is one of the contested seats, challenged by Alderman President Mike Doenges).

“I don’t think this should be a football for politics,” Gillam said. “I think this witch hunt we’re going after here is not the right way to do this.”

The board voted to move the discussion to the Board of Aldermen’s economic development committee.

Franco, who is the Board of Aldermen’s representative to the RRA, clarified during the meeting that he wasn’t attempting to single Duffy out.

“I’m truly disappointed this is seen as a witch hunt or attack on anyone or anything when this is really about the city’s best interests,” he said.

Duffy, who has been with the RRA for the past 11 years, said he watched the meeting on a live-stream from home.

“I was really kind of disappointed and surprised,” Duffy said in a phone interview after the meeting, explaining personnel discussions are usually reserved for executive sessions. “I feel like I’ve given my heart and soul to the redevelopment authority. I feel pretty unappreciated at the moment.”

Duffy is one of two employees at the Rutland Redevelopment Authority. The Board of Aldermen and RRA signed a five year-agreement of services in 2018, which is due for renewal in 2023. As part of the agreement, the Board of Aldermen contributes about $50,000 each quarter to the RRA’s annual budget of just under $500,000. The RRA also levies taxes and gives about $280,000 to the Downtown Rutland Partnership.

Duffy said the RRA intentionally takes a passive role in economic development.

“I’ve received very specific direction (from the RRA board), we want to be facilitating work with these other entities in our community,” Duffy said.

RRA chair Ed Clark said he was disappointed Franco didn’t discuss his concerns about the RRA prior to the meeting.

“I felt disparaged by what he said,” Clark said.

Clark, who received an email from Franco prior to the motion, questioned Franco’s intentions and said despite Franco’s role as being a liaison between the two boards, Franco has only attended a few RRA meetings.

Clark was hopeful the RRA and Board of Aldermen could reach an agreement.

“You need to evolve and change with the times,” Clark said. “I certainly would like to think we can do that with the group of people we have. I don’t know that the feeling is mutual.”

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Pride in Rutland: Flags, resistance, and showing up

June 25, 2025
By Emily Pratt Slatin Pride returned to downtown Rutland this June with more color, noise, and purpose than ever before. What began as a joyful celebration quickly became something deeper—something that felt like resistance. And belonging. And a promise that no one in this community has to stand alone. The day kicked off with the…

Plan to manage 72,000 acres of the Telephone Gap project is finalized

June 25, 2025
Staff report The U.S. Forest Service issued its final plan for managing 72,000 acres of public and private land on June 16. The proposed Telephone Gap Integrated Resource Project area is located on the Green Mountain National Forest (GMNF) within the towns of Brandon, Chittenden, Goshen, Killington, Mendon, Pittsfield, Pittsford, and Stockbridge. “The Telephone Gap project is…

Hot air balloons took flight over Quechee

June 25, 2025
By James Kent This past weekend, June 21-22, people came from all over New England to participate in the 45th annual Hot Air Balloon Festival. Music, food, games, and fun were available for all ages throughout the weekend, but the main attraction was the hot air balloons. And for those looking to see these gigantic,…

Killington residents push for skate park as town reimagines recreation future 

June 25, 2025
By Greta Solsaa/VTDigger As Killington celebrates the 50th anniversary of its recreation center, some residents are pushing to make a skate park a new permanent fixture of the town’s summer offerings.  The town crafted its recreation master plan to holistically determine how to best use its resources to serve residents in the future, Recreation Department Director Emily Hudson…