On April 20, 2022

From natural ingredients to handmade soap, how a self-taught local soapmaker crafts her wares

When she retired from her career in information technology during the height of the Covid-19 pandemic, Andi Lutter of Hartland didn’t pack up for a sunny life of leisure. Instead, she taught herself the art of handmade cold-process soapmaking, and launched a small business.

Courtesy of Andi Lutter

“All my soaps are handmade, by me, in small batches in my Hartland kitchen,” said Lutter. She learned soapmaking by scouring the internet for online how-to videos, and perfected her process through trial and error. In 2021, OutsideIn Soaps, LLC was born.

From the start, Lutter was determined that unlike commercial products, her soaps would feature only all-natural vegetable and essential oils. No detergents. No preservatives. No artificial fragrances.

The process requires precision with recipes and temperatures. When the oils are combined with sodium hydroxide (or lye), a process called “saponification” occurs. “The result is pure soap and glycerin – the lye is no more,” Lutter said.

The saponification process requires at least 24-48 hours to complete. The soap can then be removed from the mold, hand-cut by Lutter and left to set for up to four to six weeks. It’s then ready to use.

Lutter’s creativity is on full display in everything from natural aromatherapy ingredients like eucalyptus and frankincense, to clever packaging and novel gift concepts. The “Stone Collection” soaps look uncannily like rounded river stones of gray or pink granite. Each is hand wrapped with twine and a Chinese feng shui coin. For Mother’s Day, some offerings are combined with a bamboo face cloth and a stone heart charm. For St. On Patrick’s Day and Father’s Day, a special batch called “Suds O’ Stout” was on tap. Brewed up with Guinness Stout as its not-so-secret ingrediant, the rich brown bars look like a pint glass with a frothy head of suds, each bar embossed with a shamrock.

“Because they are hand cut, no two are exactly the same,” says Lutter. “Most bars average between 4.5 and 5 ounces, and if one seems a little light to me, customers catch me slipping an extra bar into their order.”

OutsideIn soaps are available for $7 apiece. For more information visit: OutsideInSoaps.com.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

VTSU names John Casella 2025 Castleton commencement speaker

April 23, 2025
Vermont State University (VTSU) is graduating its second class this spring on May 17-18, 2025 and has announced a remarkable lineup of commencement speakers for the four ceremonies, held at the Castleton, Lyndon, Johnson, and Randolph campuses over the weekend.  “We are delighted to welcome distinguished alumni and campus community leaders John Casella, Greg Tatro,…

Rutland affordable housing project earns state award for energy excellence

April 23, 2025
RUTLAND— A historic home on River Street in Rutland has been recognized among Vermont’s top energy-efficient building projects, earning a “Best of the Best” award at Efficiency Vermont’s annual Better Building by Design (BBD) conference. The award, presented to Hildebrand Homes, LLC, highlights a creative and forward-thinking approach to affordable housing that aligns energy efficiency…

Youth turkey-calling contest draws record participation

April 23, 2025
CASTLETON— A record-breaking 33 young participants, ranging in age from 2 to 18, showcased their best gobbles, clucks, and yelps at the 19th annual Bart Jacob Memorial Youth Turkey Calling Contest on April 12 at Kehoe Conservation Camp in Castleton. Sponsored by the Oxbow Mountain 4-H Club and underwritten by the Vermont Fish and Wildlife…

How Killington became The Beast: Part 7

April 23, 2025
By Karen D. Lorentz Editors’ Note: This is part of a series on the factors that enabled Killington to become The Beast of the East. Quotations are from author interviews in the 1980s for the book “Killington, A Story of Mountains and Men.” Despite the two-year delay to Killington’s debut—caused by the access road not…