On September 15, 2021

FBI opens criminal probe into 3 troopers over fake Covid-19 vaccination cards

By Alan J. Keays/VTDigger

Three Vermont State Police troopers out of the Shaftsbury barracks have resigned and a criminal probe is underway to determine whether they may have violated federal law by making fake Covid-19 vaccination cards.

The matter has been referred to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Vermont, as well as the FBI, which is investigating, according to a statement released by the Vermont State Police Tuesday afternoon, Sept. 7.

Courtesy of Vermont State Police
Pictured (l-r): Raymond Witkowski, David Pfindel and Shawn Sommers.

Michael Schirling, commissioner of the Vermont Dept. of Public Safety, said he couldn’t comment beyond the statement.  “Because there’s an ongoing federal investigation, I can’t get into in any more detail than what’s in the release,” he said.

Two of the troopers, Shawn Sommers and Raymond Witkowski, submitted their resignations on Aug. 10, according to the state police statement. That’s a day after another trooper brought the matter to a supervisor.

As a result of further investigation by the state Dept. of Public Safety, the third trooper, David Pfindel, resigned effective Sept. 3.

According to the statement, the troopers “are suspected of having varying roles in the creation of fraudulent Covid-19 vaccination cards,” a possible violation of federal law.

Authorities have not said why the troopers allegedly made the cards or whom they may have been providing them to.

“The accusations in this case involve an extraordinary level of misconduct — a criminal violation of the law — and I could not be more upset and disappointed,” said Col. Matthew T. Birmingham, director of the Vermont State Police.

“If these allegations are proved to be true,” he said, “it is reprehensible that state troopers would manipulate vaccination cards in the midst of a pandemic, when being vaccinated is one of the most important steps anyone can take to keep their community safe from Covid-19.”

He also said that he is “embarrassed” by what took place and knows the Vermont State Police has had its reputation tarnished.

“That said, the alleged criminal conduct from these troopers does not represent the values and actions of the dedicated men and women of the Vermont State Police,” Birmingham said.

Schirling, in the statement, said other troopers contacted their supervisors as soon as they became aware of the situation.

Sommers and Witkowski both joined the state police in 2016. Pfindel was hired in 2014.

Vermont Defender General Matthew Valerio said late Tuesday afternoon that it’s unclear what effect the troopers’ resignation could have on the prosecution of criminal cases they had worked on, although he noted there could be “some impact on their cases if credibility is an issue in the cases.”

Witkowski was involved in a case in January 2019 in which he shot and wounded a man in Arlington who police said had fired multiple shots at troopers.

Vermont Attorney General TJ Donovan cleared Witkowski of criminal wrongdoing in the case, ruling that the trooper’s use of force was justified.

The Arlington man who was wounded, Matthew Novick, was later sentenced to two years in jail on a charge of aggravated assault with a weapon, the Manchester Journal reported at the time. The newspaper also reported that Witkowski objected to that sentence for Novick as too light.

“This is more than a disappointment,” Witkowski told the court. “This is a slap in the face to me, not only as a victim but as a law enforcement professional who dedicated his life to fair and equal pursuit of justice.”

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Floods to fires, officials warn Vermonters should to protect their lungs with Quebec fires expected again

July 17, 2024
By Kate Kampner, Community News Service The warning came Monday: The most extreme wildfires on Earth are on the rise — more frequent, more intense.  A study in the journal Nature Ecology and Evolution found that across the planet wildfires have doubled in the last two decades.  As neighbors to some of the most intense wildfires reported, Vermonters might…

Where is the state road construction this week? 

July 17, 2024
The Vermont Agency of Transportation (VTrans) published its weekly report of planned construction activities that will impact traffic on state highways and interstates throughout Vermont, July 15-19 and ongoing. I-91 Springfield-Hartland: Multiple single-lane closures will be in place along I-91 southbound from north of Exit 9 to just south of Exit 7 while a paving…

Hartland seeks donations for conservation land

July 10, 2024
By Curt Peterson On July 5 Rob Anderegg, chair of the Hartland Conservation Commission, posted an update regarding the “Pohl Property Conservation Project” on the local listserv. “We are getting close to the goal,” Anderegg wrote. “Only $17,000 needs to be raised to finish the job.” The Hartland Conservation Commission added an article to the…

Vermont selected for new federal model to improve health care affordability and quality

July 10, 2024
The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) announced July 2 that it has accepted Vermont’s application to participate in the states advancing All-Payer Health Equity Approaches and Development (AHEAD) program. AHEAD offers Vermont an opportunity to collaborate with the federal government to impact how Medicare, the health insurer for 24% of Vermonters, pays for…