On December 2, 2020

Rutland City police officer will not be prosecuted for non-fatal officer-involved shooting

Use of force analyzed under both current Vermont law and new statute

The Attorney General’s Office is declining to prosecute Rutland City Police Department Officer Tyler Billings, who was responsible for the non-fatal shooting of Michael Goodnough, 45, of Rutland.

Attorney General T.J. Donovan announced Nov. 24 that his office concluded its review of the officer-involved shooting that occurred on July 8, 2020, in Rutland.

Based on the facts and circumstances, and consistent with Vermont law, the Attorney General’s Office has concluded that the actions of Officer Billings were justified.

In anticipation of Vermont’s new statute addressing use of force by police officers, the lawfulness of this shooting was also analyzed under Act 165, which goes into effect on July 1, 2021 and was modeled after a California statute. Under the new statute, the use of force would also have been justified because, based on the totality of the circumstances, it was both reasonable and necessary to protect Officer Nathan Harvey from an imminent threat of death or serious bodily injury.

In reaching the decision, the Attorney General’s Office reviewed all the materials provided by the Vermont State Police, who conducted the investigation. These materials included statements of the officers involved and civilian witnesses, video footage, and a ballistics examination of the weapon used to carry out the shooting.

As noted above, when Officer Billings deployed his weapon, Officer Harvey was lying on the ground just inches away from the front wheel of the suspect’s vehicle as the vehicle began to move forward. Moreover, Officer Billings had just witnessed Officer Harvey being dragged by the open door of the suspect’s vehicle, which he then saw collide with Officer Harvey’s cruiser, throwing him to the ground.

Under the totality of these circumstances, a reasonable officer in Officer Billings’ position would undoubtedly have concluded that there was an imminent threat to Officer Harvey’s life and that to save his life, there was no reasonable alternative to the use of deadly force. Moreover, once the driver no longer posed a threat to Officer’s Harvey’s life, Officer Billings stopped deploying his weapon. Therefore, applying the standard of Act 165 would have the same conclusion: Officer Billings’ use of deadly force in this case was justified.

Windham County State’s Attorney Tracy Kelly Shriver, who reviewed this matter for the Rutland County State’s Attorney’s Office, also conducted an independent, concurrent review of the same materials and has also declined to file charges against Officer Billings.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Robert Hecker appointed to Killington Select Board

May 15, 2024
By Curt Peterson Robert Hecker has been appointed to take Steve Finneron’s seat on the Killington Select Board. The announcement came after an executive session Monday night May 13. The position lasts until next Town Meeting Day vote, when voters will choose the person to fulfill the remaining year of Finneron’s term.  Hecker was one…

Town resolves eminent domain 

May 15, 2024
Deal with landowner called ‘win-win’ By Polly Mikula The town of Killington will not pursue an eminent domain hearing scheduled for May 20, having recently resolved the case with the landowner.  Eva Nagymihaly and her sister, Theresa Rust, own land on the east side at the base of Killington Road to the intersection with Route…

Logging company fined for wetland and water quality impacts in Bridgewater, Thetford

May 15, 2024
The Agency of Natural Resources Dept. of Environmental Conservation (DEC) and Vermont Forests, Parks, and Recreation (FPR) announced May 8 that Thomson Timber Harvesting and Trucking LLC (Thompson Timber), a company that performs logging activities in Vermont, was fined $32,550 for violating the Vermont Wetland Rules and failing to follow acceptable management practices (AMPs) for…

Wonderfeet Kids’ Museum celebrates expansion

May 15, 2024
By Polly Mikula Saturday, May 11, Wonderfeet Kids’ Museum held a grand opening celebration from 10 a.m.-2 p.m. on Merchants Row downtown. While the museum relocated to its current location (66 Merchants Row) last spring, this was the first time the organization has celebrated that expansion. The move allowed Wonderfeet Kids’ Museum to tripled in size with new…