On May 21, 2020

Right ideas wrongly applied

By Sen. Dick McCormack

The pandemic, its economic fallout, and the resulting social and personal stresses, all beg for analysis. What’s going on? What are proper responses? What mistakes are being made? What fundamental problems are exposed?

I’m grateful for the informed, insightful, indeed wise communications I’ve been getting from concerned citizens. It’s gratifying when constituents and I agree. It’s a challenging opportunity for deepened understanding when we don’t.

Even wrongheaded ideas contribute to the discussion. To believe in free speech is to trust that, overall, good ideas will prevail over bad ideas in the competitive “marketplace of ideas.” More harmful than wrong ideas are right ideas wrongly applied.

The present Covid discussion has many examples.

The right to an opinion

I suggest that it’s a right idea that everyone has an equal right to an opinion, and an equal right to argue for his/her opinion. But this right idea is wrongly applied when taken to mean all opinions are equal. Bob Dylan sang: “You’re right from your side and I’m right from mine.” Hippies believed that “everyone has their own truth.” Popular pseudo psychology tells us to “trust your feelings.” The rightwing version is when Fox News claims to be “fair and balanced” by airing “both sides” in reporting on climate science.

But this claimed equality of all opinions equates the proven with the unproven, or even with the disproven, making intelligent discernment impossible. The learned scientific consensus on global warming, for example, is not merely a show of hands among the world’s climate scientists, but a recognition that the thesis has endured the rigors of the scientific method and “the thing has been proven” (QED). Conversely, as with Covid-19, various nonsensical claims have been proven wrong. You can’t cure a virus by drinking bleach. The pandemic is not a “hoax.”

A legislator disagreeing with a citizen’s opinion does not deny the citizen the right to an opinion, or the right to promote an opinion. But those rights do not extend to a “right” to be agreed with. I remain unpersuaded that there is a God-given right to spread a deadly virus, or that social distancing is part of a plot to destroy freedom. No one is less free because a legislator does not buy his/her argument.

The contingency of all science

Another right idea is that all science requires perpetual skepticism and open-mindedness and that dogma is fundamentally unscientific. All accepted scientific claims are contingent on proof achieved via the scientific method. Such proof is always subject to being revisited and potentially reconsidered. There were once five planets, eventually nine, then back down to eight. I came to the concept of contingency early. My father, a physics teacher, started all his answers to scientific questions with, “the accepted theory is…” Scientifically, the truth is like the speed of light, something that can be approached but not attained.

The wrong application of this right idea is the nihilistic view that because scientific understandings are contingent, they therefore have no actual truth value, that all claims are equal, and that to favor the proven over the disproven is to be dogmatic. Thus, we hear “the jury is still out on global warming,” “vaccines cause autism” or Covid can be cured by this or that unproven method, and to disagree is being dogmatic.

Such arguments are not calls for skepticism and open-mindedness.

They are intellectually sloppy.

Scientists who dissent from science-based agreements are free to submit their alternative hypotheses to the rigors of the scientific process, to disprove the accepted science, and to prove their alternative hypotheses. But until the dissenters achieve that proof, we scientific laity, including policy makers, must rely on the established science.

Yes, all science is “only a theory” but a theory that enjoys a high level of discerning confidence.

I don’t plan on jumping off any high cliffs simply because gravity is “only a theory.”

Pseudo science is frustrating. But the worst of it is that the pseudo science regarding Covid undermines our ability as a society to combat a deadly enemy.

. Sen. Dick McCormack from Bethel represents the three-member at-large Windsor County district in the Vermont Senate

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Vt legislators introduce bi-partisan bill to phase out tax on Social Security benefits

January 29, 2025
Vermont legislators are calling for support on a bill that seeks to exempt Social Security benefits from state income tax, a move aimed at easing financial burdens for retirees while aligning Vermont with most other states. This proposed legislation, H.74, has over 60 co-sponsors from across all parties and from all corners of the state.  Currently, Vermont is one of…

New effort to cap Vt hospital executive pay is underway

January 29, 2025
On Thursday, Jan. 23, a coalition of Vermont state legislators and healthcare workers, in partnership with the office of Senator Bernie Sanders, unveiled a bill that would task the Green Mountain Care Board with moving healthcare resources to the front lines of patient care amidst a deepening healthcare crisis.  The bill, which was introduced on…

Pieciak announces plan to eliminate $100m in medical debt

January 29, 2025
 Last Tuesday, Jan. 21, Treasurer Mike Pieciak, Senator Ginny Lyons, and Representative Alyssa Black announced a proposal to provide medical debt relief to thousands of Vermonters. The proposal would eliminate up to $100 million in medical debt for a one-time investment of $1 million. Further, the proposal would protect Vermonters’ credit scores by eliminating the…

State economists tout strong economy but warn of uncertainty under Trump

January 29, 2025
By Shaun Robinson/VTDigger Vermont’s economy, and the country’s as a whole, is in “exceptional” shape, the state’s economists told a panel of top fiscal lawmakers Wednesday, Jan. 22 — but cautioned their outlook was tempered by uncertainty over the actions President Donald Trump has pledged to take, or already taken, early on in his second term.…