On May 8, 2019

Benson Village Store destroyed in fire

Staff report

The historic Benson Village Store has closed due to a fire last week.

“My guess is that it will be declared a total loss,” said Benson Fire Chief Tom Newmann.

The fire started around 2 a.m. April 29.

Store owner James Tillman, who lived upstairs, was asleep at the time, Newmann said.

“Before we arrived on scene,  folks had discovered the fire. While some were calling 911, others were trying to get him awake and out of the second floor,” Newmann said.

Several people placed a 6 foot step ladder in the bed of a pickup truck and climbed up to the porch roof, broke an upstairs bedroom window with a broom and woke up Tillman.

Tillman had cuts on his hands from climbing through the window, but he was safe, according to a press release.

Newmann said the fire started in the basement.

“The investigation is pointing it to be an electrical start to the fire,” Newmann said.

The historic building, which had been through several renovations, made it difficult for firefighters, Newmann said.

“There were inaccessible areas,” he said.

Newmann said they had to cut the floorboards to get to the hot spots in the basement because the stairwell to the basement collapsed.

Firefighters remained at the store for two days to fully extinguish the flames.

“We had a lot of active fire,” Newmann said.

The structure of the building also made it unsafe for investigators to do a complete investigation.

The fire travelled from the basement up a rear stairwell, spreading this fire throughout the structure and roof areas.   

Attempts to reach Tillman and co-owner Robin Morzella weren’t successful.

Tillman, who has owned the store since 2017, said on Facebook that he is working with insurance agents.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Killington Recreation gears up for a summer of fun at the Johnson Recreation Center

June 11, 2025
KILLINGTON — With a hopeful nod to clearer skies after a rainy May, the Killington Recreation Dept. is preparing for a summer packed with activities, events, and community connections. The Johnson Recreation Center will serve as the hub for the town’s seasonal offerings, with programs for all ages beginning in mid-June. Johnson Recreation Pool opens…

Bridge replacement underway in Plymouth, Route 100A

June 11, 2025
Drivers traveling along Route 100A should prepare for ongoing delays and a full closure later this summer as construction ramps up on Bridge 9 in Plymouth. The Vermont Agency of Transportation (VTrans) has initiated a long-term project to replace the aging structure over Pinney Hollow Brook. A southbound lane closure is currently in effect near…

Over 30 young anglers reel in big fun at Fran Renner Youth Fishing Derby

June 11, 2025
More than 30 eager young anglers lined the pond at the Mendon Fish and Game Club on June 8 for the 2025 Fran Renner Youth Fishing Derby. With 300 brook trout freshly stocked for the occasion, the annual event delivered a morning full of excitement, friendly competition, and family camaraderie. Now in its 40-plus year…

Fact: TIF builds education and municipal funds

June 11, 2025
The cost of living in Vermont continues to rise, especially in communities with greater affordability challenges but with fewer resources to invest in major infrastructure projects necessary to address those needs. A recent bill that passed in the Vermont Legislature aims to allow communities to leverage the same financing model behind TIF for small-scale housing…