On July 20, 2017

Man who settled suit over drug arrest is jailed on new charges in Rutland

By Alan Keays/VTDigger

A Richmond man who recently settled a lawsuit for $100,000 with the city of Burlington over allegations that a former officer lied to make drug charges stick is now behind bars facing new drug charges.

Michael P. Mullen, 26, was arraigned Monday in Rutland Superior Court on felony charges of possessing cocaine with the intent to sell and possessing marijuana, as well as a misdemeanor count of operating a motor vehicle with a suspended license.

Mullen invoked his right to wait 24 hours before entering a plea. He was ordered jailed for lack of $50,000 bail pending a hearing Tuesday afternoon.

Rutland County State’s Attorney Rose Kennedy had requested Monday that the $50,000 bail be continued while the case remains pending.

Steven Zwicky, Mullen’s court-appointed public defender, had been seeking his client’s release on conditions before asking a judge for additional time to make his bail argument.

Despite recently reported news that Mullen had settled a lawsuit for $100,000, he was appointed a public defender Monday with a $50 copay.

Rutland police said Mullen was arrested in the city’s downtown around 3:50 p.m. Saturday when he was pulled over for driving his 2007 Saturn Ion without a front license plate.

Police said Mullen’s driver’s license was suspended and that a search showed he had a felony amount of cocaine. Also, police said, a search of the vehicle revealed a felony amount of marijuana.

No charges were filed against passengers in Mullen’s vehicle at the time of the stop.

The Burlington Free Press reported this month that Mullen would receive $100,000 in a settlement with the city of Burlington and an officer who no longer works for the department over allegations that his rights were violated.

Mullen had been arrested on a felony charge of cocaine possession after a traffic stop in October for having a license plate light out.

Body camera footage contradicted Burlington Police Officer Christopher Lopez’s sworn written statement that he smelled marijuana coming from Mullen’s car, justifying searches of Mullen and the vehicle.

Mullen spent four months in jail before that case was thrown out. Lopez has since resigned from the Burlington Police Department, and the Vermont attorney general’s office initiated a criminal review of the officer’s actions.

John Treadwell, head of the attorney general’s criminal division, could not immediately be reached Monday for comment on the status of that probe.

Mullen filed his lawsuit in May.

In the Rutland case, police said after the traffic stop Saturday a later search of Mullen turned up several plastic baggies of crack cocaine and powdered cocaine totaling about 88 grams, or a little more than 3 ounces.

In the vehicle, police said, they also found about 2 ounces of marijuana.

Rutland City Police Patrol Commander Matthew Prouty said Monday afternoon that the department does not currently use body cameras.

He said the department’s cruisers are equipped with dash cameras. He said the department wouldn’t release any dash cam video of Saturday’s arrest to the public while the case is pending.

If convicted of the most recent charges, Mullen faces up to 15 years in prison.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Killington Recreation gears up for a summer of fun at the Johnson Recreation Center

June 11, 2025
KILLINGTON — With a hopeful nod to clearer skies after a rainy May, the Killington Recreation Dept. is preparing for a summer packed with activities, events, and community connections. The Johnson Recreation Center will serve as the hub for the town’s seasonal offerings, with programs for all ages beginning in mid-June. Johnson Recreation Pool opens…

Bridge replacement underway in Plymouth, Route 100A

June 11, 2025
Drivers traveling along Route 100A should prepare for ongoing delays and a full closure later this summer as construction ramps up on Bridge 9 in Plymouth. The Vermont Agency of Transportation (VTrans) has initiated a long-term project to replace the aging structure over Pinney Hollow Brook. A southbound lane closure is currently in effect near…

Over 30 young anglers reel in big fun at Fran Renner Youth Fishing Derby

June 11, 2025
More than 30 eager young anglers lined the pond at the Mendon Fish and Game Club on June 8 for the 2025 Fran Renner Youth Fishing Derby. With 300 brook trout freshly stocked for the occasion, the annual event delivered a morning full of excitement, friendly competition, and family camaraderie. Now in its 40-plus year…

Fact: TIF builds education and municipal funds

June 11, 2025
The cost of living in Vermont continues to rise, especially in communities with greater affordability challenges but with fewer resources to invest in major infrastructure projects necessary to address those needs. A recent bill that passed in the Vermont Legislature aims to allow communities to leverage the same financing model behind TIF for small-scale housing…