On January 15, 2016

Newly named Rutland Herald/Times Argus publisher charged with DUI, leaving an accident

Photo courtesy of Rutland City Police Department

CATHERINE NELSON

By Elizabeth Hewitt, VTDigger.org

Rutland City Police confirmed that Catherine Nelson, who was just named publisher to lead the Rutland Herald and Times Argus, was arrested on Dec. 26 and faces charges of drunk driving and leaving the scene of an accident.

Police say Nelson was arrested after 8 p.m. Saturday, after police responded to a call from the Howe Center in Rutland. Nelson crashed into a porch and a guardrail. She then crashed into the Westminster Cracker Company building. A breathalyzer test showed that her blood alcohol level was more than twice the legal limit.

The newspaper owners announced Tuesday morning, Dec. 29, just days after the arrest, that Nelson would take the helm from the longtime publisher R. John Mitchell.

Nelson, 64, currently the company’s vice president and CEO, joined the company in 2006. She did not return calls for comment Tuesday. Mitchell and other representatives from the newspaper were also unavailable.

Mitchell’s family has owned the Rutland Herald since 1946 and the Times Argus since 1964. He began selling advertising for the company in 1965, and took over as publisher in 1979.

Mitchell told staff at both newspapers that he would be stepping down during a meeting Monday afternoon. He will remain president and chairman of the board, according to the announcement.

Mitchell’s son, Rob Mitchell, the current editor of the Rutland Herald, will be the editor-in-chief of both newspapers.

The company announced that the New England Business Journals, which the family acquired in 2003, would also cease to be printed independently at the end of January. There are plans to incorporate the journal as an insert in the Sunday newspapers. One position in the sales department has been cut, and, under the plans, four field editor jobs will be eliminated as well. Many of those individuals also freelance for the Business Journals, according to the announcement.

The Herald’s circulation has declined from a peak of 25,000 copies to 11,800 currently. The announcement noted that ad revenues have been flat, impacted by the departure of Sears and J.C. Penney.

“I told the staff we’ve had a difficult 10 years our industry has taken,” Nelson said in the announcement. “But just like the Rutland community, we have a renaissance, and we think we’re going in the right way.”

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

CEDRR receives $2,500 Smart Growth Award

June 4, 2025
The Vermont Natural Resources Council announced the latest grant recipients for the Small Grants for Smart Growth program, May 27. Grantee selections are made on a rolling basis. The committee chose the Bridport Housing Task Force, the Chamber & Economic Development of the Rutland Region (CEDRR), and the South Burlington Energy Committee to be awarded a combined $6,750 in the most recent…

Public notice: East Mountain Road Paving postponed till Tuesday, May 27.

May 23, 2025
KILLINGTON—Temporary paving of East Mountain Road is delayed due to weather until Tuesday, May 27. The area will remain gravel until then, and is open to all traffic.  Please get in touch with the Killington Public Works Director, Abbie Sherman, at 802-712-4243 or [email protected] with any questions or concerns.

Stafford Technical Center students construct planter boxes for Castleton seniors in time for spring planting

May 21, 2025
Stafford Technical Center students Tyler Gugliotta (left), Charlie Souza (middle), and Paden Lynch (right), as well as staff in the RHS EPIC After School Program Carpentry Club, constructed seven new planter boxes for the Castleton Community Seniors Wellness Center entrance.

Learning can be sweet!

May 21, 2025
Mrs. Jodi Schneider’s pre-Kindergarten students are in the middle of a unit of study about ice cream. As part of the unit, they needed to find an expert in the field to answer questions that they haven’t found yet. Ben Pilsmaker from Mountain Creamery presented to the class on Monday, May 19, how he makes…