On June 5, 2015

Rutland’s Tom Poole is one of two finalists in statewide home brew competition

Tom Poole wearing an Ommegang shirt

Tom Poole

By Polly Lynn

WOODSTOCK — Friday, May 29, Tom Poole of Rutland entered  Worthy Kitchen where his home brew was being served in a taste-off with fellow finalist Brett Seymour, of Warren, Vt. It’s the final days of a home brew competition that drew over 250 entries from amateur brewers statewide. Poole is a contender to win the entire challenge. The winner of the Make The Cut Homebrew Challenge will be announced the week of the Vermont Brewers Festival, which takes place July 17-18 at Burlington Waterfront Park.

The Make the Cut Home Brew Challenge, was created by the Beverage Warehouse and 14th Star Brewing Company with the goal of giving an aspiring Vermont home brewer the chance to compete commercially.

The hundreds of home brews submitted for the competition were judged by a panel of professional and amateur judges, who selected two finalists to brew a limited 120-gallon batch of their beer. These batches were then sold in tasting pairs at six participating Vermont craft beer meccas (Worthy Kitchen in Woodstock, Farm House Tap & Grille in Burlington, Mule Bar in Winooski, Prohibition Pig in Waterbury, Three Penny Taproom in Montpelier and 14th Star Brewing Co. in Saint Albans) along with a ballot for public voting. The ballots along with the judges’ scores will combine to determine the winner of the Make the Cut Home Brew Challenge.

Tom Poole’s entry was a Belgian Witbier. Poole, a physical therapist by profession, has been brewing beer at home for about eight years, experimenting with different recipes. “I never brew the same beer twice,” he said Friday at Worthy Kitchen in Woodstock. Rather, Poole likes to alter the proportions and ingredients in search of the perfect pint for family and friends to enjoy. When asked if he were pleased with the concoction on tap Friday, he said, “Yes, but it’s different again,” adding that the flavors of coriander were stronger in this batch than in others he’d made.

Poole’s Belgian Witbier has a “hallucinating haze due to the high level of unfiltered, protein rich wheat,” according to the description of his brew on the Make the Cut website. “Balanced by coriander and sweet orange peel then rounded out with generous carbonation, this easy drinking beer is perfect after a day of hiking, running or just relaxing,” the description continued.

Poole’s competitor is Brett Seymour, of Warren, Vt. who brewed a darker Schwarzbier. Seymour is a member of the Green Mountain Mashers, a homebrew club based in the Burlington area, and has been brewing beer at home for about seven years. “In a beer scene that is currently dominated by hops, Brett’s Schwarzbier proves that the right combination of malts can be just as interesting as the right combination of hops,” stated his description on the Make the Cut site. “This traditional, easy drinking, German style dark lager, is the perfect introduction to dark beers.”

Both finalist brews will be on tap at the six participating locations starting May 29 until they run out. The Worthy Kitchen expected it’s “two logs” (approximately 10 gallons) to be kicked by Tuesday, proving that both brews are indeed passing the test of commercial viability!

The winner of the Make The Cut Homebrew Challenge will be announced the week of the Vermont Brewers Festival, which takes place July 17-18 at Burlington Waterfront Park. The winner will pour their winning brew for the crowd as well as receive $1,000 from The Beverage Warehouse and be invited to brew production sized batches of their winning beer at 14th Star Brewing Company. The winner will maintain the rights to their recipe.

For more information visit makethecut.14thstarbrewing.com.

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Pride in Rutland: Flags, resistance, and showing up

June 25, 2025
By Emily Pratt Slatin Pride returned to downtown Rutland this June with more color, noise, and purpose than ever before. What began as a joyful celebration quickly became something deeper—something that felt like resistance. And belonging. And a promise that no one in this community has to stand alone. The day kicked off with the…

Plan to manage 72,000 acres of the Telephone Gap project is finalized

June 25, 2025
Staff report The U.S. Forest Service issued its final plan for managing 72,000 acres of public and private land on June 16. The proposed Telephone Gap Integrated Resource Project area is located on the Green Mountain National Forest (GMNF) within the towns of Brandon, Chittenden, Goshen, Killington, Mendon, Pittsfield, Pittsford, and Stockbridge. “The Telephone Gap project is…

Hot air balloons took flight over Quechee

June 25, 2025
By James Kent This past weekend, June 21-22, people came from all over New England to participate in the 45th annual Hot Air Balloon Festival. Music, food, games, and fun were available for all ages throughout the weekend, but the main attraction was the hot air balloons. And for those looking to see these gigantic,…

Killington residents push for skate park as town reimagines recreation future 

June 25, 2025
By Greta Solsaa/VTDigger As Killington celebrates the 50th anniversary of its recreation center, some residents are pushing to make a skate park a new permanent fixture of the town’s summer offerings.  The town crafted its recreation master plan to holistically determine how to best use its resources to serve residents in the future, Recreation Department Director Emily Hudson…