On January 7, 2015

Rutland County parent awarded $147,500 to settle free speech case

By VTDigger staff

A Rutland County parent who was barred from attending school board meetings has received a $147,500 settlement from the Addison-Rutland Supervisory Union.

Marcel Cyr, who with his wife, Valerie Cyr, had been critical of the quality of the education their child received at Benson Village School, was issued a no-trespass order and told that he could be arrested if he came onto district property.

A federal court in September ruled that the district violated Cyr’s rights by barring his participation in board meetings without explanation and without recourse.

The settlement was reached through mediation, according to a news release from the Vermont chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union, which helped to represent Cyr in the case. The Vermont ACLU contended that the board’s ban infringed upon Cyr’s due process and free speech rights.

“The message to government agencies is simple: you can’t treat the interested public like trespassers,” ACLU of Vermont executive director Allen Gilbert said in a news release Monday, Jan. 5. “The federal court has ruled that doing so violates the constitution, and now, the supervisory union has paid for infringing on a concerned parent’s rights.”

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Zuckerman urges support for ranked choice voting during Ludlow Rotary talk

April 16, 2025
LUDLOW—Former Vermont Lieutenant Governor David Zuckerman recently addressed the Ludlow Rotary Club, making a case for ranked-choice voting in elections with multiple candidates. He argued that allowing voters to rank their choices rather than select just one could foster broader participation and more open dialogue among candidates. “Ranked choice voting gives voters more voice and…

David Steven Hodulik, 69

April 16, 2025
David Steven Hodulik of Ship Bottom, New Jersey, died on March 12. Hodulik was the first child of George and Dorothy Hodulik, born prematurely on April 2, 1955. His life was miraculous, as he received baptism and Last Rights at birth and was expected to live only days. He grew up in Dunellen, New Jersey,…

Jon Lamb, 63

April 16, 2025
From Jon Lamb’s daughters It is with heavy hearts that we share the passing of our father, Jon Lamb, on April 2. Jon left this world with his ski boots on, doing what he loved most in the beautiful resort town of Big Sky, Montana. His family will remember him as a man passionate for…

Deborah Lee (Hyde) Colby, 75

April 16, 2025
Deborah Lee (Hyde) Colby passed away on Sunday, March 30, at Jack Byrne Center for Palliative & Hospice Care in Lebanon, New Hampshire. She was born on April 8, 1949, in Long Beach, California, the daughter of Harley and Lee Hyde. Deborah was the beloved wife of Scott Colby, with whom she shared over four…