On February 26, 2020

The electoral college and other quirks of U.S. voting

By Christopher Ross, Addison Independent

To get a sense of why the Electoral College is criticized so heavily these days, one need only consider that Republican Donald Trump was elected president in 2016 despite losing the popular vote by 2,868,686 ballots.

In other words, the Electoral College system had the equivalent effect of erasing every vote cast for Democrat Hillary Clinton in Vermont plus 12 other small states, plus one congressional district of a 13th, plus the District of Columbia.

Many predict that this November’s presidential election will produce a similar result.

“Much more likely (than Trump winning the popular vote) would be the same outcome as in 2016 — Trump losing the popular vote to the Democratic candidate, but winning enough electoral votes to be re-elected,” wrote Eric L. Davis, professor emeritus of political science at Middlebury College, in the Addison Independent this past April.

If this comes to pass, it would be the third time in the last six presidential elections that a Republican candidate was elected despite losing the popular vote.

So what is this Electoral College, exactly, where did it come from and why do we still have it?

These were among several questions that retired history teacher Jeff Johnson attempted to answer on Thursday, Feb. 13, in a talk called “History Matters: The Evolution of the Presidential Election Process,” which he gave at the Bristol Firehouse.

Johnson has offered courses on the election process every 4 years since 2008. Now retired and living in Castleton, he gives monthly history talks at Eastview.

Johnson divided “History Matters,” into three subtopics:

The roots of the Electoral College system.

Historical forces that have dramatically altered the original concepts behind the Electoral College.

Reasons the Electoral College is so unpopular today and movements to abolish or reform it.

Watch it at bit.ly/JeffJohnsonHistory

Do you want to submit feedback to the editor?

Send Us An Email!

Related Posts

Vermont State University’s Construction Management Program gains industry recognition, addresses workforce shortages

February 12, 2025
Vermont State University’s (VTSU) Construction Management program is making strides in addressing Vermont’s skilled labor shortage while achieving national recognition with a new accreditation. The program, which prepares students for high-demand careers in construction, has earned accreditation from the Applied and Natural Sciences Accreditation Commission of ABET, affirming its commitment to excellence in industry-recognized education.…

Phil Scott outlines proposal for making it ‘faster, easier and less expensive’ to build housing 

February 12, 2025
By Carly Berlin/VTDigger Editor’s note: This story, by Report for America corps member Carly Berlin, was produced through a partnership between VTDigger and Vermont Public. During the first days of his fifth term in office, Gov. Phil Scott emphasized a familiar priority: create more housing across Vermont. At a press conference at the Statehouse Jan. 21, members of…

Message delivered

February 12, 2025
Late last week, House Republicans banded together to vote against the annual midyear Budget Adjustment Act. The BAA, often a noncontroversial shifting of state funds between various accounts to address changes in budget actuals, included several policy issues that proved problematic for Republicans. Extending the winter rules for Vermont’s hotel assistance program to June 30…

Legislative update: looking ahead

February 12, 2025
Many of you have been in touch about the unprecedented actions being taken by our new President and those he has deputized. In addition to the scores of emails I’ve had from constituents, Montpelier was the focus of a huge demonstration on Wednesday, Feb. 5, protesting the actions taken by the Trump Administration targeting USAID,…